Document Detail

Critical diaphragm failure in sudden infant death syndrome.
Jump to Full Text
MedLine Citation:
PMID:  21222555     Owner:  NLM     Status:  MEDLINE    
Sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) is the leading cause of death in infants between the ages of 1 and 12 months in developed countries. SIDS is by definition a diagnosis of exclusion, and its mechanism of action is unknown. The SIDS-Critical Diaphragm Failure (CDF) hypothesis postulates that the cause of death in SIDS is respiratory failure caused by CDF. Four principal risk factors contribute to CDF in young infants: undeveloped respiratory muscles, non-lethal infections, prone resting position, and REM sleep. Even relatively minor infections can cause an acute and significant reduction in diaphragm force generation capacity that in conjunction with other risk factors can precipitate CDF. CDF-induced acute muscle weakness leaves few, if any pathological marks on the affected tissue.Understanding the underlying mechanism of SIDS may help in formulating new approaches to child care that can help to further reduce the incidence of SIDS.
Pontus Max Axel Siren; Matti Juhani Siren
Related Documents :
6641565 - Neurological assessment of preterm infants at term conceptional age in comparison with ...
24043575 - The genesis of empathy in human development: a phenomenological reconstruction.
184425 - The effect of premature delivery on the development of gluconeogenic enzymes in the gui...
1643015 - The immunophenotype in infant acute lymphoblastic leukaemia: correlation with clinical ...
9200875 - Neonatal insulin secretion: implications for the programming of metabolic homeostasis.
6412205 - Development and differences of intestinal flora in the neonatal period in breast-fed an...
Publication Detail:
Type:  Journal Article     Date:  2011-01-12
Journal Detail:
Title:  Upsala journal of medical sciences     Volume:  116     ISSN:  2000-1967     ISO Abbreviation:  Ups. J. Med. Sci.     Publication Date:  2011 May 
Date Detail:
Created Date:  2011-04-13     Completed Date:  2011-07-28     Revised Date:  2013-07-02    
Medline Journal Info:
Nlm Unique ID:  0332203     Medline TA:  Ups J Med Sci     Country:  England    
Other Details:
Languages:  eng     Pagination:  115-23     Citation Subset:  IM    
JGK Memorial Research Library, Snellmanin k 15, 00170, Helsinki, Finland.
Export Citation:
APA/MLA Format     Download EndNote     Download BibTex
MeSH Terms
Bacterial Infections / physiopathology
Diaphragm / physiopathology*
Infant, Newborn
Melatonin / physiology
Mitochondria / physiology
Risk Factors
Sudden Infant Death / pathology*
Reg. No./Substance:
Comment In:
Ups J Med Sci. 2013 May;118(2):143-4   [PMID:  23570456 ]
Ups J Med Sci. 2011 Aug;116(3):220   [PMID:  21671726 ]

From MEDLINE®/PubMed®, a database of the U.S. National Library of Medicine

Full Text
Journal Information
Journal ID (nlm-ta): Ups J Med Sci
Journal ID (publisher-id): UPS
ISSN: 0300-9734
ISSN: 2000-1967
Publisher: Informa Healthcare
Article Information
Download PDF
© Upsala Medical Society
Received Day: 02 Month: 12 Year: 2010
Accepted Day: 10 Month: 12 Year: 2010
Print publication date: Month: 5 Year: 2011
Electronic publication date: Day: 12 Month: 4 Year: 2011
Volume: 116 Issue: 2
First Page: 115 Last Page: 123
ID: 3078540
PubMed Id: 21222555
DOI: 10.3109/03009734.2010.548011
Publisher Id: UPS_A_548011_O

Critical diaphragm failure in sudden infant death syndrome
Pontus Max Axel SirenAF0001
Matti Juhani SirenAF0001
JGK Memorial Research Library, Helsinki, Finland
Correspondence: Correspondence: Pontus Max Axel Siren, JGK Memorial Research Library, Snellmanin k 15, 00170, Helsinki, Finland. +358 9 241 40 55.


It has been recognized since antiquity that seemingly healthy infants can die suddenly and for no obvious reason during their sleep. Indeed, the Bible makes reference to such an incidence in the First Book of Kings. One of the first known medical autopsies of an apparent sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) case was conducted by Samuel Fearn and published in the Lancet in 1834 (1). In his short communication, Fearn asked a simple question that has frustrated generations of doctors and researchers: ‘what was the cause of death?’ Over 175 years later the question is still unanswered (2). SIDS has been the target of an enormous research effort, with over 9,500 scientific articles published on the subject (3), but it remains one of the most mysterious disorders in medicine.

Our primary research interest, cancer cachexia (4), gave us a singular perspective into SIDS, and we formulated the SIDS–Critical Diaphragm Failure (CDF) hypothesis to answer Fearn's original question. It is perhaps surprising that research areas unrelated to SIDS could contribute meaningfully to the understanding of this complex syndrome, and yet there is a large body of experimental and clinical evidence that suggests that the cause of death in SIDS is respiratory failure caused by CDF. We argue that four factors contribute to CDF in SIDS: undeveloped respiratory muscles, non-lethal infections, prone resting position, and REM sleep. Infants younger than 6 months have undeveloped respiratory muscles that are susceptible to CDF, because even minor infections can precipitate a significant reduction in the diaphragm force generation capacity. The prone sleeping position significantly increases the diaphragm work-load, and the intercostal muscles that usually provide respiratory support are inactivated in REM sleep. The non-monotonic mortality rate of SIDS is explained by the passive maternal antibodies that effectively attenuate infections during the first month of life, and rapid development of the infant diaphragm that reaches the same fiber composition and pressure generation capacity as the adult muscle approximately 6 months post partum.


Research has identified over 40 potential SIDS risk factors (5), making the investigation of the syndrome extremely complicated. However, the salient and uncontentious characteristics of SIDS are well known; it affects fewer than 1 in 1000 live births in the developed world and is associated with sleep, a bell-shaped mortality incidence rate (peak age 2–4 months), premature and low-birth-weight infants, male gender (60% of cases), episodes of non-lethal infections, and the prone sleeping position (6–8). So far, no convincing genetic or congenital mechanism for SIDS has been identified.

