Document Detail

Exercise and quality of life in patients with cystic fibrosis: A 12-week intervention study.
Jump to Full Text
MedLine Citation:
PMID:  21722067     Owner:  NLM     Status:  MEDLINE    
Abstract/OtherAbstract:
It was hypothesised that increased exercise capacity is related to improved quality of life (QoL) in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF). A 12-week individually tailored unsupervised aerobic exercise programme was offered to 42 patients with CF. At the start and at the end of the exercise programme, data on QoL, current exercise habits and preferences, anthropometric data, exercise test, and lung function test were collected. Adherence was observed by a heart rate (HR) monitor. A total of 24 patients accepted to be enrolled in the exercise programme and 14 completed the programme. Another 14 patients declined to be enrolled in the exercise programme but completed the Cystic Fibrosis Questionnaire for Adolescents and Adults (CFQ-R 14+). Four patients did not want to participate at all. The 14 patients completing the exercise programme had a significantly increased VO(2max), but they showed no significant change in total QoL score. However, the scores in the domain of treatment burden and emotional functioning increased significantly. There was no significant difference in QoL and lung function between patients participating in the exercise programme (n = 24) and non-participants (n = 14). A 12-week individually tailored unsupervised aerobic exercise programme where HR monitors were used significantly affected VO(2max). Improvement in QoL could not be demonstrated in this study.
Authors:
Anne Mette Schmidt; Ulla Jacobsen; Vibeke Bregnballe; Hanne Vebert Olesen; Thorsten Ingemann-Hansen; Mikael Thastum; Peter Oluf Schiøtz
Related Documents :
9029197 - Testosterone and cortisol in relationship to dietary nutrients and resistance exercise.
19577377 - A "mini-fast with exercise" protocol for fat loss.
21372447 - Effects of aerobic exercise on lipid profiles and high molecular weight adiponectin in ...
21589787 - The effect of exercise on the severity of the fatigue in colorectal cancer patients who...
25455437 - The effects of arm crank ergometry, cycle ergometry and treadmill walking on postural s...
21975737 - Exercise training for adults with chronic kidney disease.
Publication Detail:
Type:  Clinical Trial; Journal Article; Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't     Date:  2011-07-03
Journal Detail:
Title:  Physiotherapy theory and practice     Volume:  27     ISSN:  1532-5040     ISO Abbreviation:  Physiother Theory Pract     Publication Date:  2011 Nov 
Date Detail:
Created Date:  2011-10-19     Completed Date:  2012-02-14     Revised Date:  2013-06-28    
Medline Journal Info:
Nlm Unique ID:  9015520     Medline TA:  Physiother Theory Pract     Country:  England    
Other Details:
Languages:  eng     Pagination:  548-56     Citation Subset:  IM    
Affiliation:
Department of Physiotherapy, Aarhus University Hospital, Skejby, Aarhus N, Denmark. schmidt@skejby.rm.dk
Export Citation:
APA/MLA Format     Download EndNote     Download BibTex
MeSH Terms
Descriptor/Qualifier:
Adolescent
Adult
Anthropometry
Cystic Fibrosis / therapy*
Exercise*
Exercise Tolerance*
Female
Forced Expiratory Volume
Humans
Intervention Studies
Male
Quality of Life*
Young Adult
Comments/Corrections

From MEDLINE®/PubMed®, a database of the U.S. National Library of Medicine

Full Text
Journal Information
Journal ID (nlm-ta): Physiother Theory Pract
Journal ID (publisher-id): uptp
ISSN: 0959-3985
ISSN: 1532-5040
Publisher: Informa Healthcare
Article Information
Download PDF
© 2011 Informa Healthcare USA, Inc.
open-access:
Accepted Day: 27 Month: 11 Year: 2010
Print publication date: Month: 11 Year: 2011
Electronic publication date: Day: 03 Month: 7 Year: 2011
Volume: 27 Issue: 8
First Page: 548 Last Page: 556
ID: 3172143
PubMed Id: 21722067
DOI: 10.3109/09593985.2010.545102

Exercise and quality of life in patients with cystic fibrosis: A 12-week intervention study
Anne Mette Schmidt, BS, PT1
Ulla Jacobsen, PT1
Vibeke Bregnballe, RN, MHH2
Hanne Vebert Olesen, MD, PhD2
Thorsten Ingemann-Hansen, MD, PhD3
Mikael Thastum, PhD4
Peter Oluf Schietz, MD2
1Department of Physiotherapy, Aarhus University Hospital, Skejby, Aarhus N, Denmark
2Department of Pediatrics, Aarhus University Hospital, Skejby, Aarhus N, Denmark
3Department of Sport Science, Aarhus University, Skejby, Aarhus C, Denmark
4Department of Psychology, Aarhus University, Skejby, Aarhus C, Denmark
Correspondence: Address correspondence to Anne Mette Schmidt, BS, PT, Department of Physiotherapy, Aarhus University Hospital, Skejby, Brendstrup-gaardsvej 100, DK-8200 Aarhus, N Denmark. E-mail: annemette.schmidt@skejby.rm.dk

INTRODUCTION

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is the most common hereditary disease in Caucasians, and no curative treatment has yet been found. In Denmark, life expectancy is now a median of 42 years (Ravilly et al, 2005).

