|Terbutaline versus salbutamol for suppression of preterm labor: a randomized clinical trial.|
|Jump to Full Text|
|PMID: 20697169 Owner: NLM Status: MEDLINE|
|BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Preterm labor (PTL) is a common medical problem during pregnancies and is associated with neonatal mortality and morbidity. Beta-adrenergic agonists are among the most commonly used tocolytic agents. The aim of this study was to compare the effectiveness, safety and adverse effects of terbutaline with those of salbutamol in the prolongation of pregnancy beyond 48 hours and until 37 weeks of gestation.
PATIENTS AND METHODS: Two hundred women with PTL were randomly assigned to receive subcutaneous terbutaline (250 μg) or intravenous salbutamol (0.1 mg) followed by oral terbutaline (20 mg/d) or oral salbutamol (24 mg/d) as maintenance. The efficacy, side effects and complications after 48 hours and until 37 weeks of gestation were analyzed and compared.
RESULTS: There was no significant difference between the two groups in success rate within 48 hours (P= .091). Gestational age at delivery (P=.031) and the number of days for which the gestation was prolonged (P=.024) were significantly higher in those receiving terbutaline. Adverse effects, including tachycardia (P=.007) and anxiety (P=.006), were experienced more in the salbutamol group. Birth weight was significantly lower in the salbutamol group (P=.001).
CONCLUSION: Terbutaline provided more effective tocolysis with fewer adverse effects and a better neonatal outcome. However, terbutaline and salbutamol are equally effective in the first 48 hours.
|Shahdokht Motazedian; Fariborz Ghaffarpasand; Khatereh Mojtahedi; Nasrin Asadi|
Related Documents :
|16969009 - The effectiveness of adrenocorticotropin repeated doses in high risk pregnancies.
18834339 - Comparison of biochemical markers and cervical length for predicting preterm delivery.
18978109 - First-trimester maternal serum a disintegrin and metalloprotease 12 (adam12) and advers...
16360489 - High-order multiple gestations.
7900509 - Antibodies to ureaplasma urealyticum in women with intraamniotic infection and adverse ...
23420029 - Placental protein 13 (pp13): a new biological target shifting individualized risk asses...
1759549 - Zygosity, placental membranes and weinberg's rule in a danish consecutive twin series.
11704199 - Idiopathic osteonecrosis of the hip during pregnancy: outcome in a subsequent gestation.
14687739 - Effect of electromagnetic field emitted by cellular phones on fetal heart rate patterns.
|Type: Comparative Study; Journal Article; Randomized Controlled Trial|
|Title: Annals of Saudi medicine Volume: 30 ISSN: 0975-4466 ISO Abbreviation: Ann Saudi Med Publication Date: 2010 Sep-Oct|
|Created Date: 2010-09-13 Completed Date: 2010-12-07 Revised Date: 2013-05-29|
Medline Journal Info:
|Nlm Unique ID: 8507355 Medline TA: Ann Saudi Med Country: Saudi Arabia|
|Languages: eng Pagination: 370-5 Citation Subset: IM|
|Fasa University of Medical Sciences, Fasa, Iran.|
|APA/MLA Format Download EndNote Download BibTex|
Adrenergic beta-2 Receptor Agonists / adverse effects, therapeutic use*
Albuterol / adverse effects, therapeutic use*
Obstetric Labor, Premature / drug therapy*
Terbutaline / adverse effects, therapeutic use*
Tocolytic Agents / adverse effects, therapeutic use*
|0/Adrenergic beta-2 Receptor Agonists; 0/Tocolytic Agents; 18559-94-9/Albuterol; 23031-25-6/Terbutaline|
Journal ID (nlm-ta): Ann Saudi Med
Journal ID (publisher-id): ASM
Publisher: Medknow Publications, India
© Annals of Saudi Medicine
Received Month: 12 Year: 2009
Accepted Month: 4 Year: 2010
Print publication date: Season: Sep–Oct Year: 2010
Volume: 30 Issue: 5
First Page: 370 Last Page: 375
Publisher Id: ASM-30-370
PubMed Id: 20697169
|Terbutaline versus salbutamol for suppression of preterm labor: a randomized clinical trial|
aDepartment of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran
bStudent Research Committee, Fasa University of Medical Sciences, Fasa, Iran
