Document Detail

Eating lizards: a millenary habit evidenced by Paleoparasitology.
Jump to Full Text
MedLine Citation:
PMID:  23098578     Owner:  NLM     Status:  MEDLINE    
Abstract/OtherAbstract:
BACKGROUND: Analyses of coprolites have contributed to the knowledge of diet as well as infectious diseases in ancient populations. Results of paleoparasitological studies showed that prehistoric groups were exposed to spurious and zoonotic parasites, especially food-related. Here we report the findings of a paleoparasitological study carried out in remote regions of Brazil's Northeast.
FINDINGS: Eggs of Pharyngodonidae (Nematoda, Oxyuroidea), a family of parasites of lizards and amphibians, were found in four human coprolites collected from three archaeological sites. In one of these, lizard scales were also found.
CONCLUSIONS: Through the finding of eggs of Pharyngodonidae in human coprolites and reptilescales in one of these, we have provided evidence that humans have consumed reptiles at least 10,000 years ago. This food habit persists to modern times in remote regions of Brazil's Northeast. Although Pharyngodonidae species are not known to infect humans, the consumption of raw or undercooked meat from lizards and other reptiles may have led to transmission of a wide range of zoonotic agents to humans in the past.
Authors:
Luciana Sianto; Isabel Teixeira-Santos; Marcia Chame; Sergio M Chaves; Sheila M Souza; Luiz Fernando Ferreira; Karl Reinhard; Adauto Araujo
Related Documents :
20642148 - The dispersals of established food-producing populations.
12321308 - Population growth to put pressure on some food supplies.
8689248 - Improving the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of food aid grain delivery.
23289438 - Occurrence of β-lactamase genes among non-typhi salmonella enterica isolated from huma...
16812538 - Information on response requirements compared with information on food density as a rei...
6666698 - The influence of proximal vs. distal goals on adherence to prescribed calories.
Publication Detail:
Type:  Journal Article; Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't     Date:  2012-10-25
Journal Detail:
Title:  BMC research notes     Volume:  5     ISSN:  1756-0500     ISO Abbreviation:  BMC Res Notes     Publication Date:  2012  
Date Detail:
Created Date:  2012-11-23     Completed Date:  2013-03-18     Revised Date:  2013-07-11    
Medline Journal Info:
Nlm Unique ID:  101462768     Medline TA:  BMC Res Notes     Country:  England    
Other Details:
Languages:  eng     Pagination:  586     Citation Subset:  IM    
Affiliation:
Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Avenida Brasil 4365, Manguinhos, CEP 21040-900, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil.
Export Citation:
APA/MLA Format     Download EndNote     Download BibTex
MeSH Terms
Descriptor/Qualifier:
Animals
Fossils
Humans
Lizards* / parasitology
Nematoda / isolation & purification
Paleontology*
Predatory Behavior*
Comments/Corrections

From MEDLINE®/PubMed®, a database of the U.S. National Library of Medicine

Full Text
Journal Information
Journal ID (nlm-ta): BMC Res Notes
Journal ID (iso-abbrev): BMC Res Notes
ISSN: 1756-0500
Publisher: BioMed Central
Article Information
Download PDF
Copyright ©2012 Sianto et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.
open-access:
Received Day: 30 Month: 3 Year: 2012
Accepted Day: 1 Month: 10 Year: 2012
collection publication date: Year: 2012
Electronic publication date: Day: 25 Month: 10 Year: 2012
Volume: 5First Page: 586 Last Page: 586
PubMed Id: 23098578
ID: 3504575
Publisher Id: 1756-0500-5-586
DOI: 10.1186/1756-0500-5-586

Eating lizards: a millenary habit evidenced by Paleoparasitology
Luciana Sianto1 Email: lsianto@ensp.fiocruz.br
Isabel Teixeira-Santos1 Email: isabeltsantos@gmail.com
Marcia Chame1 Email: mchame@fiocruz.br
Sergio M Chaves1 Email: smiranda@ensp.fiocruz.br
Sheila M Souza1 Email: sferraz@ensp.fiocruz.br
Luiz Fernando Ferreira1 Email: ludovico@ensp.fiocruz.br
Karl Reinhard2 Email: kreinhard1@mac.com
Adauto Araujo1 Email: adauto@ensp.fiocruz.br
1Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Avenida Brasil 4365, Manguinhos, CEP 21040-900, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil
2University of Nebraska-Lincoln School of Natural Resources, 719 Hardin Hall, 3100 Holdrege Street, Lincoln, NE 68583-0987, USA

Findings

As in modern times, diet varied among prehistoric human groups and small animals, including lizards and other reptiles, were important food sources for prehistoric people [1,2]. Analyses of human coprolites demonstrate this dietary diversity. Coprolites also contain intestinal parasites transmitted by contaminated food or water, including zoonotic helminths [3]. Moreover, spurious parasites can also be found in human coprolites and continue to occur, especially in current groups with traditional food habits [4]. By spurious, we mean parasite eggs that are not infective to humans and pass harmlessly through the human intestinal tract. Parapharyngodon sceleratus Chatterji, 1933 (Oxyuroidea: Pharyngodonidae) eggs were recorded in lizard coprolites (Tropidurus torquatus, Squamata, Tropiduridae) dating from 9,000 to 11,000 years [5]. The diagnosis was based on egg morphology and metric parameters in comparison with published checklists. The parasite is known to commonly occur in several lizard and amphibian species of the American continent [6-10].