Approximately 1 in 4,700 (Watters and Mehta, 2007) live births in Denmark is affected by the condition, and there are approximately 420 patients with CF in Denmark. CF primarily affects lung function and nutritional status (Klijn et al, 2003).

During the last decade, focus has been on exercise as an important element in the treatment of CF. Exercise has thus been incorporated in many standard treatment regimes, and exercise capacity is more often used as an outcome variable in intervention studies. Exercise capacity is currently used as an important parameter of disease status and progression (Orenstein and Higgins, 2005; Schneidermann-Walker et al, 2000; Turchetta, 2004), and it is well known that patients with a high exercise capacity have a longer life expectancy (Hebestreit et al, 2006; Klijn et al, 2004; Orenstein et al, 2004). Furthermore, it has been stated that aerobic capacity correlates with quality of life (QoL) measures, and changes in the former are associated with changes in the latter (Hebestreit et al, 2006).

Therefore, we designed a 12-week intervention study consisting of an individually tailored and unsupervised aerobic exercise programme to investigate the association between increased exercise capacity and changes in QoL in patients with CF. The exercise programme comprised everyday life activities adapted to the preferences of each individual patient. The patient was personally responsible for activating an HR monitor for every exercise session, indicating intensity, frequency, and duration and thus adherence to the programme.

It is our clinical experience that it can be difficult to motivate patients with CF to incorporate regular exercise into their everyday life. QoL is potentially negatively affected by the large burden of treatment and the complexity of the treatment evolving over years as CF progresses (Gee et al, 2005). It was our hope that an increase in exercise capacity and thereby an experienced increase in QoL could motivate the patients to adhere to the unsupervised exercise programme.

It was hypothesised that a 12-week individually tailored and unsupervised aerobic exercise programme in patients with CF could increase exercise capacity and thus QoL.


MATERIALS AND METHODS
Patients

Patients from the CF Centre at Aarhus University Hospital, Skejby, between 14 and 50 years of age, were invited. In our CF registry we found 42 eligible patients, and 24 accepted to participate in the study. A total of 14 of the 18 patients who declined participation filled in the Cystic Fibrosis Questionnaire for Adolescents and Adults (CFQ-R 14+).

Exclusion criteria were FEV1% <60, lung transplantation, debut of asthma or diabetes in the intervention period, and/or physical or psychological disability preventing participation.

All patients attended the CF Centre regularly, and during the study period the patients continued their regular therapy, including airway clearance therapy using a positive expiratory pressure mask, enzymes, vitamins, and other medical treatment.

Written informed consent was obtained from patients or parents. The study was approved by the Central Denmark Region Committees on Biomedical and Research Ethics, file number 20060052.

Study design

The study period was 12 weeks. Measurements were performed at the start and at the end of the study. The pretests and posttests were identical.

Measurements

Measurements were performed by the same assessors involved in the delivery of the intervention, and the patients were initially acquainted with the test procedures.

Quality of life

QoL was measured by using the Danish validated version (Bregnballe et al, 2008) of the disease-specific health-related QoL questionnaire, CFQ-R 14+ (Quittner et al, 2000). With a Chronbach's a ranging from 0.54 to 0.95, this seemed to be a reliable and valid instrument for measuring CF specific QoL (Bregnballe et al, 2008).

The CFQ-R 14+ consists of 49 self-reported items within 12 domains: 1) physical functioning (8 items); 2) vitality (4 items); 3) emotional functioning (5 items); 4) eating disturbances (3 items); 5) treatment burden (3 items); 6) general health perception (3 items); 7) social functioning (6 items); 8) body image (3 items); 9) role limitations (4 items); 10) weight problems (1 item); 11) respiratory symptoms (6 items); and 12) digestive symptoms (3 items). Answers were reported on a four-point scale rating frequency, difficulty, or truth, and selecting one of four statements that described the patient's situation. The scores ranged from 0 to 100 and higher scores equalled higher QoL.

Current exercise habits and preferences

To assess the patients' level of current physical activity, we asked them to fill in a short questionnaire (Wilhelmsen, Tibblin, Fordor, and Werkö, 1971). Furthermore, we interviewed the patients about their preferred physical activity.

