|Influence of a hairpin loop on the thermodynamic stability of a DNA oligomer.|
|Jump to Full Text|
|PMID: 21904665 Owner: NLM Status: In-Data-Review|
|DSC was used to evaluate the mechanism of the thermally induced unfolding of the single-stranded hairpin HP = 5'-CGGAATTCCGTCTCCGGAATTCCG-3' and its core duplex D (5'-CGGAATTCCG-3')(2). The DSC melting experiments performed at several salt concentrations were successfully described for HP and D in terms of a three-state transition model HP↔I (intermediate state) ↔ S (unfolded single-stranded state) and two state transition model D↔2S, respectively. Comparison of the model-based thermodynamic parameters obtained for each HP and D transition shows that in unfolding of HP only the HP↔I transition is affected by the TCTC loop. This observation suggests that in the intermediate state its TCTC loop part exhibits significantly more flexible structure than in the folded state while its duplex part remains pretty much unchanged.|
|Jurij Lah; Mojca Seručnik; Gorazd Vesnaver|
Related Documents :
|12877175 - State-of-the-art of gas chromatography-based methods for analysis of anthropogenic vola...
540585 - Review of the methods of quantification.
12805985 - Recent developments in the methods of estimating shooting distance.
24167635 - Coastal habitats as surrogates for taxonomic, functional and trophic structures of bent...
16942105 - Computational study of the structure and behavior of aqueous mixed system sodium unsatu...
24064785 - Changes in psychosocial work exposures among employees between 2005 and 2010 in 30 coun...
|Type: Journal Article Date: 2011-08-29|
|Title: Journal of nucleic acids Volume: 2011 ISSN: 2090-021X ISO Abbreviation: J Nucleic Acids Publication Date: 2011|
|Created Date: 2011-09-09 Completed Date: - Revised Date: -|
Medline Journal Info:
|Nlm Unique ID: 101533042 Medline TA: J Nucleic Acids Country: United States|
|Languages: eng Pagination: 513910 Citation Subset: -|
|Faculty of Chemistry and Chemical Technology, University of Ljubljana, Askerceva 5, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia.|
|APA/MLA Format Download EndNote Download BibTex|
Journal ID (nlm-ta): J Nucleic Acids
Journal ID (publisher-id): JNA
Publisher: SAGE-Hindawi Access to Research
Copyright © 2011 Jurij Lah et al.
Received Day: 13 Month: 4 Year: 2011
Accepted Day: 16 Month: 5 Year: 2011
Print publication date: Year: 2011
Electronic publication date: Day: 29 Month: 8 Year: 2011
Volume: 2011E-location ID: 513910
PubMed Id: 21904665
|Influence of a Hairpin Loop on the Thermodynamic Stability of a DNA Oligomer|
|Faculty of Chemistry and Chemical Technology, University of Ljubljana, Askerceva 5, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia
|Correspondence: *Jurij Lah: firstname.lastname@example.org and
Correspondence: *Gorazd Vesnaver: email@example.com
[other] Academic Editor: Luis A. Marky
Hairpin loops are a common form of nucleic acid secondary structure and are crucial for tertiary structure and function . They are known to play a key role in a number of biological processes such as gene expressions, DNA recombination, and DNA transposition [2–4]. In RNA molecules hairpins act as nucleation sites for RNA folding into final conformations [5–7] and play a critical role in RNA-protein recognition and gene regulation [8, 9]. Furthermore, due to the specificity of probe/target hybridization determined as a match-versus-mismatch discrimination, hairpin DNA oligomer probes have become an important tool in modern biotechnology and diagnostics [10, 11]. The thermodynamics and kinetics of hairpin formation, hairpin binding to complementary nucleic acids, and hairpin-ligand associations have been studied extensively [12–21]. There is no doubt that studies of hairpin-to-coil transitions and hairpin-ligand binding affinity and specificity have greatly enhanced our understanding of structural features and function of the naturally occurring nucleic acids [22, 23]. However, despite extensive biophysical research on the systems involving hairpin structures that produced a number of high-quality explanations and evaluations on properties and behavior of nucleic acids containing hairpin formations, there are still many unresolved questions.