|Correspondence: Correspondence: Fariborz Ghaffarpasand, MD · #103, Biat Alley, Shuride Shirazi Street, Shiraz, PO Box: 7173646199, Fars, Iran · M: +00989173095214 F: +0098711643561 · firstname.lastname@example.org
Preterm labor (PTL) occurs in 5% to 10% of all pregnancies worldwide1 and is defined as labor occurring prior to 37 weeks of gestation. PTL is also the most common cause of neonatal mortality and morbidity, after congenital malformations. More than 10% of infants born before 28 weeks of gestation are severely handicapped. It has also been shown that severe neonatal morbidity, such as respiratory distress syndrome (RDS) and intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH), decreases with increasing gestational age.2 Newborns of less that 31-32 weeks gestation suffer more from neurological and sensorial deficiencies.3, 4
It is essential to suppress uterine contractions in patients with PTL (except in those with intrauterine infections and fetal distress) so as to postpone pregnancy until the fetus becomes mature enough. Until now many medications or interventions have been introduced for prolongation of pregnancies complicated with PTL. However, none have been found to be completely effective, and the choice of drug is often limited by adverse effects.5, 6 Beta-adrenergic agonists are among the most commonly used tocolytic agents. It has been shown that these agents postpone the delivery for 24, 48 hours and even 7 days. However, such a delay has not been associated with a significant reduction in either perinatal mortality or morbidity.7, 8
Postponement of pregnancy for at least 48 hours allows the corticosteroids to reach their maximum effect for reducing RDS and its sequelae, as well as IVH.9 Previous studies have shown that both subcutaneous terbutaline10–12 and intravenous salbutamol13–15 are effective tocolytic agents for patients with PTL. However, no study has compared the effects of these two agents until now. Accordingly, this study aimed to compare the effectiveness, safety and adverse effects of terbutaline with those of salbutamol in the prolongation of pregnancy until and beyond 48 hours.
This randomized clinical trial was performed at the labor ward of Zeinabieh Hospital, a tertiary care center affiliated with Shiraz University of Medical Sciences. We screened 287 patients with PTL, ranging in age from 17 to 32 years, between April 2009 and September 2009. The respective approvals of the review board and the ethics committee of the Shiraz University of Medical Sciences were obtained before proceeding with the study. The study protocol and its benefits and complications were explained to all participants, and all recruited patients completed and signed the ‘informed consent’ form.
All women who presented to the labor ward between 20 and 37 weeks of pregnancy (determined by the date of the last menstrual period when known or by early ultrasound) were assessed for enrollment into the study. Preterm labor was defined as the persistence of at least two symptomatic uterine contractions within a 10-minute period during the 60 minutes after admission and despite bed rest in the presence of cervical dilation between 0 and 3 cm for primigravida and between 1 and 3 cm for multigravida, with cervical effacement less than 50%. Women with cervix dilatation greater than 5 cm, polyhydramnios [amniotic fluid index (AFI) greater than 20 cm], oligohydramnios (AFI less than 10 cm), macrosomia (estimated fetal weight of 4 kg or more), suspected intrauterine infection (a temperature greater than 37.5°C) or growth restriction, major antepartum hemorrhage, rupture of membranes, major maternal medical disorders, diabetes mellitus, presence of a contraindication for vaginal delivery (e.g., major placenta previa), one previous cesarean delivery, multiple pregnancy, hypertension in pregnancy, blood pressure less than 90/50 mm Hg, previous history of abruption placenta, signs of fetal distress, lethal fetal anomaly and contraindication for the use of beta-sympathomimetic drugs and previous treatment with tocolytics in the present gestation were excluded from the trial.