Anthropometric data

Body weight was measured by using an electronic calibrated kilogram scale (BWB-800MA, Titan Corporation, Netherlands) and standing height using a stadiometer. The measurements were used to calculate the body mass index (BMI). For comparison between the different age groups, a BMI z score was calculated on the basis of Danish data on children and adults (Nysom, Mølgaard, Hutchings, and Michaelson, 2001).

Exercise test and maximum heart rate

Exercise capacity was measured as peak oxygen consumption rate (L/min). Before starting the incremental maximum exercise test, the patients warmed up on a voluntary level for 5 minutes on the cycle ergometer (Monark, Ergomedic 828E, Sweden). To reach the patients' maximum in 5-10 minutes, step-wise increments of 0.4 kilopond (kp) every 1.5 minutes were made, starting on individual levels from 0.8 to 1.8 kp, depending on the physical fitness of the patient. The patients were asked to choose a cadence between 60 and 85 revolutions per minute and to keep it during the test. The maximum level was reached when the patient could no longer maintain the cadence or to volitional fatigue. Patients were verbally encouraged throughout the test. The patients wore a close-fitting mask connected to an online respiratory gas exchange analyser (AMIS 2001, Innovision, Denmark) and computer system. Expired air was sampled continuously, and oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide production were measured every 10 seconds. VO2max was determined as the peak oxygen uptake every 10 seconds throughout the test. VO2max was normalised to body mass (VO2max/kg)- The HR was monitored (Polar, RS400, Finland) continuously every 5 seconds during the test, and the highest value was recorded. After the test, efforts were considered to be at a maximum level when three of the following four criteria were met: 1) total exhaustion; 2) HR above (220 - age) -10% 3) respiratory exchange ratio (the ratio between the measurements of VCO2 and VO2) above 1.11; and 4) the VO2 curve levelled off with a surge of less than 0.15 L/min from the last increment until the patient stopped the test.

Lung function

FEV1% was performed by using a Pneumotach spirometer (Masterscreen Body, Jäger, Germany). The pretest on lung function was performed on the day the patient entered the study, and the posttest on lung function was performed the day the patient ended the study.

Intervention

To optimise adherence, each patient had the opportunity to select one or more physical activities for their individually tailored exercise programme. The patients chose different activities such as bicycling (including exercise bike), running, gymnastics, swimming, and dancing. Some patients performed more than one activity.

The patients were instructed to exercise at least half an hour three times a week for 12 weeks with an HR above 70% of their maximum HR calculated from the maximum HR of the pretest. An intensity of 70% of maximum HR has been used in several studies on patients with CF where an improvement in VO2max was obtained (de Jong et al, 1994; Gulmans et al, 1999; Schneidermann-Walker et al, 2000; Selvadurai et al, 2002).

The exercise programme was intended to be a supplement to any exercise the patient already did.

Each training session was divided into two phases: 1) a warm-up phase of 5 minutes and 2) a training phase of at least 25 minutes. If the patients could not endure intensity above 70% of their HR maximum, they were allowed to stop the HR monitor and have a short break. HR was continuously monitored every 5 seconds by an HR monitor (Polar, RS400, Finland) to control training intensity. Exercise data were stored in the HR monitor as an exercise dairy and an evidence of adherence.

The patients were offered supervised training at the CF Centre once every second week, but no patients accepted this offer. We made motivational phone calls to all patients every week in the beginning of the exercise programme, and subsequent follow-up was planned individually. The motivational phone calls followed a nonstandardised semistructured interview guide. After the posttest exercise, data were transferred to a computer for analysis.

Statistical analysis

Pretest values for different groups were analysed by a Mann-Whitney test. Dichotomous variables were tested by a chi-square test. Pretest and posttest values were compared by using a paired t test. A p-value of ≤ 0.05 was considered statistically significant. A Wilcoxin signed-ranks test was conducted to evaluate the impact of the exercise programme on CFQ-R14+ scores. By a Kruskal-Wallis test, CFQ-R 14+ scores of group 1 were compared with the CFQ-R 14+ scores of group 0 before starting the exercise programme and with group 2 (see classification of groups in Results).


RESULTS
Baseline data

The patients were classified as follows: group 0 = dropouts from the exercise programme (n = 10); group 1 = patients completing the exercise programme (n = 14); and group 2 = patients only filling in the CFQ-R 14+, non-participants (n = 14). Clinical characteristics of the 24 patients in the exercise programme (groups 0 + 1) are shown in Table 1.

Ten (group 0) of the 24 patients did not complete the exercise programme mainly due to practical reasons (e.g., lack of time and/or motivation and one patient had a knee injury at work). These 10 patients were not posttested. Fourteen (group 1) of the 24 patients were pretested, completed the exercise programme, and were posttested.