As pointed out by Marky et al.  the most suitable hairpin molecules for studying the thermodynamics of their conformational transitions and ligand binding are the single-stranded hairpin molecules. They form stable partially paired duplexes that tend to melt in simple monomolecular transitions. Furthermore, their conformational stability and ligand binding properties are easily compared with those of the corresponding core duplexes. In this way one can evaluate the contributions of the loops to the thermal stability of the hairpins. Despite the simple structure of single-stranded hairpins it is not clear whether their monomolecular folding/unfolding transitions occur in a two-state or multistate manner. Measurements of their thermally induced unfolding transitions followed by UV, CD, and/or fluorescence spectroscopy as a rule result in sigmoidal melting curves suggesting that they may be considered as two-state processes. The same conclusion can be reached also on the basis of DSC measurements performed on the same sample solutions in the older generation of less sensitive DSC instruments (e.g., Microcal MC-2) which resulted in single-peak DSC thermograms. Recent measurements of conformational transitions of DNA quadruplex structures have shown, however, that the sigmoidal shape of UV or CD melting curves may be misleading. Namely, the DSC measurements performed on samples for which sigmoidal UV and CD melting curves were observed using the DSC of the latest generation (CSC, Microcal) resulted in thermograms containing two or three well-distinguished peaks thus indicating that the observed DNA melting process occurs in a multi-state manner [25, 26]. Furthermore, recent T-jump experiments performed on small hairpin molecules have produced a direct evidence that their unfolding transitions involve intermediate structures and thus cannot be considered as two-state processes [19, 27–29].
In our DSC study of the unfolding mechanism and stability of the 5′-CGGAATTCCGTCTCCGGAATTCCG-3′ hairpin we performed the DSC melting experiments on the hairpin and its core duplex, (5′-CGGAATTCCG-3′)2 (see Figure 1), at several salt concentrations using an extremely sensitive microcalorimeter (CSC). To see to what extent the TCTC loop affects the hairpin unfolding process we attempted to describe for each oligonucleotide the measured DSC thermograms in terms of the simplest possible unfolding model. We derived the corresponding model functions and by fitting them to the experimental data we tested the appropriateness of the suggested models and obtained for each transition the characteristic thermodynamic quantities of transition ΔG(T)0, ΔH(T)0, ΔS(T)0, and ΔcP0. By comparing these values determined for the hairpin and the core duplex we tried to estimate the contribution of the TCTC loop to the stability of the hairpin.
Self-complementary oligonucleotide 5′-CGGAATTCCG-3′ and oligonucleotide 5′-CGGAATTCCGTCTCCGGAATTCCG-3′ that in solution at room temperature form a duplex (D) and a single-stranded hairpin structure (HP), respectively, were purchased HPLC pure from Invitrogen Co., Germany and used without any further purification. Their concentrations in buffer solution (10 mM phosphate buffer and 1 mM Na2EDTA adjusted to pH = 7.0)) in the presence of 100 mM NaCl were determined at 25°C spectrophotometrically in the Cary Bio 100 UV-spectrophotometer. The molar extinction coefficients were determined using the nearest neighbor data of Cantor et al.  for single-stranded DNA at 25°C and the absorbance at 260 nm of thermally unfolded oligonucleotide extrapolated back to 25°C (εD260 = 84600 M−1cm−1, εHP260 = 216000 M−1cm−1). The phosphate buffer solutions used in all experiment contained 0, 0.1, 0.3, or 1.0 M NaCl.
Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). Thermally induced unfolding of duplex (D) and hairpin (H) in buffer solutions with different added NaCl concentrations was followed between 5 and 95°C in a Nano-II DSC calorimeter (CSC; UT) at the heating rate of 1°C/min and essentially the same results were obtained from several test-experiments performed at the heating rate of 0.25°C/min. The thermally induced unfolding of both oligonucleotides was monitored in terms of cPex=c̅p2-c̅pD,F versus T thermograms in which the differences between the partial molar heat capacity of the measured oligonucleotide c̅p2 (raw signals corrected for the solvent contributions) and the partial molar heat capacities of the corresponding folded states extrapolated from low temperatures over the whole measured temperature interval, c̅pD,F, are normalized for the duplex or hairpin concentration. The total enthalpy of unfolding, ΔH(T)cal ,was obtained from the measured thermograms as the area under the cPex(T) versus T curve.