After performing biochemical and hematological blood tests and an electrocardiogram, women were randomly assigned to two study groups using a computerized random number generator in a sequence of sealed, numbered opaque envelopes. There was a 1:1 randomization ratio. Women in the first group received subcutaneous terbutaline (Tehran Chimi Drug, Tehran, Iran) in a dosage of 250 μg (loading dose) followed by the same dose every 45 minutes if the uterine contractions persisted. Women in the second group received intravenous salbutamol (Tehran Chimi Drug, Tehran, Iran) in a dosage of 0.1 mg (bolus dose) followed by same boluses every 5 minutes until discontinuation of contractions. After stoppage of the uterine contractions, women in the first group received 20 mg/day oral terbutaline in 4 divided doses while women in the second group received 24 mg/day oral salbutamol in 4 divided doses as maintenance. All study personnel and participants were blinded to treatment assignment for the duration of the study. Only the study statisticians and the data monitoring committee saw unblinded data, but none had any contact with study participants.
Fetal heart rate and uterine contractions, as well as maternal blood pressure and pulse rate, were assessed every 12 hours. Prolongation of pregnancy for a period of 48 hours was the primary outcome in this study. The intervention was considered a failure in participants who delivered during the period, or still had contractions after 48 hours; and it was considered a success in participants whose contractions stopped for the full 48 hours. Patients whose contractions discontinued after 48 hours were discharged from the hospital with the maintenance therapy. If uterine contractions reappeared, relapse was diagnosed and treatment was repeated as indicated above. Medication was continued until 37 weeks of gestation. The participants were instructed to report in a daily diary the onset of any adverse experiences, specifying the severity, duration and a possible cause-effect relationship with drug administration. Neonatal weight, Apgar score, umbilical arterial and venous pH values and the presence of hyperbilirubinemia were determined after delivery. Neonatal complications such as hemorrhage or infections were also recorded. The secondary outcome of the study was the length of pregnancy and the side effects of each medication. Prolongation of gestation from admission to hospital to delivery and the number of preterm deliveries before 37 weeks (259 days) of gestation were also assessed.
Seventy-five patients were required in each group for the study to have 90% power to detect 10% difference between two groups regarding success rate (P=.05, 2-sided). To compensate for possible non-evaluable data, we enrolled 100 participants in each group. The statistical software package SPSS for Windows, version 15.0 (SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA), was used for data analysis. Paired t tests were used to compare results within groups; independent t tests were used to compare results between the groups; χ2 tests were used to compare proportions. Multivariate logistic regression analyses were carried out to control for the potentially confounding effect of important baseline factors. Data were reported as mean (standard deviation) for 95% confidence intervals. A 2-sided P value <.05 was considered statistically significant.
A total of 287 women were assessed for eligibility; 200 were eligible and were randomized into two study groups. All finished the study (Figure 1). None of the demographic and baseline parameters differed significantly between the two groups (Table 1). A 48-hour prolongation of pregnancy was achieved in 87 (87%) patients receiving terbutaline and 84 (84%) patients receiving salbutamol, which was not statistically significant (P=.091) (Table 2). There was also no difference in the delivery rate within 48 hours (P=.072). The patients in the salbutamol group experienced more complications (P<.001), including tachycardia (P=.007), palpitation (P=.002), anxiety (P=.006) and chills (P<.001).
Seven women in the terbutaline group and 9 in the salbutamol group discontinued maintenance medication due to complications (P=.048); thus, 81 and 75 women, respectively, were available for secondary analysis (Figure 1). Table 3 shows the secondary outcome and the pregnancy outcome in the two study groups. Gestational age at delivery was significantly higher in those receiving terbutaline (P=.031). Women receiving salbutamol experienced more relapses compared to those who received terbutaline (P=.001). Birth weight was significantly lower in those who received salbutamol as a tocolytic agent (P=.001). In the same way, the prevalence of low birth weight (<2500 g) was higher in the salbutamol group (P=.004). There was no significant difference between groups in Apgar score (P>.05) and perinatal mortality (P=.606). We performed a multivariate logistic regression analysis incorporating maternal age, gestational age, cervical dilatation, cervical effacement, contraction intervals, contraction duration and allocated treatment as independent covariables in the analysis, with gestational age at delivery and length of pregnancy (days) separately as dependent outcomes. After controlling for independent factors in both models for gestational age at delivery and length of pregnancy, terbutaline tocolysis remained significantly associated with increased gestational age at delivery and increased length of pregnancy.