Engagement in vigorous activities in patients completing the exercise programme (group 1) did on average not meet the intended frequency and duration. Frequency was on average 2.31 times a week instead of three times a week, and duration was on average 79 minutes a week instead of 90 minutes a week. The patient exercising with the lowest intensity exercised with a 75% of maximum HR on average, and the patient exercising with the highest intensity exercised with an 86% of maximum HR on average (both patients, lowest and highest) exercising more than the recommended 70% of maximum HR. As shown in Table 2, we found no significant differences between group 0 and group 1 concerning physical baseline data.

Fourteen (group 2) of 18 patients filled in the CFQ-R14+ but did not participate in the exercise programme. As shown in Table 3, no significant difference (p = 0.74) was found in FEV1% between participants in the exercise programme (groups 0 + 1) and non-participants (group 2). Similarly, there was no significant difference (p = 0.55) between participants completing the exercise programme (group 1) and non-participants (group 2).

Primary outcomes
Exercise capacity

As seen in Table 4 and Figure 1, patients in group 1 significantly improved their VO2max, and their VO2max/kg improved, though not significantly.

Quality of life

In group 1 a significant increase was found in the domain of treatment burden from the scores before the intervention (M = 64.39; SD = 13.20) to the post-intervention scores (M = 76.19; SD = 8.56) p = 0.013; and in the domain of emotional functioning from the scores before the intervention (M = 81.43; SD = 17.77) to the postintervention scores (M = 86.19; SD= 13.70) p = 0.021 (Table 5). The eta-squared statistic (emotional functioning = 0.30; treatment burden = 0.50) indicated a large effect size. No significant differences were found in any other domains.

The CFQ-R 14+ scores of group 1 before the exercise programme were compared with the CFQ-R 14+ scores of group 0 (drop-outs) before the exercise programme and with the CFQ-R 14+ scores of group 2. No differences were found in any of the comparisons.

The internal consistency of each scale showed Cronbach's α coefficients ranging from 0.42 to 0.92 with coefficients <0.70 in the domains of role limitations (0.67); body image (0.62); social functioning (0.43); and digestive symptoms (0.42).

Secondary outcomes
Anthropometric data

We found no significant differences in BMI z scores (Table 4).

Lung function

We found no significant differences in FEV1% (Table 4).


DISCUSSION

To our knowledge, this is the first study in patients with CF investigating the response to an individually tailored and unsupervised aerobic exercise programme involving use of HR monitors. As far as we know, this is the first time when VO2max and QoL measured by CFQ-R 14+ are primary outcomes. Our study also included QoL and FEV1% analysis of patients not participating in the exercise programme (group 2).

We did not find a significant difference in FEV1% between participants in the exercise programme (group 0 + 1) and non-participants (group 2). This may indicate that the patient's lung function did not seem to play any role in the willingness to participate in this study. Our individually tailored and unsupervised exercise programme had no positive or negative effect on FEV1%. The expected decline in lung function in patients with CF is likely to be between 2% and 3% annually. This suggests that studies shorter than 12 months may be unable to detect any difference in lung function (Orenstein and Higgins, 2005). Consequently, our study was not able to detect any effect on lung function.

We showed that patients with CF with a relatively good lung function (FEV1% above 60%) can increase their VO2max significantly by participating in a 12-week individually tailored and unsupervised aerobic exercise programme. Our results are consistent with the results of other studies in both children and adults. Klijn et al (2004) found a significant change in VO2max but not in VO2max/kg following a 12-week anaerobic exercise programme in children with CF.

We did not find any significant increase in VO2max/kg. This is in contrast to several studies (de Jong et al, 1994; Gulmans et al, 1999; Hebestreit et al, 2010; Selvadurai et al, 2002; Turchetta et al, 2004). However, it is worth mentioning that these studies had different designs concerning type of intervention (e.g., aerobic exercise, anaerobic exercise, or a combination of these); the nature of the exercise (e.g., intensity, frequency, and duration); age of study population; duration of study; and outcome measurements.

Our study showed that 30 minutes of unsupervised exercise three times a week with an intensity of 70% of the maximum HR was enough to increase VO2max-Still, half of our patients did not manage to adhere to this exercise programme for an extended period of time. We expected that adherence in our study would be better than other studies on unsupervised exercise programmes because our patients could choose between different activities, knowing that adherence would never be as good as in supervised exercise studies. We still chose to have unsupervised exercise in our study to make it as realistic as possible. We believe that it is not realistic for logistical, financial, and geographical reasons that patients attend all exercise sessions supervised in the hospital. Our study underlines that HR monitors are preferred in unsupervised studies rather than exercise diaries because they are often poorly updated and seldom returned (Orenstein and Higgins, 2005). The HR monitors gave an impression of whether the patients exercised as instructed. Moreover, some of the patients told us that the HR monitor was a motivating factor. Apart from our study being unsupervised, the reason for the high dropout rate in our study may be the lack of emphasis on exercise as a part of routine CF treatment in Denmark.