SIDS is by definition a diagnosis of exclusion that has no identifiable cause of death. However, it is generally accepted that sudden death that is not caused by trauma must be due to either respiratory or circulatory failure (9). Clinical observations, heartrate, and respiratory recording of infants who subsequently succumb to SIDS and animal models strongly suggest a respiratory pathway for the syndrome (2).The absence of any obvious defects or abnormalities in the lungs or inspiratory muscles has led to the conclusion that respiratory failure in SIDS must be caused either by a dysfunctional control system (2,10) or upper airway obstruction (11). However, the dysfunctional respiratory control system hypothesis fails to explain many of the salient features of SIDS (6), and studies have found no significant respiratory abnormalities in infants who subsequently die of SIDS (12,13). Furthermore, both human and animal studies (14–17) suggest that upper airway occlusion is not a precipitating factor in SIDS, and obstructive apnea as the cause of SIDS is arguably doubtful.

The respiratory failure hypothesis is still favored by many SIDS researchers (11), but so far no convincing mechanism has been identified. Surprisingly, the possible role of the diaphragm in the etiology of SIDS has been largely ignored. In October 2010, there were only 41 PubMed hits with the search words ‘SIDS and diaphragm’ from a total of over 9,500 SIDS articles (18). Yet, the diaphragm is the main respiratory muscle, and as Muller and Bryan observe ‘respiratory failure is frequently respiratory muscle failure’ (19).

Diaphragm and survival

Two muscles are essential for human survival, and while the vital role of the heart is obvious, the diaphragm is often overlooked. The diaphragm is a thin muscle that is shaped like a parachute and that separates the thoracic from the abdominal cavity. It is the main engine of the vital respiratory pump (20), and its contraction is critical for intrathoracic pressure generation (21). Anraku and Shargall note that ‘in adults, the diaphragm represents less than 0.5% of body-weight, but it is the most important muscle in the human body after the heart’. The incapacitation of supportive respiratory muscles, such as the intercostals, is not lethal, but bilateral diaphragm paralysis usually results in respiratory failure (22). The adult diaphragm can generate indefinitely approximately 40% of its maximum transdiaphragmatic pressure (Pdimax) (23), but it is susceptible to critical fatigue in certain conditions. Macklem succinctly observes that ‘the inspiratory muscles form a pump just as vital as the heart, and this pump can and does fail in much the same manner as the heart fails’ (20). In adults, respiratory muscle weakness is one of the most common causes of ventilatory failure (24).

We argue that the diaphragm is the locus minoris resistentiae in SIDS. The young infant has undeveloped secondary respiratory muscles, and the diaphragm is responsible for the majority of respiratory work (25). Assuming the same relative organ proportions as in the adult, a normal neonate weighing 3000 g would have a diaphragm that weighs approximately 12 g and is approximately 2 mm thick (26). Indeed, roughly similar dimensions are observed in preterm infants weighing between 1260 g and 2100 g who have diaphragms that are between 1.09 (±0.08) and 1.74 (±0.04) mm thick (27). An increase in diaphragm size correlates directly with inspiratory force (28), and full-term infants reach adult levels of Pdimax at approximately 6 months of age (25). The diaphragm in young infants is also structurally immature and significantly more susceptible to fatigue than a fully developed muscle. A premature infant's diaphragm consists of only 10%fatigue-resistant type I fibers. The diaphragm of a full-term infant has 25% type I fibers, increasing to 40% at 3 months and to 50%–55% (adult share) (22) by the age of 7–8 months (19).The younger the infant, the smaller the oxidative capacity of the respiratory muscles and the higher the risk for ventilatory muscle fatigue (19). We suggest this may be a reason why low-birth-weight or premature infants have up to four times the risk of SIDS compared to full-term neonates (8). Overall, the respiratory muscles of the young infant appear to be poorly equipped to sustain increased work-loads. Muller and colleagues argue that ‘the normal preterm and term infant is very close to the threshold of diaphragmatic fatigue’ (29). Indeed, fatigue patterns can readily be observed if the work of breathing is increased in young infants (30). Still, some authors have suggested that the infant diaphragm is not at increased risk of fatigue and that it may be even more fatigue-resistant than the adult inspiratory muscle (31). We do not believe this contention is well supported by the existing evidence. However, even those who disagree about the relative fatigue risk of the infant diaphragm agreed that it can and does fatigue under certain conditions.

Infection-induced acute diaphragm weakness

The central argument of the SIDS–CDF hypothesis is that even minor infections can cause a rapid and significant reduction in diaphragm strength. Respiratory muscle performance can decline for two reasons: due to a reduction in total muscle mass or due to a decline in muscle force generation capacity (32). The loss of muscle mass is an incremental process and is usually associated with chronic diseases such as cancer. The reduction of force generation capacity is associated with acute conditions such as sepsis where muscle strength can decline significantly within hours. We propose that an acute decline in muscle force-generating capacity is primarily responsible for CDF in SIDS cases. A large body of evidence strongly suggests that various types of infections, both viral and bacterial, can cause a significant and acute reduction in diaphragm force-generating capacity. Importantly, even minor infections can significantly reduce diaphragm strength without affecting muscle mass or histology.

Acute infections were shown to reduce significantly skeletal muscle strength in 1977 (33). Since then, numerous human and animal studies have shown that infections can induce severe diaphragm and secondary respiratory muscle weakness (34,35), whereas the cardiac muscle does not appear to be similarly vulnerable (36). Standardized endotoxins are often used to study diaphragm force reduction (37–39), but a broad range of pathogens, both viral and bacterial, has a similar effect. Human studies and animal models have shown that significant diaphragm weakness can be induced by endotoxin injection (40), bronchopulmonary infection (41), septic peritonitis (42), parasitic infection (43), and pathogens such as Escherichia coli (44), group B Streptococcus (45), Streptococcus pneumoniae (S) (46), Pseudomonas aeruginosa (41), Bordetella pertussis (47), Phlebovirus (48), as well as factors associated with upper respiratory tract infection (49). A case study of an infant with vulnerable respiratory muscles illustrates the point. The patient exhibited diaphragm muscle dystrophy as the sole anomaly and suffered from episodes of severe respiratory distress that required mechanical ventilation to sustain life (50). Interestingly, these episodes occurred only during Staphylococcus aureus or Haemophilus influenzae infections. The evidence cited above strongly suggests that various pathogens, both viral and bacterial in origin, can precipitate a significant reduction in the ventilatory capacity of the diaphragm.