The thermally induced conformational transitions can be experimentally followed in a model-independent way only by DSC. At relatively low concentrations used in DSC experiments the measured solute-normalized heat capacity of the sample solution, cP(T), with the subtracted baseline may be equalized with the oligonucleotide partial molar heat capacity, c̅P2(T). Thus, the overall heat effect that accompanies the measured conformational transition from its initial folded state at the temperature T1 to its final unfolded state at T2 can be expressed as
According to the DSC thermograms of the measured hairpin (HP), its thermally induced unfolding involves at least two conformational transitions (Figure 2). Thus, the simplest suggested model to describe the observed thermal behavior would consist of two consecutive monomolecular transitions: HP (hairpin) ↔ I (intermediate state) ↔ S (unfolded single-stranded state). The enthalpy, H, of a solution containing an HP sample characterized by the suggested thermal unfolding
|HP⟷KHPII⟷KISS; KHPI=[I][HP] KIS=[S][I]|
|cP,ex=c̅P,2− c̅P,HP=αIΔcP,HPI+dαIdTΔHHPI+αS(ΔcP,HPI+ΔcP,IS) +dαSdT(ΔHHPI+ΔHIS),|
cP,ex can be obtained experimentally simply by subtracting the hairpin c̅P,HP versus T curve extrapolated from low-T region over the entire measured temperature interval from the corresponding measured c̅P,2 versus T curve. The model-based cP,ex, however, can be calculated from the right-hand side term of (8). According to the suggested model (4) the total solute molar concentration, cT, and the fractions αi of the solute species present in the solution can be expressed as cT = [HP] + [I] + [S] and αHP = [HP]/cT, αI = [I]/cT and αS = [S]/cT. Since αHP + αI + αS = 1 one obtains from (4) that
|ΔGi(T)0=T[ΔGi(Ti,(1/2))0Ti,1/2+ΔHi(Ti,1/2)0(1T−1Ti,1/2) +ΔcPi0(1−Ti,1/2T−ln TTi,1/2)],|
|cP,ex= αIΔcp,HPI0+dαIdTΔHHPI0+αS(Δcp,HPI0+Δcp,IS0) +dαSdT(ΔHHPI0+ΔHIS0),|
In contrast to HP unfolding, the measured thermally induced duplex (D) to single strand (S) transition appears to be a simpler, all-or-none process
|cT=[D]+[S]2; αS=[D]cT; KDS=4αS2cT1−αS.|
Inspection of (18) and (19) shows that the model function (18) is expressed in terms of adjustable parameters, T1/2, ΔHDS(T1/2)0 and ΔcP,DS0 that can be determined by fitting the model function to the experimental cP,ex versus T curve and further used to determine the ΔGDS(T)0, ΔHDS(T)0 and ΔSDS(T)0 values at any T.
To obtain a set of the “best fit” adjustable parameters Ti,1/2, ΔHi(Ti,1/2)0 and ΔcP,i0 describing the hairpin and duplex thermal unfolding at each of the added salt concentrations the iterative nonlinear Levenberg-Marquardt χ2 regression procedure was used . Furthermore, assuming that for the observed transitions the accompanying ΔcP,i0 quantities do not depend on the added NaCl concentration their values may be determined also from the slopes of the ΔHi(T1/2)0 versus Ti,1/2 curves constructed from the “best fit” ΔHi(T1/2)0 and Ti,1/2 parameters determined at different added salt concentrations . These data can be also used to construct the corresponding Ti,1/2 versus ln [Na+] plots from which the amount of the Na+ ions released upon thermal unfolding of the hairpin or duplex structure can be estimated (see discussion, (20)).
