Document Detail

Insight to neoplastic thyroid lesions by fine needle aspiration cytology.
Jump to Full Text
MedLine Citation:
PMID:  23661936     Owner:  NLM     Status:  PubMed-not-MEDLINE    
BACKGROUND: Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is a valuable adjunct to pre-operative screening in the diagnosis of thyroid nodules, and in most cases, it can distinguish between benign and malignant lesions.
AIM: To study the cytology of neoplastic thyroid lesions to minimize surgical intervention and for confirmation of the diagnosis by histopathological study.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: 100 cases of thyroid FNAC smears were analyzed and cyto-histopathological correlation was done in 47 cases. Galen and Gambino's method was used to calculate the sensitivity and positive predictive value.
RESULTS: Of the 100 cases, 90 were diagnosed as neoplastic lesions by FNAC and ten cases as non-neoplastic lesions, which turned out to be neoplasms on histopathological study. Among 100 cases, 47 were biopsied and subjected to histopathological study. The sensitivity of FNAC was 75.60%, and positive predictive value was 83.78% for malignant lesions.
CONCLUSIONS: FNAC is a rapid, efficient, cost-effective, relatively painless procedure with a high diagnostic accuracy. It has high rate of sensitivity and positive predictive value in diagnosing thyroid neoplastic lesions. Hence, it is a valuable tool in the diagnosis and management of patients.
M Rangaswamy; Kl Narendra; S Patel; C Gururajprasad; Gv Manjunath
Related Documents :
19454006 - Non-o1 vibrio cholerae inguinal skin and soft tissue infection with bullous skin lesion...
24438036 - Aggressive epidermotropic cutaneous cd8+ lymphoma: a cutaneous lymphoma with distinct c...
25083396 - Rare presentation of metastatic prostate adenocarcinoma as a meningioma mimic.
25082566 - Polymerase chain reaction¿based assays for the diagnosis of human brucellosis.
8592236 - Posttraumatic intradiploic meningoencephalocele. case report.
8206416 - Ovarian carcinoma presenting as intra-abdominal hemorrhage.
Publication Detail:
Type:  Journal Article    
Journal Detail:
Title:  Journal of cytology / Indian Academy of Cytologists     Volume:  30     ISSN:  0970-9371     ISO Abbreviation:  J Cytol     Publication Date:  2013 Jan 
Date Detail:
Created Date:  2013-05-10     Completed Date:  2013-05-13     Revised Date:  2013-05-13    
Medline Journal Info:
Nlm Unique ID:  8915204     Medline TA:  J Cytol     Country:  India    
Other Details:
Languages:  eng     Pagination:  23-6     Citation Subset:  -    
Department of Pathology, JSS Medical College and Hospital, JSS University, Mysore, Karnataka, India.
Export Citation:
APA/MLA Format     Download EndNote     Download BibTex
MeSH Terms

From MEDLINE®/PubMed®, a database of the U.S. National Library of Medicine

Full Text
Journal Information
Journal ID (nlm-ta): J Cytol
Journal ID (iso-abbrev): J Cytol
Journal ID (publisher-id): JCytol
ISSN: 0970-9371
ISSN: 0974-5165
Publisher: Medknow Publications & Media Pvt Ltd, India
Article Information
Copyright: © Journal of Cytology
Print publication date: Season: Jan-Mar Year: 2013
Volume: 30 Issue: 1
First Page: 23 Last Page: 26
PubMed Id: 23661936
ID: 3643357
Publisher Id: JCytol-30-23
DOI: 10.4103/0970-9371.107508

Insight to neoplastic thyroid lesions by fine needle aspiration cytology
M Rangaswamyaff1
KL Narendraaff1
S Patelaff1
C Gururajprasadaff1
GV Manjunathaff1
Department of Pathology, JSS Medical College and Hospital, JSS University, Mysore, Karnataka, India
Correspondence: Address for correspondence: Dr. M. Rangaswamy, ‘sreeranga’, 24/B, Chamundi Vihar Layout, Nazarbad, Mysore, Karnataka, India. E-mail:


Thyroid is a frequent site of disease in human body. Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is a simple, safe, rapid, cost-effective diagnostic method and is a valuable adjunct to pre-operative screening in the diagnosis of thyroid lesions and a valuable tool in the management of patients.[1, 2] Lymphoma and undifferentiated carcinoma of thyroid can be treated with radiation or chemotherapy and do not need surgery. This study was undertaken to appreciate the cytology of neoplastic thyroid lesions to improve the diagnostic accuracy, to minimize surgical intervention, and for confirmation of the diagnosis by histopathology

Materials and Methods

FNAC of hundred cases of a suspected neoplastic thyroid were performed using 23-gauge needle by the non-aspiration technique. Ultrasound-guided FNACs were performed wherever necessary. In cases of cystic lesions, fluid was completely aspirated and was centrifuged. Subsequently sedimented material was examined. Re-aspiration was done in such cases. Slides were studied after staining with hematoxylin-eosin, Papanicolaou and May-Grünwald-Giemsa (MGG) stain. Cyto-histopathological correlation was done in 47 cases.