It is well known that systemic infection can lead to severe loss of diaphragm strength and respiratory failure (51). However, also less severe infections can cause a significant reduction in the force-generating capacity of the diaphragm. Animal studies have shown that non-lethal sepsis induced by either Streptococcus pneumoniae or E. coli with no change in blood pressure, serum electrolytes, or acid status caused a significant impairment of diaphragm function (52). In human adults, Mier-Jedrzejowicz and co-workers observed already in 1988 that pulmonary function can deteriorate significantly (P < 0.05) after even apparently mild respiratory infections (53). In patients with vulnerable respiratory systems, routine infections have been shown to result in shortness of breath, reduction in vital capacity, and acute hypercapnia (49). Supinski and colleagues recently concluded that in vulnerable populations, ‘increasing evidence indicates that even minor infections can produce profound reductions in diaphragmatic force-generating capacity’ (54). A large body of experimental evidence supports this observation (34,41,43,55–58). It is important to note that the degree of diaphragmatic force reduction is determined not only by the intensity of the infectious assault but also by the immune and the developmental status of the host (41,45). Fundamentally, terms such as ‘lethal’ or ‘minor’ used to characterize infections are always relative.

Infections can reduce the force-generating capacity of the diaphragm by 50% in as little as 24 hours (54), and lead to severe respiratory muscle dysfunction and respiratory failure (45). In a study on human adults with routine upper respiratory tract infection, diaphragm strength fell significantly (P < 0.01), with the largest decline occurring between days 3 and 7 of clinical illness (53). Full recovery of respiratory pressure took place by day 14. Numerous other studies show that a significant reduction in diaphragm strength can occur within 1 to 48 h of infection indicating that a significant decline in the performance of the main respiratory muscle can occur very rapidly (34,41,42,49,51,59). However, infection-induced muscle force reduction is an acute but temporary event, and the diaphragm can recover its normal function relatively quickly. This may explain why near-SIDS cases do not manifest diaphragmatic weakness (60).

Animal models using either Streptococcus pneumoniae or E. coli endotoxin show that non-lethal sepsis impairs diaphragm function without affecting muscle mass or histology (46,61). Supinski and Callahan have observed that ‘24 h after administration of endotoxin, diaphragm specific force had fallen by 50% without any reduction in diaphragm muscle mass or diaphragm protein content, obvious depletion of major diaphragm protein bands or specific loss of myosin or actin stores’ (57). Sepsis reduces muscle strength long before contractile protein levels decline significantly (34). Others have reported similar results (62,63), confirming that even though infections can cause acute and severe diaphragm dysfunction, they leave few, if any pathological marks in the affected tissue. These findings are of some importance, because the absence of significant pathophysiological abnormalities in the inspiratory musculature of SIDS cases has led to the erroneous conclusion that the diaphragm does not play a role in the etiology of the syndrome (10).

The one pathological finding that characterizes over 70% of SIDS cases is intrathoracic petechiae (64).Goldwater reported recently that SIDS cases demonstrate intrathoracic petechial hemorrhages in the thymus (89.5%), pleura (80%), and epicardium (79.9%) (16). SIDS-related intrathoracic petechiae are not characteristic of asphyxia, strangulation (16), upper airway obstruction (17), or cardiac arrest (64). Rather, experimental evidence suggests that an infection together with gasping or a ‘struggle to breathe’ episode is required for the formation of characteristic intrathoracic petechial hemorrhages (17,65). Interestingly, the clinical signs of respiratory muscle fatigue are rapid shallow breathing, paradoxic chest wall/abdominal movements, and respiratory pauses combined with hyperventilation (20,66).

The data presented above strongly suggest that even minor infections can cause a significant and rapid reduction in diaphragm force-generating capacity without affecting muscle mass or histology. Surprisingly, the pathophysiological implications of infection-induced acute diaphragmatic weakness have not been previously considered in the context of SIDS even though it is well known that young infants have undeveloped and potentially vulnerable respiratory muscles.

Mitochondrial dysfunction and the role of melatonin in SIDS

The molecular mechanisms behind infection-induced acute diaphragm weakness have been actively investigated. Systemic infection displays consistent similarities to the pathogenesis of SIDS (67), and can induce a significant (P < 0.001) reduction in the mitochondrial function (e.g. ATP-generating capacity) of the diaphragm muscle tissue (68). There is substantial evidence that excessive free-radical generation plays a central role in infection-induced myopathy and causes mitochondrial impairment. Infection causes significant changes in oxidative phosphorylation and induces the selective depletion of several electron transport chains in the respiratory muscles (32). Newborns and infants born prematurely are especially prone to oxidative stress because they are exposed to high oxygen concentrations and have reduced antioxidant defense mechanisms and high levels of free iron that are required for the Fenton reaction (69). Existing evidence strongly suggests that infections can produce rapid and profound alterations in the mitochondrial function of the diaphragm and severely disrupt its energy metabolism.

Melatonin (N-acetyl-5-methoxytryptamine) is a highly conserved small amphiphilic molecule that is biosynthesized from tryptophan. Serotonin is converted to melatonin in the pineal gland by arylalkylamine N-acetyltransferase (AA-NAT) and hydroxyindole O-methyltransferase (HIOMT) (70). Serotonin is a rate-limiting factor for melatonin. Melatonin has been shown to protect against oxidative stress in various divergent experimental systems (71). It is a highly effective antioxidant and free-radical scavenger that can significantly attenuate mitochondrial failure and preserve cell function and survival (72–74). In the clinical setting, melatonin has been shown to improve the clinical outcome in the septic newborn (75). Gitto and colleagues observe that ‘several clinical studies that used melatonin showed that it reduces oxidative stress in newborns with sepsis, distress or other conditions where there is excessive ROS/RNS (reactive oxygen species/reactive nitrogen species) production’(69). However, young infants exhibit transient melatonin deficiency for the first 2–4 months of life (76).