According to the measured DSC thermograms presented in Figure 2 the thermally induced unfolding of the hairpin HP consists of at least two conformational transitions while the one observed for the duplex D occurs in a simpler “all or none” manner. In addition, UV melting experiments (not shown) resulted for HP in biphasic melting curves that exhibit transitions independent on HP concentration (monomolecular transitions) while for D monophasic melting curves dependent on D concentration (nonmonomolecular transition) were observed. Moreover, excellent repeatability of the consecutive measured heating and cooling cP versus T curves and the observed independence of the measured DSC peaks on the applied heating rate (several test experiments) clearly shows that the studied thermal unfolding events may be considered as reversible processes. Model analysis of the measured thermograms shows that the hairpin thermal unfolding can be well described in terms of a three state model involving H (hairpin) ⟷I (intermediate state) ⟷S (unfolded single-stranded structure) transitions and the corresponding model function (14) characterized for each of the suggested transitions with the corresponding “best fit” adjustable parameters Ti,1/2, ΔHi(Ti,1/2)0, and ΔcP,i0 (Table 1). However, analysis of the applied fitting procedure indicates that the parameter ΔcP,IS0 is highly correlated to some other adjustable parameters. Thus, to obtain safe estimate of ΔcP,IS0 another method of its determination has to be used. Assuming that it does not depend on the simple salt concentration ΔcP,IS0 was estimated as a slope of the ΔHIS(T1/2)0 versus TIS,1/2 plot (Figure 3(a)) constructed from the “best fit” parameters determined at different NaCl concentrations (Table 1). This method of determining ΔcP,i0 was justified by a good agreement between the ΔcP,i0 values for other transitions obtained by the described fitting procedure and the ΔcPi0 values determined as the slopes of the corresponding ΔHi(Ti,1/2)0 versus Ti,1/2 plots (Table 1). By using the parameters presented in Table 1 one can calculate for the duplex and hairpin solutions the relative populations of the model-predicted species in the measured temperature interval and at all added salt concentrations (Figure 2). Evidently, the thermal stability of the folded state of the measured duplex and the hairpin is substantially enhanced by increasing the added salt concentration. At low salt concentrations, however, a small fraction of the hairpin molecules undergoes transition into the intermediate state already at physiological temperatures.
A standard way of testing the quality of a suggested model is to compare the enthalpy of unfolding determined at a given temperature directly by an appropriate integration of the experimental cP,ex(T) versus T curve (ΔHHScal, see (3)) with the corresponding model-based value ΔHHS0 calculated at the same temperature using the reported “best fit” adjustable parameters. As shown in Table 1 a good agreement was obtained which clearly supports the appropriateness of the suggested H⟷I⟷ S unfolding model.
It is well known that DNA unfolding is accompanied by release of counterions. The number of the released Na+ ions, ΔnNa+,i, upon each HP and D transition, expressed per mole of oligonucleotide, may be estimated from 
|dTi,1/2dln [Na+]=RTi,1/22ΔHi(Ti,1/2)0 ΔnNa+,i,|
At any T in the measured range of physiological temperatures the difference between the given property characterizing the total unfolding of the hairpin H and the duplex D (for ex. ΔΔH(T)0 = ΔHHS(T)0 − ΔHDS(T)0) reflects the contribution of the TCTC loop to that property relative to the core duplex (Figure 4, Table 2). Thus, the observed ΔΔH(T)0 > 0 indicates a favorable energy contribution of the TCTC loop to the stability of the hairpin that results, very likely, from the increased number of stacking interactions (in the first place from those occurring at the core duplex-loop connections) . The corresponding ΔΔS(T)0 > 0 is consistent with the highly positive ΔΔH(T)0 indicating that the unfavorable entropy contribution of the TCTC loop to the hairpin stability arises largely from a substantial disruption of the loop structure accompanying the unfolding of the hairpin. The observed ΔΔcP0 > 0 and ΔΔnNa+ > 0 show, however, that the loop contributions to ΔΔH(T)0and ΔΔS(T)0 may be, to a certain extent, determined also by hydration  and electrostatic interactions. The ΔΔcP0 > 0 suggests that within the folded hairpin conformation, not only the core duplex but also the TCTC loop are less exposed to water than in the unfolded state. In addition, the observed ΔΔnNa+ > 0 may be ascribed to a decrease in the surface charge density accompanying the unfolding of the oligonucleotide which is significantly more pronounced in the case of hairpin unfolding. Comparison of the ΔΔ values for ΔGT0, ΔHT0, ΔST0, ΔcP0, and ΔnNa+ quantities determined for the HP → I and I → S transitions of the hairpin with the corresponding ΔΔ values determined for the D → 2S transition of the duplex shows that the ΔΔ values for the I → S and D → 2S transitions are very close (Figure 4, Table 2). Evidently, one may speculate that in the hairpin structure only the HP → I transition is influenced by the TCTC loop. In other words, it seems that the observed HP → I transition reflects mainly the changes in the TCTC conformation. Thus, the intermediate state I may be considered as a state in which the core duplex remains more or less unchanged while the TCTC loop occurs as a more flexible structure characterized by the additional stacking interactions and the freedom of the neighboring water molecules and ions similar to the one in the unfolded state.