Herein we describe the finding of Pharyngodonidae eggs in four coprolites, morphologically identified as specimens of human origin (Figure 1) according to Chame [11]. These coprolites were collected during excavations in the Archaeological Area of São Raimundo Nonato (n=3) and in the archaeological site of Furna do Estrago (n=1), situated in the states of Piauí and Pernambuco, respectively. Piauí and Pernambuco are neighboring states of Brazil located in the northeastern part of the country [12]. The dates of coprolites were based on radiocarbon technique applied to bones from layers and burials where coprolites were found. The method adopted in paleoparasitological analysis was applied to each sample as follows. Five grams from each coprolite were removed and placed in receptacles with 0.5% aqueous trisodium phosphate solution for 72 hours for rehydration [13]. After this period, the fragments were homogenized with a glass rod and strained through a funnel with triple-folded gauze into conical glass jars [14]. The content retained in gauze was analyzed for food remains with a stereomicroscope. After 24 h, twenty slides were prepared from the sediment in the bottom of each jar for optical microscope analysis. Slides were observed at 100x and 400x magnifications.

The first coprolite was collected in the archaeological layer dated to 10,640 ± 80 years before present (BP) and located in the site known as Toca dos Coqueiros (Archaeological Area of São Raimundo Nonato). Two other samples were collected in the site of Toca da Baixa dos Caboclos (Archaeological Area of São Raimundo Nonato) from two human burials dated respectively 525 to 315 (Beta 136209) and 530 to 440 (Beta 136208) cal years BP.

A fourth coprolite was collected in the archaeological site of Furna do Estrago (Pernambuco state), which is located in an area of upland forests, a mesic enclave, representing a true "oasis" in a semiarid region. The coprolite was found in a human burial dated between 1860 ± 50 (Beta 145954) and 1610 ± 70 (Beta 145955) years BP [15].

In all four coprolites, nematode eggs were found, two eggs in each coprolite from Toca da Baixa dos Caboclos and one egg into each other, measuring 76.9 (SD 8.1) × 43 (SD 6.6) μm (n=6). First, eggs were identified as oxyurid eggs. Then, morphological characters of eggs found in human coprolites (Figure 2) were compared with those of oxyurid eggs available in literature [16-18]. Eggs found in coprolites presented a striated brown shell formed in three layers and size range between 62,5-85,7 × 35–51, 2 μm, similar to those of oxyurid eggs from reptiles [6,19]. Since these eggs were similar in shape and size to those formerly recorded in lizards [20], including in lizard coprolites [5,21], they were identified as eggs of Pharyngodonidae, likely of Parapharyngodon sp. or Pharyngodon sp., both genera of intestinal parasites of reptiles and amphibians. A more accurate diagnosis was not possible because of the similarities between the eggs of these two genera [22] that parasitize several lizard species in Brazil [7,23].

A careful analysis of food remains was carried out. All coprolites showed macroscopic and microscopic remains consistent with those expected for a typical human diet, such as seeds, plant fibers, cooked starch grains, phytoliths, charcoal remains, and pollen grains. These latter were identified as belonging to the families Chenopodiaceae, Malvaceae and Convolvulaceae. Some species in these families are known for their medicinal properties and have traditionally been used, even up to the present day, to treat inflammation, abscesses, intestinal disorders, and parasites [24,25].

In one of the two human burial coprolites from Toca da Baixa dos Caboclos, small iridescent plates, identified as reptile scales, were also found (Figure 3). The scales didn’t present evidence of burn or cooking. First, they were identified as reptile scales. Then scales were compared microscopically in our lab with scales belonging to our reference collection. Our zoological reference collections include a lizard found dead in same area during a field expedition. Based on the morphological similarities, scales were securely identified as lizard. Based on the finding of eggs of typical reptile parasites (without known zoonotic potential) together with lizard scales in the same coprolite, we concluded that an individual had ingested one or more lizard hosts of Pharyngodonidae adult parasites. This caused Pharyngodonidae eggs to be released in the human’s intestinal tract. The undigested eggs were spuriously present this ancient human. Thus, lizard remains and Pharyngodonidae eggs were associated in this human burial coprolite.