Pineal dysfunction and impaired melatonin metabolism have been associated with SIDS (77,78). Sturner and colleagues examined melatonin levels from the ventricular cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) in SIDS deaths compared to non-SIDS cases. After adjusting for age differences, melatonin levels were significantly (P < 0.05) lower among the SIDS infants (91 ± 29 pmol/L; n = 32) than among those dying of other causes (180 ± 27; n = 35) (79). Young infants who experienced a life-threatening event (ALTE) demonstrated significantly (P < 0.05) lower urinary excretion of the main melatonin metabolite 6-sulfatoxymelatonin compared to controls (1588 ng/24 h versus 3961 ng/24 h) (80). Serotonergic deficiency has repeatedly been associated with SIDS (81), suggesting that the role of the tryptophan–serotonin–melatonin pathway in the etiology of SIDS should be further investigated.

The prone sleeping position and SIDS

A change in the recommended sleeping position for young infants from prone to supine has reduced SIDS deaths worldwide between 40% (Argentina) and 83% (Ireland) (2). SIDS can occur in the supine resting position, but any hypothesis regarding the etiology of SIDS must convincingly explain why the prone sleeping position is such a significant risk factor.

The effects of the prone sleeping position on diaphragm function have been considered previously (82). The hypothesis that the prone sleeping position significantly increases the work-load of the diaphragm was tested by Rehan and co-workers in a study with 16 healthy infants (83). The study showed that in the prone position the diaphragm is significantly thicker and, therefore, shorter at the end of both expiratory (EEV) and inspiratory lung volumes (EIV). The shortening of any muscle produces a marked fall in the maximal tension it can develop (19), indicating that the inspiratory muscle force of the diaphragm decreases as it shortens. Indeed, Rehan and colleagues note that ‘this degree of diaphragm shortening is similar to that seen with an increase in lung volume of 15%–30% of vital capacity’. Such increases in EEV can significantly impair diaphragm performance, and, as Rehan and colleagues conclude, ‘in adults, diaphragm strength and endurance as well as the efficiency of breathing are reduced by 40%–50% with this magnitude of increase in lung volume’. Greenough and colleagues have reported similar results in several clinical studies with premature infants and observe that respiratory muscle strength is significantly reduced in the prone compared to the supine position in (106–108).

Interestingly, an earlier study that measured infant breathing did not find significant differences in ventilatory performance as a function of sleep position (84). However, the study reported a significant increase (+66%) in rib-cage motion in the prone compared with the supine position. Others have observed that due to the high rib-cage compliance in young infants, the thorax motion increases either during deep inspiratory effort or when the intercostals are inactivated (31). As both the sleep position studies were conducted during non-REM (NREM) sleep when the intercostals are active, it is possible that the significantly increased thoracic motion in the prone position was due to increased diaphragm work needed to maintain ventilation pressure at the same level as in the supine position. Indeed, in another study with healthy infants sleeping in the prone position, chest wall distortion during REM sleep led to the reduction of the tidal volume, but ventilation was upheld by significantly (P < 0.01) increasing the work-load of the diaphragm (85). We suggest that healthy infants with normal diaphragms can easily tolerate the added mechanical strain that the prone position imposes on the diaphragm. However, for some infants the prone sleeping position combined with an infectious episode can increase the risk of CDF.

Why is SIDS associated with sleep?

SIDS deaths often take place between midnight and 6 a.m. (5,86), and there is a close temporal relationship between SIDS and sleep (87). The original name for SIDS, ‘cot death’, reflects this basic observation. The reason for the preponderance of SIDS deaths during sleep is unclear, and while we should remember that newborns sleep up to 20 hours per day, there seems to be a causal link between sleep and SIDS. A premature infant spends up to 80% and a 3-month-old approximately 38% of his sleep in the REM phase (19). It is well known that the intercostals muscles show both phasic and tonic inhibition during REM sleep that renders them largely or totally inactive, and that this has a significant effect on respiratory function(31,88–90). The intercostals play a central role in stabilizing the thorax, and, as Davis and Bureau note, ‘chest wall muscles are critical for ventilation in the infant with a pliable chest wall’ (66). Others have suggested that the inactivation of the intercostals during REM sleep may be a contributing factor in SIDS (82). We argue that the inactivation of the intercostal muscles in combination with other factors can increase the risk of CDF.

The internal and external intercostal muscles are activated to attenuate diaphragm fatigue (19,91,92). In a study with preterm infants, diaphragm fatigue was followed either by a 50%–150% increase in intercostal activity or apnea that lasted 10–30 s and often required stimulation (93). In full-term infants, diaphragm fatigue provokes similar responses: the intercostal muscles are activated to support the respiratory effort or apnea lasting 5–20 s ensues (followed by intercostal muscle activation) (91). In another study, the diaphragmatic work-load in the young infant increased by over 150% (P < 0.001) during REM sleep (29). Diaphragmatic fatigue patterns were observed only in REM sleep together with marked reductions in intercostal activity and rib-cage retraction. In the young infant intercostal muscle support is even more important than in the adult because their rib-cage is mostly cartilaginous and significantly more compliant compared to adults. If the intercostals do not stabilize the rib-cage during inspiration, a significant portion of the power generated by the diaphragm will be wasted sucking in the ribs rather than fresh air (94), and to maintain the same tidal volume the work of the diaphragm has to increase substantially (88). This increased respiratory work-load may contribute to diaphragm fatigue.

The studies discussed above suggest that REM sleep is associated with increased diaphragmatic work-load and respiratory muscle fatigue in normal infants. Importantly, a fatigued diaphragm can be relieved only by decreasing the respiratory work-load or by activating the intercostals. If the critically fatigued muscle is not supported by the secondary respiratory muscles, ventilatory efficiency and muscle oxygenation will progressively decline and the risk of respiratory failure increases.

The bell-shaped mortality rate in SIDS

One of the more puzzling aspects of SIDS is the bell-shaped mortality incidence rate. SIDS seems closely related to the developmental status of the infant, because 95% of the cases occur before the age of 6 months, and SIDS is rare in infants 1 year and older. Paradoxically, SIDS is also rare in infants younger than 1 month (5). SIDS clearly has a different type of mortality incidence rate compared to the monotonic distribution in congenital anomalies (6). Others have argued that bacterial toxins cause SIDS and that maternal antibodies can protect the infant during the first months of life (95). We suggest that the bell-shaped mortality distribution of SIDS is due to the passive immune protection maternal antibodies provide during the first month of life when the respiratory muscles are most vulnerable.