Many participants complained about lack of time to do exercise but no one complained about the intensity. This is interesting in the light of our results on frequency, duration, and intensity. Engagement in vigorous activities in patients completing the exercise programme (group 1) did, on average, not meet the intended frequency and duration. However, the intensity of the lowest and the highest exercising patient was between 75% of maximum HR on average and 86% of maximum HR on average, both patients exercising with an intensity considerably higher than the recommended 70% of maximum HR. This suggested that the recommended intensity on 70% of maximum HR was not the reason for the high dropout level in our study. It can be debated whether the intensity was individualised. The intensity in relative terms was the same for all patients, whereas the absolute intensity was based on maximum HR of each patient. It may be that motivation, adherence, and QoL could increase as intensity increased and the duration of the exercise decreased.

The participation in our study was based on the patient's willingness, and we thus expected that all participating patients were motivated. This study did not allow patients to be randomised into a control group (no exercise) and participants were informed about this. At our CF Centre we encourage patients to gradually take responsibility of their disease when they become adolescents. We try to engage patients through continuous (educational) dialogue regarding treatment to enable the patient to take ownership of their treatment. Our belief is that we can achieve more by voluntariness of our patients and by their inner motivation. We had hoped that an increase in VO2max would increase QoL and thereby the inner motivation to do exercise. A study by Arias Llorente, Bousono Garcia, and Dìaz Martin (2008) concluded that adherence has shown to improve with treatments that are perceived by patients as more important or influencing their QoL to a greater extent. Approximately 50% of people with chronic conditions do not adhere to treatment, and adherence reduces with the complexity of treatment. Previous studies in CF have found that adherence to chest physiotherapy and exercise is lower than other treatments (Myers, 2009).

Despite the proven benefits of exercise, the degree of physical activity generally undertaken in the CF population remains an issue of concern. The development of positive attitudes toward and a regular schedule for activity early in life may be important in determining an active style into adulthood (Prasad and Cerny, 2002). Earlier studies reported reasonable levels of compliance with exercise regimes. There are numerous possible reasons for the improved rates of adherence reported by these studies (e.g., the nature of activity, individualised programs, and whether activity is supervised). Programmes involving a single activity especially if prescribed over long periods of time are associated with poor long-term adherence (Prasad and Cerny, 2002).

Our patients were offered supervised training at the CF Centre once every second week but no patients accepted this offer. We made motivational phone calls to all patients every week in the beginning of the exercise programme and subsequent follow-up was planned individually. Nearly all the patients had one supervised exercise session during the intervention. Our strategy was to improve adherence by regular contact between us and the patient, not to supervise the programme as such but simply to show interest, enquire about the patient's well-being, and allow any queries to be answered. This method has been used previously as a part of an overall strategy to improve compliance in an exercise study by Schneidermann-Walker et al (2000). This study reported good rates of adherence.

We assumed that the short intervention period and individually tailored programme based on willingness to participate could lead to a relatively high adherence. However, several factors may influence adherence to any treatment regime, including a patient's willingness to participate in regular exercise over a period of time. These can be factors related to the disease process itself, gender, age, and external factors such as social support, perception of competency, self-esteem, enjoyment of activity, and factors associated with the patient's behaviour such as motivation and choice (Prasad and Cerny, 2002). The reason for the high dropout rate in this study could be the subject of further interest.

Our study failed to show that increased exercise capacity expressed as VO2max could improve QoL. We found a statistically significant increase in scores of the domain of treatment burden and emotional functioning. The magnitude of the differences in the means were very large (eta-squared in treatment burden = 0.50; emotional functioning = 0.30). The increase in the scores of the domain of treatment burden was surprising. The explanation might be that the patients did not see the exercise program as a treatment burden, and the exercise program might have made them feel more energetic though this was not reflected in other domains such as vitality. Change of behaviour starts as a mental process, and this study indicated that changes did occur in patients who completed the exercise programme (group 1) by an improved emotional function score.

In this study the internal consistency of the CFQ-R 14+ scales measured by Chronbach's α failed to reach the recommended 0.7 in four of the scales. Three of these scales also showed a weak internal consistency in the validation of the CFQ-R +14; the fourth scale (role limitation) only showed a slightly lower Chronbach's α (0.67) than recommended.