Hunter-gatherers groups in different parts of the world consume freshly killed animals or living animals for their subsistence, including reptiles. The biological risks associated with consumption of reptile meat has been reviewed by Magnino et al. [26] and includes diseases caused by bacteria, viruses, intestinal helminths and other parasites. Forty-six species of lizards are reported in the Brazilian Caatinga, including large species such as Iguana iguana and Tupinambis merianae and many others of medium and small size [27,28]. They represent an important biomass and a food source available for human groups. The consumption of lizards is a relatively common practice in parts of Brazilian northeast semi-arid region, especially during periods of prolonged drought, when the population is forced to search alternative food resources [29]. Today, in this study area, children and young people capture small lizards for complementary feeding of families. Anthropologically, this suggests that prehistoric people in the semiarid region of Brazil used small animals as food source similarly to hunter-gatherers and agriculturalists in North America, as discussed by Reinhard et al. [1] and Sutton and Reinhard [30]. It is noteworthy that in some areas of Brazil, this strategy is still used currently.

Even arthropods potentially able to transmit parasitic disease, such as ticks and fleas, were reported in human coprolites [31]. Humans can also ingest head lice in the process of grooming hair [32].

Results of the present analysis of human coprolites bring further data about spurious parasitism and food habits in prehistoric populations. We found eggs of reptilian parasites and lizard remains in human coprolites dating from 10,000 years ago to colonial times. This shows that the habit of eating lizards, still persistent in the current local population, had ancient origins in the Brazilian semiarid region. Moreover, although species of parasites belonging to the Pharyngodonidae family are not known to infect humans, it is possible that the consumption of lizard meat led to the risk of human infection by a wide variety of zoonotic agents in the past [26].


Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.


Authors' contributions

LS, MC, AA and LFF performed paleoparasitological analysis and parasite identifications. LS, AA, ITS prepared the first versions of the manuscript, and LFF and KR reviewed the final versions. Diet remains were analysed by ITS and KR. SMS helped with archaeological contextualization. All authors participated in obtainment of financial support for research and drafting of the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.


Acknowledgements

Coprolites were sent to our laboratory by the team of archaeologists from Fundação Museu do Homem Americano (which also provided estimated dates) and from Universidade Católica de Pernambuco- UNICAP; we received financial support from the Brazilian agencies CNPq (Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico) and FAPERJ (Fundação Carlos Chagas Filho de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado do Rio de Janeiro).