The age profile of SIDS deaths is reciprocal to infants' serum concentrations of immunoglobulin (96), and maternal antibodies can increase the immune resistance of neonates during the first months of life (97,98). Infants have varying levels of passive immune protection because the maternal antibody concentration determines the neonatal titer at birth (99). Full-term infants seem to have higher antibody titers than premature ones (100). However, the passive immune protection wanes relatively rapidly in all neonates. A study with 213 mother–infant pairs showed that the mean time to immunity loss for rubella and varicella was 2.1 months and 2.4 months, respectively (101). For measles the maternal antibodies endured for a median of 2.6 months (99). Maternal antibodies to the Varicellazoster virus (VZV) had a median half-life of 25.5 days in neonates (range 14.6–76.0 days) (102). Another study showed that 26% of infants had potentially protective antibody levels against pertussis (whooping cough) at delivery, but by week 6 nearly 90% had lost most of the original maternal antibodies (103). These and other studies (104,105) suggest that neonates can benefit from passive maternal immune factors for 1–2 months post partum but that the temporary immune protection wanes relatively quickly.

Concluding remarks

We propose that the cause of death in SIDS is respiratory failure caused by CDF. It is well known that young infants have potentially vulnerable diaphragms and that infections can produce severe respiratory muscle dysfunction. We argue that ‘non-lethal’ infections are the main cause of CDF in SIDS. As such, there is no specific underlying genetic or congenital vulnerability in SIDS infants, and completely normal infants can die of SIDS. However, infants with weak or underdeveloped respiratory muscles who spend a large portion of the day in REM sleep and are exposed to infections are at increased risk. Dysfunctional melatonin metabolism may also be a contributing factor in SIDS. By definition, the infections associated with SIDS are not considered to be lethal, but they can cause a significant and acute loss of diaphragm strength. Additional stressors such as the prone sleeping position and REM sleep can move the infant closer to CDF and precipitate respiratory failure. Diagnosing CDF-precipitated respiratory failure is challenging because it usually does not affect muscle mass or histology.

An obvious question that the SIDS–CDF hypothesis might raise is that if young infants have vulnerable respiratory muscles and even minor infections can cause significant loss of diaphragm strength, why is SIDS not more common? Diaphragm fatigue is not the same as diaphragm failure, and while young infants are susceptible to CDF, they also have effective defense mechanisms that help preserve respiratory function. First, the immune system actively attenuates the negative effects of infectious assaults. Second, the activation of the intercostal muscles can decrease the respiratory burden and support a fatigued diaphragm. Third, the diaphragm develops rapidly, and by age 6 months has the same distribution of fatigue-resistant fibers and pressure-generating capacity as the adult muscle. Thus, moving from diaphragm fatigue to CDF usually requires a relatively rare combination of events that include an infectious episode, insufficient immune response, undeveloped respiratory muscles, continuous REM sleep, and often a prone resting position. Even if all these factors are present, the fatigued diaphragm may be rescued by altering the sleep state and activating the secondary respiratory muscles.

The clinical impact of an infection is dependent on its intensity as well as the immune and developmental status of the host. A potent infection can alone be lethal to a young infant, but a less severe infection will be dangerous only in conjunction with other factors. Yet, diagnosing an apparently ‘non-lethal’ infection as the cause of death is by definition a contradiction in terms. In a sense, a SIDS diagnosis reflects the failure to understand that apparently ‘minor’ infections can be fatal to some infants in certain circumstances. If the causes of infant mortality can be accurately ascribed, SIDS may no longer be needed as a diagnosis.This goal should be pursued in the spirit of Fearn's original question.


The authors dedicate this work to the memory of Pirkko and Jorma Gallen-Kallela. We also wish to acknowledge the critical role of information technology in enabling and empowering the revolution in global collaborative innovation. Our research would not have been possible without it.

Declaration of interest: The authors report no conflicts of interest. The authors alone are responsible for the content and writing of the paper.