In this study, we compared the efficacy, safety and adverse effects of terbutaline with those of salbutamol in suppression of PTL and maintaining a normal pregnancy until term delivery. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study comparing terbutaline and salbutamol for prolongation of pregnancy in patients with PTL. We found that there was no difference between these two beta-adrenergic agonists in the success rate and delivery rate within the first 48 hours. However, length of pregnancy was significantly higher in those who received terbutaline. Adverse drug effects were significantly greater in the salbutamol group. These findings show that terbutaline is more effective in suppressing PTL while prescribed as maintenance for the long term. It is also accompanied by fewer side effects and complications. Salbutamol was associated with an increased prevalence of low birth weight. However, there was no statistically significant difference in the Apgar scores or other complications. Terbutaline was safer and better tolerated and had a better pregnancy outcome.
Our findings are consistent with previous studies that have shown that terbutaline10–12 and salbutamol13–15 are effective tocolytic agents accompanied by side effects. These studies show that beta-adrenergic agonists are more effective compared to calcium channel blockers;10–12, 14 however, their significant side effects have limited use in practice. On the other hand, these agents do not decrease the neonatal mortality and morbidity associated with PTL. Thus, the popularity of these agents as first-line tocolytic agents has decreased.16, 17 Nevertheless, these agents are recommended as first-line tocolytic agents because of their efficacy.12, 14
Phupong et al13 studied the effect of oral salbutamol (32 mg/d) on prolongation of pregnancy in those with PTL. Of the 132 pregnancies, 81.1% were prolonged for more than 24 hours; 59.8%, for more than 2 days; 32.6%, for more than 1 week; and 8.3%, for more than 4 weeks. Tachycardia was the most common side effect, which was experienced by 85.6% of the individuals. Neonatal complications occurred in 28% of the babies, while respiratory distress syndrome occurred in 22.7% of the babies. The pregnancy outcome was significantly better in the group that had a prolongation time of at least 48 hours. In this study, we used both subcutaneous and intravenous boluses of terbutaline and salbutamol, respectively, for suppression of PTL within 48 hours and oral maintenance (20 mg/d for terbutaline and 25 mg/d for salbutamol until 37 weeks of gestation) for prevention of PTL. Tachycardia and chills were the most common side effects observed in those who received salbutamol. Our findings are consistent with those in the study by Phupong et al,13 which found that oral salbutamol is associated with severe side effects and poor pregnancy outcome.
Mawaldi et al10 compared the effects of subcutaneous terbutaline with those of oral nifedipine for prolongation of gestation. Terbutaline and nifedipine appeared to be equally effective in their tocolytic action. However, nifedipine did have the advantage of ease of administration. It also had significantly lesser effect on the fetal heart rate and was accompanied by lesser side effects. It was also shown by Vani et al15 that adjusted-dose intravenous salbutamol tocolysis prior to external cephalic version increases its success rate and reduces the cesarean delivery rate. Oral terbutaline was more effective in preventing PTL until 37 weeks of gestation, as demonstrated by a lesser number of relapses during this period.
The oral form of terbutaline and salbutamol was used as maintenance in this study because it does not require intensive medical nursing care and observations and is not associated with the discomfort of an intravenous line. The dosage used in this study is equivalent to that commonly used, intravenous salbutamol infusion dose of 6-30 μg/min, to inhibit preterm labor.18 Beta-adrenergic agonists increase the blood glucose levels by promoting glucagon release, gluconeogenesis and insulin resistance.19 Although none of our patients developed increased blood glucose, it must be kept in mind that women with diabetes were excluded from the study. This effect may therefore be of concern in diabetic women.