The fact that the questionnaire failed to show an overall improvement in QoL might be explained by the complexity of the CFQ-R 14+. Retrospectively, we could not expect improvements in QoL after a 12-week intervention within the physical domains in CFQ-R 14+ such as eating disturbances and weight problems. Furthermore, group 1 had a high score in several of the physical domains in the pretest, leaving little room for improvement. The CFQ-R 14+ consists of 49 self-reported items within 12 domains, and the tool might have been too complex to show whether increased exercise capacity could result in increased QoL for patients with CF.

Two previous studies (Hebestreit et al, 2010; Klijn et al, 2004) on exercise have used CFQ to evaluate QoL, but not as a primary outcome. In contrast to our study, Klijn et al (2004) included anaerobic training. The intervention period was similar to ours, but this study was supervised. Klijn et al (2004) found a significantly higher score in the domain of physical function, but no change was found in other domains. Recently, in a partially supervised exercise programme for at least 6 months, Hebestreit et al (2010) did not find any significant effect on QoL except for the scale “Subjective Health Perception.”

Other intervention studies on exercise have measured QoL as a secondary outcome but with different measurements. In terms of degree of limitation in activities of daily living (ADL), de Jong et al (1994) found a decrease in the limitations in ADL. Using the “Quality of Well-Being Scale” Orenstein et al (2004) did not find any significant changes in QoL, but Selvadurai et al (2002) showed a significant difference in the aerobic exercise group. Earlier Orenstein, Nixon, Ross, and Kaplan (1989) assessed the “Quality of Well-Being Scale” and found a correlation between this scale and peak oxygen consumption. Gulmans et al (1999) found a significant improvement for the Total Competence Score as well as for the subscales “physical appearance” and “general self-worth” using the “Self Perception Profile for Children.” In summary, earlier studies have not provided a precise picture of the connection between exercise and QoL. Our study was not successful in fully clarifying this either.

There are some limitations of this study to be addressed. First, a 12-week study is a short time for a lifestyle change in patients with a chronic disease such as CF. Our aim was to increase exercise capacity and investigate if it had any positive effect on QoL. Bearing in mind that earlier studies have shown significant changes in either VO2max or VO2max/kg in 12 or less than 12 weeks of exercise (de Jong et al, 1994; Klijn et al, 2004; Selvadurai et al, 2002; Turchetta et al, 2004), we assessed that 12 weeks would be enough to increase VO2max and thereby hopefully QoL. However, 12 weeks might not be enough to increase QoL even though it is enough to increase VO2max, and it could be interesting to study whether a longer study period would make a difference.

Second, our patients did not on average exercise at the recommended frequency and duration; instead, they exercised with a higher intensity than recommended. We do not know if the influence on QoL would have been different if our patients had exercised as recommended. Yet, the effect of the exercise programme was still in favor of the intervention and caused the expected increase in VO2max.

Third, in our exercise test we applied stepwise increments with fixed increment of 0.4 kp in determining the peak oxygen uptake. We are aware that some laboratories use continuous load increase to avoid one heavy load at one occasion. Stepwise increments could possibly cause some patients to finish the exercise test too early. However, in the present study all peak oxygen uptake measurements fulfilled three of four criteria (total exhaustion, HR above (220 - age) - 10%, respiratory exchanges ratio above 1.11, and/or the VO2 curve levelled off).

Fourth, the high dropout rate and thereby small sample size have weakened the conclusions. However, this has shown that the degree of encouragement and supervision in this programme may not have been sufficient and has to be individualised to achieve adherence to exercise as part of CF treatment.

Finally, due to lack of follow-up, we do not know if the patients in group 1 obtained a lifestyle change at the end of the study period. Hebestreit et al (2010) showed that at least 6 months of a partially supervised and individualised physical activity programme might be sufficient to cause persisting changes in activity behaviour and health. Whether our study is enough to induce this persisting change is unknown. A follow-up period in our study could have clarified this because a lasting effect after 12 weeks would be clinically relevant because such a programme can be realised relatively easily. Our aim was to measure the immediate effect of an unsupervised and individualised 12-week exercise programme on VO2max and QoL, and our study was not designed as a follow-up study due to resources.

In conclusion, this study has shown that an effect on VO2max can be achieved with an individually tailored and unsupervised aerobic exercise programme using HR monitors. A frequently postulated benefit of any physical exercise is an enhanced feeling of well-being. Thus, it was hypothesised that exercise capacity would be related to QoL in patients with CF. Improvement in QoL could not be demonstrated in this study.

Regular exercise is a very important factor in maintaining good health. This is even more important in patients with chronic diseases such as CF. Therefore, we still recommend that patients with CF increase or maintain as good a physical fitness as possible.