1.. Fearn SW. Sudden and unexplained death of childrenLancetYear: 183423246
2.. Kinney HC,Thach BT. The sudden infant death syndromeN Engl J MedYear: 200936179580519692691
3.. PubMed search 15 October 2010.
4.. Siren PMA,Siren MJ. Systemic zinc redistribution and dyshomeostasis in cancer cachexiaJ Cachexia Sarcopenia MuscleYear: 201012333
5.. Sullivan FM,Barlow SM. Review of risk factors for sudden infant death syndromePaediatr Perinat EpidemiolYear: 20011514420011383580
6.. Guntheroth WG,Spiers PS. The triple risk hypotheses in sudden infant death syndromePediatricsYear: 2002110e6412415070
7.. Mitchell EA. SIDS: past, present and futureActa PaediatrYear: 20099817121919807704
8.. Moon RY,Horne RS,Hauck FR. Sudden infant death syndromeLancetYear: 200737015788717980736
9.. Hunt CE. The cardiorespiratory control hypothesis for sudden infant death syndromeClin PerinatolYear: 199219757711464189
10.. Fleming PJ,Levine MR,Long AM,Cleave JP. Postneonatal development of respiratory oscillationsAnn N Y Acad SciYear: 1988533305133421633
11.. Thach BT. The role of respiratory control disorders in SIDSRespir Physiol NeurobiolYear: 20051493435316122993
12.. Waggener TB,Southall DP,Scott LA. Analysis of breathing patterns in a prospective population of term infants does not predict susceptibility to sudden infant death syndromePediatr ResYear: 199027113172314938
13.. Schechtman VL,Harper RM,Wilson AJ,Southall DP. Sleep apnea in infants who succumb to the sudden infant death syndromePediatricsYear: 19918784162034488
14.. Poets CF,Meny RG,Chobanian MR,Bonofiglo RE. Gasping and other cardiorespiratory patterns during sudden infant deathsPediatr ResYear: 199945350410088653
15.. French JW,Beckwith JB,Graham CB,Guntheroth WG. Lack of postmortem radiographic evidence of nasopharyngeal obstruction in the sudden infant death syndromeJ PediatrYear: 197281114584643034
16.. Goldwater PN. Intrathoracic petechial hemorrhages in sudden infant death syndrome and other infant deaths: time for re-examinationPediatr Dev PatholYear: 200811450518416633
17.. Guntheroth WG,Kawabori I,Breazeale DG,Garlinghouse LE Jr,Van Hoosier GL Jr. The role of respiratory infection in intrathoracic petechiae. Implications for sudden infant deathAm J Dis ChildYear: 198013436466245575
18.. Pubmed search 15 October 2010.
19.. Muller NL,Bryan AC. Chest wall mechanics and respiratory muscles in infantsPediatr Clin North AmYear: 19792650316386235
20.. Macklem PT. Respiratory muscles: the vital pumpChestYear: 19807875387428459
21.. Celli BR. Respiratory management of diaphragm paralysisSemin Respir Crit Care MedYear: 2002232758116088620
22.. Anraku M,Shargall Y. Surgical conditions of the diaphragm: anatomy and physiologyThorac Surg ClinYear: 2009194192920112625
23.. Roussos CS,Macklem PT. Diaphragmatic fatigue in manJ Appl PhysiolYear: 19774318997893274
24.. Rochester DF. Respiratory muscles and ventilatory failure: 1993 perspectiveAm J Med SciYear: 19933053944028506901
25.. Nichols DG. Respiratory muscle performance in infants and childrenJ PediatrYear: 19911184935022007920
26.. Arora NS,Rochester DF. COPD and human diaphragm muscle dimensionsChestYear: 198791719243568775
27.. Rehan VK,Laiprasert J,Wallach M,Rubin LP,McCool FD. Diaphragm dimensions of the healthy preterm infantPediatricsYear: 2001108E9111694675
28.. Watchko JF,Mayock DE,Standaert TA,Woodrum DE. Postnatal changes in transdiaphragmatic pressure in pigletsPediatr ResYear: 198620658613725464
29.. Muller N,Gulston G,Cade D,Whitton J,Froese AB,Bryan MH,et al. Diaphragmatic muscle fatigue in the newbornJ Appl PhysiolYear: 19794668895457547
30.. Keens TG,Bryan AC,Levison H,Ianuzzo CD. Developmental pattern of muscle fiber types in human ventilatory musclesJ Appl PhysiolYear: 19784490913149779
31.. Watchko JF,Mayock DE,Standaert TA,Woodrum DE. The ventilatory pump: neonatal and developmental issuesAdv PediatrYear: 199138109341927697
32.. Callahan LA,Supinski GS. Sepsis-induced myopathyCrit Care MedYear: 200937S3546720046121
33.. Friman G. Effect of acute infectious disease on isometric muscle strengthScand J Clin Lab InvestYear: 1977373038616056
34.. Supinski GS,Vanags J,Callahan LA. Effect of proteasome inhibitors on endotoxin-induced diaphragm dysfunctionAm J Physiol Lung Cell Mol PhysiolYear: 2009296L994100119376888
35.. Supinski GS,Ji X,Callahan LA. The JNKMAP kinase pathway contributes to the development of endotoxin-induced diaphragm caspase activationAm J Physiol Regul Integr Comp PhysiolYear: 2009297R8253419605759
36.. Supinski G,Nethery D,Stofan D,Di Marco A. Comparison of the effects of endotoxin on limb, respiratory, and cardiac musclesJ Appl PhysiolYear: 199681137088889776
37.. Supinski GS,Nethery D,Di Marco AF. Endotoxin induces free radical mediated diaphragm and intercostal muscle dysfunctionAm Rev Respir DisYear: 19931481318248239170
38.. Boczkowski J,Lanone S,Ungureanu-Longrois D,Danialou G,Fournier T,Aubier M. Induction of diaphragmatic nitric oxide synthase after endotoxin administration in rats: role on diaphragmatic contractile dysfunctionJ Clin InvestYear: 199698155098833903
39.. Callahan LA,Supinski GS. Diaphragm and cardiac mitochondrial creatine kinases are impaired in sepsisJ Appl PhysiolYear: 2007102445316916915
40.. Supinski G,Nethery D,Nosek TM,Callahan LA,Stofan D,Di Marco A. Endotoxin administration alters the force vs. pCa relationship of skeletal muscle fibersAm J Physiol Regul Integr Comp PhysiolYear: 2000278R891610749776
41.. Divangahi M,Matecki S,Dudley RW,Tuck SA,Bao W,Radzioch D,et al. Preferential diaphragmatic weakness during sustained Pseudomonas aeruginosa lung infectionAm J Respir Crit Care MedYear: 20041696798614670804
42.. Fujimura N,Sumita S,Aimono M,Masuda Y,Shichinohe Y,Narimatsu E,et al. Effect of free radical scavengers on diaphragmatic contractility in septic peritonitisAm J Respir Crit Care MedYear: 200016221596511112131
43.. Drew JS,Farkas GA,Pearson RD,Rochester DF. Effects of a chronic wasting infection on skeletal muscle size and contractile propertiesJ Appl PhysiolYear: 19886446053356664