In conclusion, the results of this study demonstrate that terbutaline and salbutamol appeared to be equally effective tocolytic agents within 48 hours. However, oral terbutaline was more effective in preventing PTL until 37 weeks of gestation and was accompanied by fewer side effects and a better neonatal outcome. These findings make terbutaline the drug of choice for prolongation of pregnancy in those women with PTL.
|1.||World Health OrganizationInternational Classification of DiseasesYear: 1994Vol. 2Geneva, SwitzerlandWHO|
|2.||Robertson PA,Sniderman SH,Laros RK,Cowan R,Hilbron D,Goldenberg RL,et al. Neonatal morbidity according to gestational age and birth weight from five tertiary care centers in the United States, 1983 through 1986Am J Obstet GynecolYear: 19921661629411615970|
|3.||McCormick MC. The contribution of low birth weight to infant mortality and childhood morbidityN Engl J MedYear: 198531282903880598|
|4.||Woods NS,Marlow M,Costeloe K,Gibson AT,Wilkinson AR. Neurologic and developmental disability after extremely preterm birth: EPICure Study GroupN Engl J MedYear: 20003433788410933736|
|5.||Royal College of Obstetrics and GynecologyClinical Green Top guidelines: tocolytic drugs for women in preterm labour (1B)Year: 2002London UKRCOG|
|6.||Groome LJ,Goldenberg RL,Cliver SP,Davis RO,Copper RL. Neonatal periventricular-intraventricular hemorrhage after maternal beta-sympathominmetic tocolysis: The March of Dimes Multicenter Study GroupAm J Obstet GynecolYear: 199216787391415418|
|7.||Treatment of preterm labor with the beta-adrenergic antagonist ritodrine: The Canadian Preterm Labor Investigators GroupN Engl J MedYear: 1992327308121620169|
|8.||Gyetvai K,Hannah ME,Hodnett ED,Ohlsson A. Tocolytics for preterm labor: A systematic reviewObstet GynecolYear: 1999948697710546776|
|9.||Rodts-Palenik S,Morrison JC. Tocolysis: An update for the practitionerObstet Gynecol SurvYear: 200257S93412000859|
|10.||Mawaldi L,Duminy P,Tamim H. Terbutaline versus nifedipine for prolongation of pregnancy in patients with preterm laborInt J Gynaecol ObstetYear: 200810065817894937|
|11.||Collaris R,Tan PC. Oral nifepidine versus subcutaneous terbutaline tocolysis for external cephalic version: A double-blind randomised trialBJOGYear: 2009116748019087079|
|12.||Mohamed Ismail NA,Ibrahim M,Mohd Naim N,Mahdy ZA,Jamil MA,Mohd Razi ZR. Nifedipine versus terbutaline for tocolysis in external cephalic versionInt J Gynaecol ObstetYear: 2008102263618554601|
|13.||Phupong V,Charakorn C,Charoenvidhya D. Oral salbutamol for treatment of preterm laborJ Med Assoc ThaiYear: 2004871012615515999|
|14.||Trabelsi K,Hadj Taib H,Amouri H,Abdennadheur W,Ben Amar H,Kallel W,et al. Nicardipine versus salbutamol in the treatment of premature labor: Comparison of their efficacy and side effectsTunis MedYear: 20088643819472699|
|15.||Vani S,Lau SY,Lim BK,Omar SZ,Tan PC. Intravenous salbutamol for external cephalic versionInt J Gynaecol ObstetYear: 2009104283118922525|
|16.||Impey L,Pandit M. Tocolysis for repeat external cephalic version in breech presentation at term: A randomised, doubleblinded, placebo-controlled trialBJOGYear: 20051126273115842288|
|17.||Schutte JM,Steegers EA,Santema JG,Schuitemaker NW,van Roosmalen J. Maternal Mortality Committee Of The Netherlands Society Of Obstetrics. Maternal deaths after elective cesarean section for breech presentation in the NetherlandsActa Obstet Gynecol ScandYear: 200786240317364290|
|18.||Haukkamaa M,Gummerus M,Kleimola T. Serum salbutamol concentrations during oral and intravenous treatment in pregnant womenBr J Obstet GynaecolYear: 198592123034084465|
|19.||Leveno KJ,Cunningham FG. Beta-adrenergic agonists for preterm laborN Engl J MedYear: 1992327349511352375|
[Figure ID: F0001]
Flowchart of the study.