Associate Professor Kristian Overgaard, Department of Sport Science, Aarhus University, is thanked for assistance with the exercise tests. Funding was obtained through the Obel Family Fund, Health Research Fund of the Central Denmark Region, Research Council at Aarhus University Hospital, Skejby, Cystic Fibrosis Association, and Danish Physiotherapists. No funding body was involved in the study design, in the collection, analysis, and interpretation of data; in writing of the manuscript; or in the decision to submit the manuscript for publication.

Declaration of interest

The authors report no conflict of interest. The authors alone are responsible for the content and writing of the article.


REFERENCES
Arias Llorente RP,Bousoño Garcìa C,Dìaz Martìn JJ. Treatment compliance in children and adults with cystic fibrosisJournal of Cystic FibrosisYear: 2008735936718304896
Bregnballe V,Thastum M,Lund LD,Hansen CR,Preissler T,Schiotz PO. Validation of the Danish version of the revised cystic fibrosis quality of life questionnaire in adolescents and adults (CFQ-R14+)Journal of Cystic FibrosisYear: 2008753153618694658
de Jong W,Grevink RG,Roorda RJ,Kaptein AA,van der Schans CP. Effect of a home exercise training program in patients with cystic fibrosisChestYear: 19941054634688306748
Gee L,Abbott J,Hart A,Conway SP,Etherington C,Webb AK. Associations between clinical variables and quality of life in adults with cystic fibrosisJournal of Cystic FibrosisYear: 20054596615752683
Gulmans VAM,de Meer K,Brackel HJL,Faber JAJ,Berger R,Helders PJM. Outpatient exercise training in children with cystic fibrosis: Physiological effects, perceived competence, and acceptabilityPediatric PulmonologyYear: 199928394610406049
Hebestreit H,Kieser S,Jung S,Ballmann M,Hebestreit A,Schindler C,Schenk T,Posselt H-G,Kriemler S. Long-term effects of a partially supervised conditioning programme in cystic fibrosisEuropean Respiratory JournalYear: 20103557858319643946
Hebestreit H,Kieser S,Riidiger S,Schenk T,Jung S,Hebestreit A,Ballmann M,Posselt H-G,Kriemler S. Physical activity is independently related to aerobic capacity in cystic fibrosisEuropean Respiratory JournalYear: 20062873473916807261
Klijn PH,Oudshoorn A,van der Ent CK,van der Net J,Kimpen JL,Helders PJM. Effects of anaerobic training in children with cystic fibrosis: A randomized controlled studyChestYear: 20041251299130515078738
Klijn PHC,van der Net J,Kimpen JL,Helders PJM,van der Ent CK. Longitudinal determinants of peak aerobic performance in children with cystic fibrosisChestYear: 20031242215221914665503
Myers LB. An exploratory study investigating factors associated with adherence to chest physiotherapy and exercise in adults with cystic fibrosisJournal of Cystic FibrosisYear: 2009842542719775941
Nysom K,Mølgaard C,Hutchings B,Michaelsen KF. Body mass index of 0 to 45-y-old Danes: Reference values and comparison with published European reference valuesInternational Journal of ObesityYear: 20012517718411410817
Orenstein DM,Higgins LW. Update on the role of exercise in cystic fibrosisCurrent Opinion in Pulmonary MedicineYear: 20051151952316217178
Orenstein DM,Hovell MF,Mulvihill M,Keating KK,Hofstetter R,Kelsey S,Morris K,Nixon PA. Strength vs aerobic training in children with cystic fibrosis: A randomized controlled trialChestYear: 20041261204121415486384
Orenstein DM,Nixon PA,Ross EA,Kaplan RM. The quality of well-being in cystic fibrosisChestYear: 1989953443472914486
Prasad SA,Cerny FJ. Factors that influence adherence to exercise and their effectiveness: Application to cystic fibrosisPediatric PulmonologyYear: 200234667212112800
Quittner AL,Sweeny S,Watrous M,Munzenberger P,Bearss K,Gibson Nitza A,Fisher LA,Henry B. Translation and linguistic validation of a disease-specific quality of life measure for cystic fibrosisJournal of Pediatric PsychologyYear: 20002540341410980045
Ravilly S,Olesen HV,Quiton HB,Viviani L,Wiedemann B,Le Roux E,Parant A,Bellis G. Study on cystic fibrosis mortality in 5 countriesJournal of Cystic FibrosisYear: 20054S119S125
Schneidermann-Walker J,Pollock SL,Corey M,Wilkes DD,Canny GJ,Pedder L,Reisman JJ. A randomized controlled trial of a 3-year home exercise program in cystic fibrosisJournal of PediatricsYear: 200013630431010700685
Selvadurai HC,Blimkie CJ,Meyers N,Mellis CM,Cooper PJ,Van Asperen PP. Randomized controlled study of in-hospital exercise training programs in children with cystic fibrosisPediatric PulmonologyYear: 20023319420011836799
Turchetta A,Salerno T,Lucidi V,Libera F,Cutrera R,Bush A. Usefulness of a program of hospital-supervised physical training in patients with cystic fibrosisPediatric PulmonologyYear: 20043811511815211693
Watters S Mehta. Hodson M,Gedders D,Bush AA Epidemiology of cystic fibrosisCystic FibrosisYear: 2007LondonHodder Arnold2148
Wilhelmsen L,Tibblin G,Fordor J,Werko I. Larsen OA,Malmborg ROA multifactorial primary preventive trial in Gothenburg, SwedenCoronary Heart Disease and Physical FitnessYear: 1971BaltimoreUniversity Park Press266270