44.. Comtois AS,Barreiro E,Huang PL,Marette A,Perrault M,Hussain SN. Lipopolysaccharide-induced diaphragmatic contractile dysfunction and sarcolemmal injury in mice lacking the neuronal nitric oxide synthaseAm J Respir Crit Care MedYear: 20011639778211282776
45.. Murphy TD,Gibson RL,Standaert TA,Woodrum DE. Diaphragmatic failure during group B streptococcal sepsis in piglets: the role of thromboxane A2J Appl PhysiolYear: 19957849187759417
46.. Boczkowski J,Dureuil B,Branger C,Pavlovic D,Murciano D,Pariente R,et al. Effects of sepsis on diaphragmatic function in ratsAm Rev Respir DisYear: 198813826053195825
47.. Toutant M,Barhanin J,Bockaert J,Rouot B. G-proteins in skeletal muscle. Evidence for a 40 kDa pertussis-toxin substrate in purified transverse tubulesBiochem JYear: 198825440593140802
48.. Friman G,Wright JE,Ilbäck NG,Beisel WR,White JD,Sharp DS,Stephen EL,et al. Does fever or myalgia indicate reduced physical performance capacity in viral infections?Acta Med ScandYear: 1985217353614013826
49.. Poponick JM,Jacobs I,Supinski G,DiMarco AF. Effect of upper respiratory tract infection in patients with neuromuscular diseaseAm J Respir Crit Care MedYear: 1997156659649279255
50.. Leyten QH,Renier WO,Gabreëls FJ,terLaak HJ,Hinkofer LH. Dystrophic myopathy of the diaphragm in a neonate with severe respiratory failure during infectious episodesNeuromuscul DisordYear: 199335158329889
51.. Hussain SN,Simkus G,Roussos C. Respiratory muscle fatigue: a cause of ventilatory failure in septic shockJ Appl PhysiolYear: 1985582033403891717
52.. Lanone S,Taillé C,Boczkowski J,Aubier M. Diaphragmatic fatigue during sepsis and septic shockIntensive Care MedYear: 20053116111716189683
53.. Mier-Jedrzejowicz A,Brophy C,Green M. Respiratory muscle weakness during upper respiratory tract infectionsAm Rev Respir DisYear: 1988138573202399
54.. Supinski GS,Wang W,Callahan LA. Caspase and calpain activation both contribute to sepsis-induced diaphragmatic weaknessJ Appl PhysiolYear: 200910713899619661453
55.. Callahan LA,Nethery D,Stofan D,DiMarco A,Supinski G. Free radical-induced contractile protein dysfunction in endotoxin-induced sepsisAm J Respir Cell Mol BiolYear: 2001242101711159056
56.. Laghi F,Tobin MJ. Disorders of the respiratory musclesAm J Respir Crit Care MedYear: 2003168104812826594
57.. Supinski GS,Callahan LA. Caspase activation contributes to endotoxin-induced diaphragm weaknessJ Appl PhysiolYear: 20061001770716484358
58.. Uzuki M,Yamakage M,Fujimura N,Namiki A. Direct inotropic effect of the beta-2 receptor agonist terbutaline on impaired diaphragmatic contractility in septic ratsHeart LungYear: 200736140717362795
59.. Murphy TD,Gibson RL,Standaert TA,Mayock DE,Woodrum DE. Effect of group B streptococcal sepsis on diaphragmatic function in young pigletsPediatr ResYear: 19933310148433854
60.. Scott CB,Nickerson BG,Sargent CW,Dennies PC,Platzker AC,Keens TG. Diaphragm strength in near-miss sudden infant death syndromePediatricsYear: 19826978247079044
61.. Boczkowski J,Dureuil B,Pariente R,Aubier M. Preventive effects of indomethacin on diaphragmatic contractile alterations in endotoxemic ratsAm Rev Respir DisYear: 199014219382195931
62.. Reid MB,Lännergren J,Westerblad H. Respiratory and limb muscle weakness induced by tumor necrosis factor-alpha: involvement of muscle myofilamentsAm J Respir Crit Care MedYear: 20021664798412186824
63.. Brealey D,Karyampudi S,Jacques TS,Novelli M,Stidwill R,Taylor V,,et al. Mitochondrial dysfunction in a long-term rodent model of sepsis and organ failureAm J Physiol Regul Integr Comp PhysiolYear: 2004286R491714604843
64.. Beckwith JB. Intrathoracic petechial hemorrhages: a clue to the mechanism of death in sudden infant death syndrome?Ann N Y Acad SciYear: 198853337473048177
65.. Campbell CJ,Read DJ. Circulatory and respiratory factors in the experimental production of lung petechiae and their possible significance in the sudden infant death syndromePathologyYear: 19801218187413252
66.. Davis GM,Bureau MA. Pulmonary and chest wall mechanics in the control of respiration in the newbornClin PerinatolYear: 198714551793311539
67.. Highet AR,Berry AM,Bettelheim KA,Goldwater PN. The frequency of molecular detection of virulence genes encoding cytolysin A, high-pathogenicity island and cytolethal distending toxin of Escherichia coli in cases of sudden infant death syndrome does not differ from that in other infant deaths and healthy infantsJ Med MicrobiolYear: 200958285919208875
68.. Supinski GS,Callahan LA. Hemin prevents cardiac and diaphragm mitochondrial dysfunction in sepsisFree Radic Biol MedYear: 2006401273716337886
69.. Gitto E,Aversa S,Reiter RJ,Barberi I,Pellegrino S. Update on the use of melatonin in pediatricsJ Pineal ResYear: 20115021821029156
70.. Tan DX,Manchester LC,Terron MP,Flores LJ,Reiter RJ. One molecule, many derivatives: a never-ending interaction of melatonin with reactive oxygen and nitrogen species?J Pineal ResYear: 200742284217198536
71.. Hardeland R. Antioxidative protection by melatonin: multiplicity of mechanisms from radical detoxification to radical avoidanceEndocrineYear: 2005271193016217125
72.. López LC,Escames G,Tapias V,Utrilla P,León J,Acuña-Castroviejo D. Identification of an inducible nitric oxide synthase in diaphragm mitochondria from septic mice: its relation with mitochondrial dysfunction and prevention by melatoninInt J Biochem Cell BiolYear: 2006382677816223598
73.. Escames G,López LC,Tapias V,Utrilla P,Reiter RJ,Hitos AB,León J,et al. Melatonin counteracts inducible mitochondrial nitric oxide synthase-dependent mitochondrial dysfunction in skeletal muscle of septic miceJ Pineal ResYear: 20064071816313501
74.. Leon J,Acuña-Castroviejo D,Sainz RM,Mayo JC,Tan DX,Reiter RJ. Melatonin and mitochondrial functionLife SciYear: 2004757659015183071
75.. Gitto E,Karbownik M,Reiter RJ,Tan DX,Cuzzocrea S,Chiurazzi P,et al. Effects of melatonin treatment in septic newbornsPediatr ResYear: 2001507566011726736