Inclusion criteria

Cases, which were diagnosed as neoplastic by cytology.

Those cases diagnosed as non-neoplastic by FNAC but turned out to be neoplastic by histopathology.

Exclusion criteria

Those cases, which were diagnosed as non-neoplastic lesions cytologically.

Cases with inadequate material for interpretation.

Statistical analysis

Galen and Gambino's method was used to calculate the sensitivity and positive predictive value.


The present study was conducted prospectively from July 2008 to June 2010. During this period, 585 cases of thyroid FNACs were done. Hundred cases were diagnosed to have neoplastic lesions by FNAC, and histopathologic correlation was possible in 47 cases. Age ranged from 11-70 years, median age was 40.57 years, and majority of cases were clustered in third decade. Females [75 cases (75%)] were predominantly affected with male to female ratio of 1:3.

Majority of cases presented with solitary nodule while few cases presented with diffuse or nodular swelling. A few had difficulty during swallowing or breathing and change of voice. All the patients tolerated the procedure well without any complications. The aspirate was satisfactory for interpretation in majority. It was blood mixed to frankly hemorrhagic and in some cases, either brown or dark brown fluid was aspirated, ranging from 1 to 8 mL.

In our study, 100 suspected neoplastic cases were analyzed, and 90 cases were reported as neoplastic. Ten cases, diagnosed as non-neoplastic cytologically, turned out to be malignant by histopathology. Neoplastic lesions diagnosed cytologically were 56 cases of follicular neoplasm, 29 cases of papillary carcinoma, 2 cases of medullary carcinoma, 2 cases of anaplastic carcinoma, and 1 case of metastatic carcinoma.

Cytological diagnosis of follicular neoplasm [56 cases] included a single case of Hurthle cell adenoma [Figure 1]. Histopathological correlation was done in 21 cases with a diagnostic accuracy of 76.19%. Six cases proved to be wrong, which included colloid goiter [4 cases], follicular variant of papillary carcinoma [1 case], and follicular carcinoma [1 case].

Twenty-nine cases of papillary carcinoma were diagnosed by FNAC, of which 2 had metastatic cervical lymphadenopathy. Histopathology was done in 15 cases, and diagnosis was confirmed in 14 cases, which included 3 cases of follicular variant with diagnostic accuracy of 93.33%. One case was diagnosed as colloid goiter with papillary hyperplasia.

Two cases of medullary carcinoma were diagnosed by FNAC in a 63-yr-old male and 51-yr-old female, but histopathological correlation was not possible [Figure 2]. FNAC diagnosis of spindle cell variant of anaplastic carcinoma was offered in two elderly female patients. However, histopathological correlation was not available.

Single case of metastatic carcinoma was diagnosed cytologically in a 65-yr-old female with past history of surgery for renal cell carcinoma ten years back. This was confirmed histopathologically.

Non-neoplastic by FNAC but neoplastic by histopathology

Out of 100 cases, ten cases were non-neoplastic lesions by cytology, but were neoplasms on histopathology. Nine cases were diagnosed as colloid/adenomatoid goiter by cytology, out of which six cases were follicular adenoma, two were follicular variant of papillary carcinoma, and one was a case of papillary carcinoma. Lastly, single case was diagnosed as lymphocytic thyroiditis on cytology, but turned out to be papillary carcinoma by histopathology [Table 1].

Present study showed a sensitivity of 75.60% and a positive predictive value of 83.78% by Galen and Gambino's method. As benign lesions were not taken in the study, no true negatives were considered, and hence other statistical parameters like specificity, negative predictive value and efficacy could not be deduced.


FNACs were done in 100 patients followed by excision biopsy in 47 cases. Age distribution and median age was comparable to Hawkins et al.[1] In the present study, median age was lower when compared to Pandit et al.[2] Majority were females [75%], and males were 25%. Sex distribution was similar to studies done by Bagga et al,[3] but female patients were less compared to studies of Hawkins et al.[1] Pandit et al.[2] Since thyroid is a highly vascular organ, non-aspiration technique was used without any complications.[46] We felt 5-6 groups of well preserved cells with each group consisting of 10 or more cells was adequate material for reporting.