Figures

[Figure ID: fig1]
Figure 1 

Patients above the diagonal improved their VO2max.



Tables
[TableWrap ID: tbl1] TABLE 1 

Clinical characteristics of the 24 patients entering the exercise programme (groups 0 + 1).


N 24
Gender M/F 15/9
Age range, years (median) 14–40 (19)
Genotype
ΔF508/ΔF508 17 patients
ΔF508/other mutations 7 patients

[TableWrap ID: tbl2] TABLE 2 

Comparison of physical baseline data between patients completing the exercise programme (group 1) and dropouts (group 0); median (25; 75% percentiles).


Group 1 n = 14 Group 0 n = 10 p-value
FEV1% 89.4 (76.8;105.4) 92.8 (82.9;109.1) 0.447
BMI z score −0.34 (−0.87;0.43) 0.01(−0.87;0.90) 0.520
VO2max (L/min) 2.40 (1.93;2.78) 2.39 (2.18;3.12) 0.520
VO2max/kg (mL/min/kg) 40.5 (34.5;45.8) 45.5 (36.8;47.0) 0.412
Age (years) 19 (15.5;27.0) 17 (15.5;19.5) 0.203
Gender 8M/6F 7M/3F 0.521

[TableWrap ID: tbl3] TABLE 3 

Comparison of baseline FEV1% between patients entering the exercise programme (groups 0 + 1), patients completing the exercise programme (group 1) and patients only filling in the CFQ-R 14+ (group 2).


FEV1%; median (25:75%)
Group 0 + 1 n = 24 91.7 (79.7;106.3)
Group 1 n = 14 89.4 (76.8;105.4)
Group 2 n = 14 96.9 (79.6;104.1)

[TableWrap ID: tbl4] TABLE 4 

Comparison of physical data of patients completing the exercise programme (group 1) before and after the intervention (median (25; 75% percentiles).


Pretest Posttest p-value
FEV1% n =13 (*) 87.6 (74.8;105.8) 85.0 (76.5;99.0) 0.377
BMI z score n =14 −0.34 (−0.87;0.43) −0.41(−0.92;0.49) 0.931
VO2max (L/min) n =14 2.40 (1.93;2.78) 2.42 (1.97;3.05) 0.014
VO2max/kg (mL/min/kg) n =14 40.5 (34.5;45.8) 42.5 (35.0;48.0) 0.057

*One patient did not complete the posttest on lung function because of cough.


[TableWrap ID: tbl5] TABLE 5 

Quality of life in patients completing the exercise programme (group 1) before and after the intervention.


Group 1 (n = 14) Pretest (mean ± SD) Posttest (mean ± SD) p-value
Physical functioning 90.8 ± 14.5 93.8 ± 8.1 0.346
Role limitations 91.1 ± 12.0 92.9 ± 7.9 0.566
Vitality 59.5 ± 16.6 64.9 ± 11.4 0.204
Emotional functioning 81.4 ± 17.8 86.2 ± 13.7 0.021
Social functioning 74.6 ± 12.3 80.2 ± 13.6 0.191
Body image 83.3 ± 16.2 82.5 ± 14.9 0.783
Eating disturbances 94.4 ± 12.1 93.7 ± 15.5 0.655
Treatment burden 64.3 ± 13.2 76.2 ± 8.6 0.013
Health perceptions 66.7 ± 20.4 73.8 ± 17.2 0.091
Weight problems 83.3 ± 25.3 78.6 ± 24.8 0.317
Respiratory symptoms 77.8 ± 12.7 76.2 ± 13.5 0.371
Digestive symptoms 78.6 ± 19.7 80.2 ± 17.0 0.496


Article Categories:
  • Research Report


Previous Document:  Dense fouling in acid transfer pipelines by an acidophilic rubber degrading fungus.
Next Document:  Dietary self-monitoring and its impact on weight loss in overweight children.