76.. Gitto E,Pellegrino S,Gitto P,Barberi I,Reiter RJ. Oxidative stress of the newborn in the pre- and postnatal period and the clinical utility of melatoninJ Pineal ResYear: 2009461283919054296
77.. Sparks DL,Hunsaker JC 3rd. The pineal gland in sudden infant death syndrome: preliminary observationsJ Pineal ResYear: 19885111183367255
78.. Weissbluth L,Weissbluth M. Sudden infant death syndrome: a genetically determined impaired maturation of the photoneuroendocrine system. A unifying hypothesisJ Theor BiolYear: 199416713258176952
79.. Sturner WQ,Lynch HJ,Deng MH,Gleason RE,Wurtman RJ. Melatonin concentrations in the sudden infant death syndromeForensic Sci IntYear: 199045171802335331
80.. Sivan Y,Laudon M,Kuint J,Zisapel N. Low melatonin production in infants with a life-threatening eventDev Med Child NeurolYear: 2000424879110972422
81.. Duncan JR,Paterson DS,Hoffman JM,Mokler DJ,Borenstein NS,Belliveau RA,et al. Brainstem serotonergic deficiency in sudden infant death syndromeJAMAYear: 2010303430720124538
82.. Jones RE. Dysfunctional development of the diaphragm in SIDS and the prone sleeping positionClin Pediatr (Phila)Year: 19963517348904494
83.. Rehan VK,Nakashima JM,Gutman A,Rubin LP,McCool FD. Effects of the supine and prone position on diaphragm thickness in healthy term infantsArch Dis ChildYear: 200083234810952643
84.. Wolfson MR,Greenspan JS,Deoras KS,Allen JL,Shaffer TH. Effect of position on the mechanical interaction between the rib cage and abdomen in preterm infantsJ Appl PhysiolYear: 199272103281533209
85.. Andersson D,Gennser G,Johnson P. Phase characteristics of breathing movements in healthy newbornsJ Dev PhysiolYear: 19835289986227654
86.. Cornwell AC,Feigenbaum P,Kim A. SIDS, abnormal nighttime REM sleep and CNS immaturityNeuropediatricsYear: 1998297299638661
87.. Gould JB,Lee AF,Morelock S. The relationship between sleep and sudden infant deathAnn N Y Acad SciYear: 198853362773421639
88.. Bryan AC,Muller NL. Lung mechanics and gas exchange during sleepSleepYear: 1980340167194498
89.. Tabachnik E,Muller NL,Bryan AC,Levison H. Changes in ventilation and chest wall mechanics during sleep in normal adolescentsJ Appl PhysiolYear: 198151557647327955
90.. Okabe S,Hida W,Kikuchi Y,Taguchi O,Takishima T,Shirato K. Upper airway muscle activity during REM and non-REM sleep of patients with obstructive apneaChestYear: 1994106767738082357
91.. Lopes J,Muller NL,Bryan MH,Bryan AC. Importance of inspiratory muscle tone in maintenance of FRC in the newbornJ Appl PhysiolYear: 19815183047298425
92.. Heldt GP,McIlroy MB. Distortion of chest wall and work of diaphragm in preterm infantsJ Appl PhysiolYear: 19876216493558176
93.. Lopes JM,Muller NL,Bryan MH,Bryan AC. Synergistic behavior of inspiratory muscles after diaphragmatic fatigue in the newbornJ Appl PhysiolYear: 198151547517327953
94.. Guslits BG,Gaston SE,Bryan MH,England SJ,Bryan AC. Diaphragmatic work of breathing in premature human infantsJ Appl PhysiolYear: 1987621410153597217
95.. Morris JA,Haran D,Smith A. Hypothesis: common bacterial toxins are a possible cause of the sudden infant death syndromeMed HypothesesYear: 198722211223646461
96.. Morris JA,Harrison LM. Sudden unexpected death in infancy: evidence of infectionLancetYear: 200837118151618514712
97.. de Voer RM,van der Klis FR,Nooitgedagt JE,Versteegh FG,van Huisseling JC,van Rooijen DM,et al. Seroprevalence and placental transportation of maternal antibodies specific for Neisseria meningitidis serogroup C, Haemophilus influenzae type B, diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussisClin Infect DisYear: 200949586419480581
98.. Nagao AT,Friedlander-Del Nero D,Arslanian C,Carneiro-Sampaio MM. Elevated levels and different repertoire profile of colostral anti-LPS antibodies may have a significant role in compensating newborn immunityScand J ImmunolYear: 200153602911422909
99.. Leuridan E,Hens N,Hutse V,Ieven M,Aerts M,Van Damme P. Early waning of maternal measles antibodies in era of measles elimination: longitudinal studyBMJYear: 2010340c162620483946
100.. Heininger U,Riffelmann M,Leineweber B,Wirsing von Koenig CH. Maternally derived antibodies against Bordetella pertussis antigens pertussis toxin and filamentous hemagglutinin in preterm and full term newbornsPediatr Infect Dis JYear: 200928443519319020
101.. Leuridan E,Hens N,Hutse V,Aerts M,Van Damme P. Kinetics of maternal antibodies against rubella and varicella in infantsVaccineYear: 2010Month: 6 Day: 15 (Epub ahead of print).
102.. van Der Zwet WC,Vandenbroucke-Grauls CM,van Elburg RM,Cranendonk A,Zaaijer HL. Neonatal antibody titers against varicella-zoster virus in relation to gestational age, birth weight, and maternal titerPediatricsYear: 2002109798511773545
103.. Shakib JH,Ralston S,Raissy HH,Stoddard GJ,Edwards KM,Byington CL. Pertussis antibodies in postpartum women and their newbornsJ PerinatolYear: 20103093719812588
104.. Klauninger R,Skog A,Horvath L,Winqvist O,Edner A,Bremme K,et al. Serologic follow-up of children born to mothers with Ro/SSA autoantibodiesLupusYear: 200918792819578103
105.. Vidyashankar C. Optimal age for measles vaccinationJ Indian Med AssocYear: 200210024612206338
106.. Leipälä JA,Bhat RY,Rafferty GF,Hannam S,Greenough A. Effect of posture on respiratory function and drive in preterm infants prior to dischargePediatr PulmonolYear: 20033629530012950041
107.. Rao H,Saiki T,Landolfo F,Smith AP,Hannam S,Rafferty GF,et al. Position and ventilatory response to added dead space in prematurely born infantsPediatr PulmonolYear: 2009443879119283763
108.. Saiki T,Hannam S,Rafferty GF,Milner AD,Greenough A. Ventilatory response to added dead space and position in preterm infants at high risk age for SIDSPediatr PulmonolYear: 2010Month: 10 Day: 26

Article Categories:
  • Original Article

Keywords: sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), infection, diaphragm, pediatrics.

Previous Document:  Methylnaltrexone bromide: research update of pharmacokinetics following parenteral administration.
Next Document:  Drug release from liquisolid systems: speed it up, slow it down.