Follicular neoplasm

Follicular neoplasm was commonest neoplastic lesion encountered in our study. Histopathological confirmation was achieved in 15 cases and differed in 6 cases, which included 4 colloid goiter, 1 follicular variant of papillary carcinoma, and 1 follicular carcinoma. The reason for misdiagnosis of four cases was high cellularity with predominant follicular pattern. Review of histopathology showed presence of nodular hyperplasia with focal crowding of epithelium, and aspiration was probably done from these hypercellular areas of colloid nodules. Suster et al,[7] Silverman et al,[8] Hall et al.[9] and Bommanahalli et al,[10] had similar observations in their study.

One case of follicular variant of papillary carcinoma was misdiagnosed as follicular neoplasm because of high cellularity, predominant follicular pattern and nuclear overlapping. Focal nuclear features like grooving were ignored in view of predominant follicular pattern. Diagnosis of this tumor by FNAC and frozen section is notoriously difficult and unreliable. A possible remedy is multiple aspirations from different sites, and many feel that nuclear features in more than 20 cells have a greater risk of papillary carcinoma, and typical nuclear features are always helpful.[8, 9]

Misdiagnosis of follicular carcinoma as adenoma was because of high cellularity with follicular pattern and mild anisonucleosis. In well-differentiated follicular carcinoma, cellular atypia will be minimal and hence favors a benign lesion as suggested by Koss et al.[11] They felt that nuclear enlargements were not helpful in differentiating follicular carcinoma from adenomas. Moreover, less well-differentiated follicular carcinomas do not show marked nuclear atypia, but large nucleoli will be helpful.

Papillary carcinoma

FNAC diagnosis was offered in 28 cases. Histopathological confirmation was available in 14 cases. One case was misdiagnosed as colloid goiter with papillary hyperplasia. Smears in this case were cellular, arranged in papillary pattern with indistinct nuclear features. Kini et al,[12] and Silverman et al,[7] had similar problems. Important features like intra-nuclear inclusions can be found in colloid goiter, medullary carcinoma and follicular adenoma.[13] Powdery nuclear chromatin, papillary fronds, intra-nuclear inclusions and nuclear grooves were common findings. Psammoma bodies are seen rarely.[14] Das et al,[15] suggested that “cystic papillary carcinoma” is a common cause for false negative reports in cytology. Problems in diagnosing papillary carcinoma include cystic change, marked lymphocytic infiltration, mixed patterns of growth, papillary adenoma, hyalinizing trabecular adenoma and calcified debris.[16] Small lesions of papillary carcinoma should be aspirated under imaging guidance.

Medullary carcinoma

Two cases of medullary carcinoma were diagnosed by FNAC and showed tumor cells having plasmacytoid appearance with moderately pleomorphic nuclei, granular cytoplasm and occasional binucleated forms. Amyloid was not seen in both the cases in our study. Cyto-morphological features correlated with studies of Hawkins et al.[1]

Anaplastic carcinoma

Two cases of anaplastic carcinoma were highly cellular with marked pleomorphism. Clusters of spindle-shaped tumor cells having hyperchromatic nuclei with mitotic figures and occasional binucleate forms favored our diagnosis of spindle cell variant of anaplastic carcinoma. Zeppa et al,[17] stated that diagnostic reliability is limited, because these cases can be associated with inflammation, necrosis and hemorrhage.

Metastatic carcinoma

We diagnosed a single metastatic case cytologically, and smears showed tumor cells in sheets and singles with abundant clear cytoplasm, round to oval dark nuclei. Diagnosis was confirmed by histopathology. Prognosis of metastatic renal cell carcinoma is better than other metastases.


FNAC of thyroid lesions is a safe, simple, cost-effective and accurate method for management of palpable thyroid lesions. Misdiagnosis was more with follicular neoplasms compared to other lesions. The scope and limitations of FNAC should be fully realized, especially in the interpretation of adenomatous goiter and follicular neoplasms. We stress the importance of nuclear features in the diagnosis of papillary carcinoma and follicular variant of papillary carcinoma.


Source of Support: Nil

Conflict of Interest: None declared.