To the best of our knowledge this is the first time that a three-state unfolding of a simple hairpin structure, observed by DSC, has been reported and characterized thermodynamically. We believe that the main reason for this is that in most studies of thermal unfolding of hairpins too high starting temperatures have been chosen and therefore the low-temperature transitions have been overlooked.
This paper was supported by the Slovenian Research Agency through Grant no. P1-0201 and by the COST action MP0802.
|1.||Brion P,Westhof E. Hierarchy and dynamics of RNA foldingAnnual Review of Biophysics and Biomolecular StructureYear: 199726113137|
|2.||Roth DB,Menetski JP,Nakajima PB,Bosma MJ,Gellert M. V(D)J recombination: broken DNA molecules with covalently sealed (hairpin) coding ends in scid mouse thymocytesCellYear: 19927069839911356077|
|3.||Bhasin A,Goryshin IY,Reznikoff WS. Hairpin formation in Tn5 transpositionJournal of Biological ChemistryYear: 199927452370213702910601258|
|4.||Kennedy AK,Guhathakurta A,Kleckner N,Haniford DB. Tn10 transposition via a DNA hairpin intermediateCellYear: 19989511251349778253|
|5.||Uhlenbeck OC. Nucleic-acid structure—tetraloops and RNA foldingNatureYear: 199034662856136141696683|
|6.||Cheong C,Varani G,Tinoco I. Solution structure of an unusually stable RNA heparin—GGAC(UUCG)GUCCNatureYear: 199034662856806821696688|
|7.||Heus HA,Pardi A. Structural features that give rise to the unusual stability of RNA hairpins containing GNRA loopsScienceYear: 199125350161911941712983|
|8.||Draper DE. Themes in RNA-protein recognitionJournal of Molecular BiologyYear: 1999293225527010550207|
|9.||Svoboda P,Di Cara A. Hairpin RNA: a secondary structure of primary importanceCellular and Molecular Life SciencesYear: 2006637-890191816568238|
|10.||Bonnet G,Tyagi S,Libchaber A,Kramer FR. Thermodynamic basis of the enhanced specificity of structured DNA probesProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of AmericaYear: 199996116171617610339560|
|11.||Kim Y,Sohn D,Tan W. Molecular beacons in biomedical detection and clinical diagnosisInternational Journal of Clinical and Experimental PathologyYear: 2008110511618784800|
|12.||Scheffler IE,Elson EL,Baldwin RL. Helix formation by d(TA) oligomers. II. Analysis of the helix-coil transitions of linear and circular oligomersJournal of Molecular BiologyYear: 19704811451715448587|
|13.||Gralla J,Crothers DM. Free energy of imperfect nucleic acid helices. II. Small Hairpin LoopsJournal of Molecular BiologyYear: 19737344975114715014|
|14.||Haasnoot CA,Hilbers CW,van der Marel GA,et al. On loop folding in nucleic acid hairpin-type structuresJournal of Biomolecular Structure & DynamicsYear: 1986358438572482747|
|15.||Senior MM,Jones RA,Breslauer KJ. Influence of loop residues on the relative stabilities of DNA hairpin structuresProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of AmericaYear: 19888517624262463413094|
|16.||Zuker M. On findings all suboptimal foldings of an RNA moleculeScienceYear: 1989244490048522468181|
|17.||Rentzeperis D,Alessi K,Marky LA. Thermodynamics of DNA hairpins: contribution of loop size to hairpin stability and ethidium bindingNucleic Acids ResearchYear: 19932111268326898332464|
|18.||Freyer MW,Buscaglia R,Nguyen B,David Wilson W,Lewis EA. Binding of netropsin and 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole to an A2T2 DNA hairpin: a comparison of biophysical techniquesAnalytical BiochemistryYear: 2006355225926616828700|