References
Reinhard K,Ambler JR,Szuter CR,Hunter-gatherer use of small animal food resources as evidenced in coprolite analysisInt J OsteoarchaeolYear: 20071741642810.1002/oa.883
Sobolik K,Paleonutrition: the diet and health of prehistoric AmericansYear: 1994Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, Center for Archaeological Investigations Occasional Paper
Sianto L,Chame M,Silva CSP,Gonçalves MLC,Reinhard K,Fugassa M,Araújo A,Animal helminths in human archaeological remains: a review of zoonoses in the pastRev Inst Med Trop Sao PauloYear: 20095111913010.1590/S0036-4665200900030000119551285
Carvalho-Costa FA,Silva AG,de Souza AH,Moreira CJ,de Souza DL,Valverde JG,Jaeger LH,Martins PP,de Meneses VF,Araujo A,Boia MN,Pseudoparasitism by Calodium hepaticum (syn. Capillaria hepatica; Hepaticola hepatica) in the Negro River, Brazilian AmazonTrans R Soc Trop Med HygYear: 20091031071107310.1016/j.trstmh.2009.04.01519477475
Araújo A,Ferreira LF,Confalonieri U,A contribution to the study of helminth findings in archaeological material in BrazilRev Bras BiolYear: 198141873881
Barus V,Some remarks on the neotropical species of the genera Parapharyngodon and Batracholandros (Oxyuridae)Folia ParasitolYear: 1973201311394770803
Vicente JJ,Rodrigues HO,Gomes DC,Pinto RM,Nematóides do Brasil. Parte III. Nematóides de répteisRev Bras BiolYear: 19931019168
Ávila R,Silva R,Checklist of helminths from lizards and amphisbaenians (Reptilia, Squamata) of South AmericaJ Venom Anim Toxins Incl Trop DisYear: 20101654357210.1590/S1678-91992010000400005
Luque L,Martins A,Tavares L,Community structure of metazoan parasites of the yellow Cururu toad, Bufo ictericus (Anura, Bufonidae) from Rio de Janeiro, BrazilActa ParasitolYear: 200550215220
Walton A,Notes on amphibians parasitesProc Helminthol Soc WashYear: 194078791
Chame M,Terrestrial mammal feces: A morphometric summary and descriptionMem Inst Oswaldo CruzYear: 200398719812687767
Martin G,Pré-história do Nordeste do BrasilYear: 20084Recife: Editora Universitária UFPE
Callen E,Cameron TWM,A prehistoric diet revealed in coprolitesNew SciYear: 196083540
Araújo A,Reinhard K,Bastos OM,Costa LC,Pirmez C,Iñiguez A,Vicente AC,Morel CM,Ferreira LF,Paleoparasitology: perspectives with new techniquesRev Inst Med Trop Sao PauloYear: 19984037137610436657
Carvalho OA,Queiroz AN,Moraes FAA,Diagnóstico diferencial entre fatores tafonômicos, anomalias de desenvolvimento e casos patológicos nos crânios exumados do Sítio Furna do Estrago, Brejo da Madre de Deus, Pernambuco, BrasilCanindéYear: 2007102749
Yamaguti S,Systema helminthumYear: 1963New York: Interscience Publishers
Sloss MW,Kemp RL,Veterinary clinial parasitologyYear: 1978Iowa: Iowa State University Press
Garcia LS,Practical guide to Diagnostic ParasitologyYear: 2009Washington, D.C.: ASM Press
Saehoog P,Wongsawad C,Helminths in house lizards (Reptilia: Gekkonidae)Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public HealthYear: 1997281841899656374
Araújo A,Confalonieri U,Ferreira LF,Oxyurid infestations in small animals from 9.000 BP in BrazilPaleopathology NewsletterYear: 198031131411610747
Araújo A,Ferreira LF,Confalonieri U,Oxyurid (Nematoda) egg from coprolites from BrazilJ ParasitolYear: 19826851151210.2307/3280974
Rataj AV,Lindtner-Knific R,Vlahović K,Mavri U,Dovč A,Parasites in pet reptilesActa Vet ScandYear: 2011533310.1186/1751-0147-53-3321624124
Ávila RW,Silva RJ,Checklist of helminths from lizards and amphisbaenians (Reptilia, Squamata) of South AmericaJ Venom Anim Toxins Incl Trop DisYear: 20101654357210.1590/S1678-91992010000400005
Costa M,Tavares E,Anatomia foliar de Chenopodium ambrosioides L. (Chenopodiaceae) –erva-de-Santa MariaRev Bras Pl MedYear: 200686371
Mauseth J,Plant AnatomyYear: 1988Menlo Park: Benjamin/Cummings
Magnino S,Colin P,Dei-Cas E,Madsen M,McLauchlin J,Nockler K,Maradona MP,Tsigarida E,Vanopdenbosch E,Van Peteghem C,Biological risks associated with consumption of reptile productsInt J Food MicrobiolYear: 200913416317510.1016/j.ijfoodmicro.2009.07.00119679367
Rodrigues M,Silva J, Tabrelli M, Fonseca M, Lins L, Brasília DFFauna de anfíbios e répteis da caatingaBiodiversidade da Caatinga: áreas e ações prioritárias para conservaçãoYear: 2004Universidade Federal de Pernambuco: Ministério do Meio Ambiente175179
Rodrigues M,The conservation of brazilian reptiles: challenges for a megadiversity countryConserv BiolYear: 20051965966410.1111/j.1523-1739.2005.00690.x
Maciel M,Cultura e alimentação ou o que têm a ver os macaquinhos de Koshima com brillat-savarin?Horiz AntropolYear: 200116145156
Sutton M,Reinhard K,Cluster analysis of the coprolites from Antelope House: implications for Anasazi diet and cousineJ Archaeol SciYear: 19952274175010.1016/0305-4403(95)90004-7
Johnson KL,Reinhard KJ,Sianto L,Araújo A,Gardner SL,Janovy J Jr,A tick from a prehistoric Arizona coproliteJ ParasitolYear: 20089429629810.1645/GE-1059.118372655
Fry GF,Analysis of prehistoric coprolites from UtahYear: 1977Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press

Figures

[Figure ID: F1]
Figure 1 

Human coprolite found in burial dated between 1860 ± 50 and 1610 ± 70 years BP from archaeological site of Furna do Estrago, northeastern Brazil.



[Figure ID: F2]
Figure 2 

Pharyngodonidae eggs in human coprolites from northeastern Brazil.



[Figure ID: F3]
Figure 3 

Lizard scale found in human coprolite from burial dated 525 to 315 cal years BP, from archaeological site of Toca da Baixa dos Caboclos, northeastern Brazil.



Article Categories:
  • Short Report

Keywords: Paleoparasitology, Coprolite, Helminths, Lizard, Zoonosis.

Previous Document:  Microencapsulation of protein into biodegradable matrix: a smart solution cross-linking technique.
Next Document:  Health-related quality of life in survivors of stage I-II breast cancer: randomized trial of post-op...