1. Hawkins F,Bellido D,Bernal C,Rigopoulou D,Ruiz Valdepeñas MP,Lazaro E,et al. Fine needle aspiration biopsy in the diagnosis of thyroid cancer and thyroid diseaseCancerYear: 198759120693815295
2. Pandit AA,Kinare SG. Fine needle aspiration cytology of thyroidIndian J CancerYear: 1986235483817861
3. Bagga PK,Mahajan NC. Fine needle aspiration cytology of thyroid swellings: How useful and accurate is it?Indian J CancerYear: 2010474374221131759
4. Mair S,Dunbar F,Becker PJ,Du Plessis W. Fine needle aspiration cytology: Is aspiration suction necessary? A study of 100 masses in various sitesActa CytolYear: 198933809132488680
5. Santos JE,Leiman G. Nonaspiration fine needle cytology. Application of a new technique to nodular thyroid diseaseActa CytolYear: 19883235363376702
6. Maurya AK,Mehta A,Mani NS,Nijhawan VS,Batra R. Comparison of aspiration vs non-aspiration techniques in fine-needle cytology of thyroid lesionsJ CytolYear: 20102751421157549
7. Suster S. Thyroid tumors with a follicular growth pattern: problems in differential diagnosisArch Pathol Lab MedYear: 2006130984816831055
8. Silverman JF,West RL,Larkin EW,Park HK,Finley JL,Swanson MS,et al. The role of fine-needle aspiration biopsy in the rapid diagnosis and management of thyroid neoplasmCancerYear: 1986571164703943039
9. Hall TL,Layfield LJ,Philippe A,Rosenthal DL. Sources of diagnostic error in fine needle aspiration of the thyroidCancerYear: 198963718252914278
10. Bommanahalli BP,Bhat RV,Rupanarayan R. A cell pattern approach to interpretation of fine needle aspiration cytology of thyroid lesions: A cyto-histomorphological studyJ CytolYear: 2010271273221157563
11. Koss LG. On the history of cytologyActa CytolYear: 19802447577004037
12. Kini SR,Miller JM,Hamburger JI. Cytopathology of Hurthle cell lesions of the thyroid gland by fine needle aspirationActa CytolYear: 198125647526171979
13. Harach HR. Usefulness of fine needle aspiration of the thyroid in an endemic goiter regionActa CytolYear: 1989333152916369
14. Francis IM,Das DK,Sheikh ZA,Sharma PN,Gupta SK. Role of nuclear grooves in the diagnosis of papillary thyroid carcinoma. A quantitative assessment on fine needle aspiration smearsActa CytolYear: 199539409157539202
15. Das DK,Sharma PN. Diagnosis of papillary thyroid carcinoma in fine needle aspiration smears. Factors that effect decision makingActa CytolYear: 20095349750619798876
16. Hales MS,Hsu FS. Needle tract implantation of papillary carcinoma of the thyroid following aspiration biopsyActa CytolYear: 19903480142256415
17. Zeppa P,Benincasa G,Lucariello A,Palombini L. Association of different pathologic processes of the thyroid gland in the fine needle aspiration samplesActa CytolYear: 2001453475211393065


[Figure ID: F1]
Figure 1 

(a) Follicular neoplasm: Cellular smear with cells arranged in microfollicular pattern with anisokaryosis (MGG, ×200); (b) Follicular carcinoma: Tissue section showing vascular invasion (H and E, ×100); (c) Hurthle cell neoplasm: Cellular smear with sheets of oxyphilic cells having abundant granular cytoplasm and eccentrically placed nucleus (Pap, ×200); (d) Papillary carcinoma: Smear showing tumor cells with chewing gum colloid and psamomma body (H and E, ×200)

[Figure ID: F2]
Figure 2 

(a) Medullary carcinoma: Cellular smear showing poorly cohesive cells with a plasmacytoid appearance and moderate anisokaryosis. Occasional binucleate cells seen (Pap, ×400); (b) Anaplastic spindle cell carcinoma showing cluster of pleomorphic plump spindle cells with hyperchromatic nuclei (Pap, ×400); (c) Metastatic renal cell carcinoma: Sheets of clear cells having hyperchromatic nucleus (MGG, ×400); (d) Metastatic renal cell carcinoma in thyroid: Section showing a clear cell lesion with adjacent normal looking thyroid tissue (H and E, ×100)

[TableWrap ID: T1] Table 1 

Cyto-histopathological correlation of neoplastic and non-neoplastic lesions

Article Categories:
  • Original Article

Keywords: Cyto-histopathological correlation, fine needle aspiration cytology, thyroid lesions.

Previous Document:  Leishman Giemsa cocktail as a new, potentially useful cytological technique comparable to Papanicola...
Next Document:  Clinico-radiological and pathological evaluation of extra testicular scrotal lesions.