|19.||Kuznetsov SV,Ren CC,Woodson SA,Ansari A. Loop dependence of the stability and dynamics of nucleic acid hairpinsNucleic Acids ResearchYear: 20083641098111218096625|
|20.||Lah J,Drobnak I,Dolinar M,Vesnaver G. What drives the binding of minor groove-directed ligands to DNA hairpins?Nucleic Acids ResearchYear: 200836389790418086706|
|21.||Lah J,Carl N,Drobnak I,Šumiga B,Vesnaver G. Competition of some minor groove binders for a single DNA binding siteActa Chimica SlovenicaYear: 2006533284291|
|22.||Bevilacqua PC,Blose JM. Structures, kinetics, thermodynamics, and biological functions of RNA hairpinsAnnual Review of Physical ChemistryYear: 20085979103|
|23.||Bikard D,Loot C,Baharoglu Z,Mazel D. Folded DNA in action: hairpin formation and biological functions in prokaryotesMicrobiology and Molecular Biology ReviewsYear: 201074457058821119018|
|24.||Marky LA,Rentzeperis D,Ho J. Contribution of loops and nicks to the formation of DNA dumbbells: melting behavior and ligand bindingBiochemistryYear: 19933210256425728448114|
|25.||Prislan I,Lah J,Vesnaver G. Diverse polymorphism of G-quadruplexes as a kinetic phenomenonJournal of the American Chemical SocietyYear: 200813043141611416918826223|
|26.||Prislan I,Lah J,Milanic M,et al. Kinetically governed polymorphism of d(G4T4G3) quadruplexes in K+ solutionsNucleic Acids ResearchYear: 2011391933194221113023|
|27.||Ansari A,Kuznetsov SV,Shen Y. Configurational diffusion down a folding funnel describes the dynamics of DNA hairpinsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of AmericaYear: 200198147771777611438730|
|28.||Shen Y,Kuznetsov SV,Ansari A. Loop dependence of the dynamics of DNA hairpinsJournal of Physical Chemistry BYear: 2001105481220212211|
|29.||Ma H,Proctor DJ,Kierzek E,Kierzek R,Bevilacqua PC,Gruebele M. Exploring the energy landscape of a small RNA hairpinJournal of the American Chemical SocietyYear: 200612851523153016448122|
|30.||Cantor CR,Warshaw MM,Shapiro H. Oligonucleotide interactions. 3. Circular dichroism studies of the conformation of deoxyoligonucleotidesBiopolymersYear: 197099105910775449435|
|31.||Press WH,Flannery BP,Teukolsky SA,et al. Numerical RecipiesYear: 2007Oxford, UKCambridge University Press|
|32.||Drobnak I,Seručnik M,Lah J,Vesnaver G. Stability of a short DNA duplex as a function of temperature: the effect of ΔCp and added salt concentrationActa Chimica SlovenicaYear: 2007543445451|
|33.||Record MT,Anderson CF,Lohman TM. Thermodynamic analysis of ion effects on the binding and conformational equilibria of proteins and nucleic acids: the roles of ion association or release, screening, and ion effects on water activityQuarterly Reviews of BiophysicsYear: 1978112103178353875|
|34.||Hilbers CW,Haasnoot CAG,de Bruin SH,Joordens JJM,Van Der Marel GA,Van Boom JH. Hairpin formation in synthetic oligonucleotidesBiochimieYear: 1985677-86856954084598|
|35.||Vallone PM,Benight AS. Melting studies of short DNA hairpins containing the universal base 5-nitroindoleNucleic Acids ResearchYear: 1999273589359610446251|
Previous Document: The Role of FRMD7 in Idiopathic Infantile Nystagmus.
Next Document: The stability of a model substrate for topoisomerase 1-mediated DNA religation depends on the presen...