Baseline characteristics of the two study groups.
|Characteristic||Terbutaline group (n=100)||Salbutamol group (n=1oo)||pa|
|Maternal age (years)||22.3 (8.83)||23.2 (5.75)||.098|
|Gestational age (weeks)||30.4 (3.16)||31.1 (5.43)||.086|
|Cervical dilatation (cm)||1.56 (0.47)||1.48 (0.51)||.224|
|Cervical effacement (%)||40.6 (32.1)||39.8 (29.3)||.064|
|Contractions interval (minutes)||4.63 (0.62)||4.23(1.13)||.155|
|Contractions duration (seconds)||35.6 (4.48)||34.8 (5.12)||.092|
Values are mean (standard deviation
aIndependent sample t test
Outcome in women with preterm labor after 48 hours.
|Characteristic||Terbutaline group (n=100)||Salbutamol group (n=100)||p|
|Prolongation within 48 hours (n,%)||87 (87)||84 (84)||.091a|
|Delivery within 48 hours (n, %)||5 (5)||8 (8)||.072a|
|Duration of admission (days)||3.2 (1.4)||4.0 (1.4)||.096b|
|Side effects (n, %)||41 (41)||76 (76)||<.001a|
|Tachycardia (n, %)||20 (20)||42 (42)||.007a|
|Dyspnea (n, %)||5 (5)||12 (12)||.066a|
|Nausea (n, %)||19 (19)||29 (29)||.058a|
|Palpitation (n, %)||9 (9)||31 (31)||.002a|
|Anxiety (n, %)||15 (15)||31 (31)||.006a|
|Chills (n, %)||28 (28)||58 (58)||<.001a|
|Edema (n, %)||3 (3)||4 (4)||.161a|
Values are mean (standard deviation) or number (percent)
blndependent sample t test
Outcome in women with preterm labor after 37 weeks of gestation.
|Characteristic||Terbutaline group (n=81)||Salbutamol group (n=75)||p|
|Gestational age at delivery (weeks)||38.9 (1.5)||37.1 (1.8)||.031a|
|Prolongation of gestation (days)||59.5 (12.6)||42.3 (11.3)||.024a|
|Number of PTL relapses (%)||26 (32.1%)||49 (65.3%)||.001b|
|Discontinuing due to complications (%)||7 (8.6%)||9 (12%)||.048b|
|Cesarean delivery (%)||11 (13.6%)||10 (13.3%)||.784b|
|Birth weight (g)||3281 (382.23)||3011 (508.7)||.001a|
|Low birth weight (%)||6 (7.4%)||10 (13.3%)||.004b|
|Apgar score in 1 min||8.39 (0.8)||8.38 (0.8)||.266a|
|Apgar score in 5 min||9.29 (0.3)||9.14 (0.2)||.097a|
|Live births (%)||79 (97.5%)||74 (98.6%)||.171b|
|Perinatal mortality (%)||2 (2.5%)||1 (1.4%)||.606b|
|Respiratory distress syndrome (%)||1 (1.2%)||3 (4%)||.275b|
|Neonatal sepsis (%)||1 (1.2%)||0 (0%)||.334b|
Values are mean (standard deviation) or number (percent).
aIndependent sample t test
Previous Document: Diagnosis: Kartagener syndrome.
Next Document: The first national public breast cancer screening program in Saudi Arabia.