Document Detail

Coracoclavicular joint, an osteological study with clinical implications: a case report.
Jump to Full Text
MedLine Citation:
PMID:  19918399     Owner:  NLM     Status:  PubMed-not-MEDLINE    
Abstract/OtherAbstract:
INTRODUCTION: The presence of an anomalous coracoclavicular joint was studied in a human male skeleton aged 73 years old from the Osteology Collection of our Department.
CASE PRESENTATION: We describe the exact morphology of this variation that is occasionally reported as an anatomical or radiological curiosity in the literature (0.55-21%).
CONCLUSION: Although coracoclavicular diarthrosis is of no significance other than academic, it is important to recognize this variation and the clinical symptoms that may occur, as it is a cause of shoulder pain and arthritis in this or the adjacent sternoclavicular and acromioclavicular joint. Consequently, it is vital to apply the appropriate treatment.
Authors:
Georgios Paraskevas; Marios-Efstathios Stavrakas; Alexandra Stoltidou
Related Documents :
2653419 - Supero-lateral dislocation of sagittally split bifid mandibular condyle.
2688909 - Rehabilitation of the athlete with a knee injury.
15954069 - Femoral neuropathy due to patellar dislocation in a theatrical and jazz dancer: a case ...
18802289 - Clinical presentation of osgood- schlatter disease in the adolescent population.
9293689 - Rapid destructive osteo-arthritis of the hip.
9610979 - Propofol bolus facilitates reduction of luxed temporomandibular joints.
6501899 - Clinically apparent rubella reinfection.
21965859 - A solitary crateriform ulcer of the lower lip: a case report with review of literature.
3059659 - Eosinophilic cystitis: a therapeutic challenge.
Publication Detail:
Type:  Journal Article     Date:  2009-08-07
Journal Detail:
Title:  Cases journal     Volume:  2     ISSN:  1757-1626     ISO Abbreviation:  Cases J     Publication Date:  2009  
Date Detail:
Created Date:  2009-11-17     Completed Date:  2011-01-07     Revised Date:  -    
Medline Journal Info:
Nlm Unique ID:  101474272     Medline TA:  Cases J     Country:  England    
Other Details:
Languages:  eng     Pagination:  8715     Citation Subset:  -    
Affiliation:
Department of Anatomy, Medical Faculty, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki Thessaloniki Greece. g_paraskevas@yahoo.gr
Export Citation:
APA/MLA Format     Download EndNote     Download BibTex
MeSH Terms
Descriptor/Qualifier:
Comments/Corrections

From MEDLINE®/PubMed®, a database of the U.S. National Library of Medicine

Full Text
Journal Information
Journal ID (nlm-ta): Cases J
ISSN: 1757-1626
Publisher: Cases Network Ltd
Article Information
? 2009 Paraskevas et al.; licensee Cases Network Ltd.
open-access:
Received Day: 26 Month: 9 Year: 2008
Accepted Day: 30 Month: 12 Year: 2008
Electronic publication date: Day: 07 Month: 8 Year: 2009
collection publication date: Year: 2009
Volume: 2E-location ID: 8715
PubMed Id: 19918399
DOI: 10.4076/1757-1626-2-8715
Publisher Id: 8715

Coracoclavicular joint, an osteological study with clinical implications: a case report
Georgios Paraskevasaff1 Email: g_paraskevas@yahoo.gr
Marios-Efstathios Stavrakasaff1 Email: medstav@yahoo.gr
Alexandra Stoltidouaff1 Email: alexmed501@yahoo.com
Department of Anatomy, Medical Faculty, Aristotle University of ThessalonikiThessalonikiGreece

Introduction

Coracoclavicular joint is an anomalous diarthrosis formed between the conoid tubercle of the clavicle and the superior surface of the horizontal part of the coracoiod process of the scapula. It was first described in 1861 by Gruber. Since then, there have been reported a few cases of this variation, revealed on chest X-rays, dry skeletons or cadavers [1].

Though coracoclavicular diarthrosis is considered as a neglected structure without significance, its presence is useful to determining the aetiology of shoulder pain and its management in some instances. The presence of such a joint may cause in some cases shoulder pain radiating to the arm [2]. That relative rare anatomical structure with an incidence ranging from 0.55% to 21% [3,4] is stated that is more common in Asians than in Europeans or Africans [5].

The aim of the present study is to describe the morphology of a coracoclavicular joint found on macerated bones, as well as to report on the frequency and the correlation between this variant and any sexual, racial and tribal differences, and the possible clinical value of that variant.


Case presentation

Our material was derived from the Osteological Collection of the Department of Anatomy of Medical Faculty of University of Thessaloniki. On the left clavicle and left scapula of a dried 73-year-old Caucasian male skeleton, two distinct anatomical features were found, in the area of the coracoclavicular syndesmosis. In particular, we came across an abnormal coracoclavicular joint at the left clavicle and left scapula. We noticed the existence of two outgrowths forming two articular facets, one on the coracoid process and the other on the inferior surface of the clavicle, near the conoid tubercle, 5 cm medial to the acromial edge. The noticed clavicular outgrowth was triangular in shape with the base at the clavicle and the apex directed downwards. The outer surface was oblique and smooth and it was in exact apposition with the chondral covered surface of the horizontal portion of the coracoid process. From the medical history of our specimen, there was a report of a diffuse left shoulder pain of unknown cause. The examined left clavicle and scapula didn?t appear any pathologic conditions or congenital abnormalities. The present study was approved by the University Research Ethic Committee. (Figure 1 and Figure 2).


Discussion

The coracoclavicular joint is an anomalous, roundish joint, easily observable in primates. Its frequency ranges between 0.7% and 10% according to osteological studies or dissection [3,6] and between 0.55% and 21% according to radiological studies [1,5,6]. Coracoclavicular joint occurred unilaterally more frequently than bilaterally thus 0.49% versus 0.06% [1] and 5,02% versus 4,58% [7]. However, Cho et al [8] found the bilateral occurrence as higher at 8.8% of the 9,8% overall occurrence. The use of radiographs is of higher value in the study of the coracoclavicular joint than when dry bones are studied directly [1]. It is important to mention that only wet dissections can reveal with more accuracy the existence of cartilaginous facets, often regarded as evidence of a joint [9].

As far as sexual differences are concerned, it is found that this joint is more frequent in males than females in a proportion 11:1 [9]. However, most authors detected no statistically significant differences between the genders [1,3,7,8]. The variation seems to be more common in Asians than in other races [4,5,10]. This is contrary to the results presented by Nalla et al [7], who supported that both the white (10%) and black (9.4%) South African populations showed similar frequencies to those found in the Japanese and North-West Indian populations.

The development of arthritis at the coracoclavicular joint is not completely clear at the moment. According to Hall [2] any degenerative deformation of the coracoclavicular joint may cause cervicobrachial syndrome, because of the very close proximity to the brachial plexus. On the other hand, Cockshott?s study [5] revealed that coracoclavicular joint is subject to osteophytic marginal lipping, which is unable to create symptoms or disability. However, in some cases there have been described clinical symptoms attributed to coracoclavicular joint. Thus, these symptoms include shoulder-joint pain, radiating to the arm, the breast and neck, persisting during rest and increasing with exercise. The maximum intensity persisted at the site of the abnormal joint. Occasional symptoms included itching of the last four fingers, followed by transient paralysis of the hand [2]. In our case, the specimen during his life appeared a diffuse shoulder pain, presumably due to osteoarthritic changes of the coracoclavicular and acromioclavicular joint.

The possible complications of the existence of the anomalous joint that are presented in literature are humeral head fracture [11], cervicobrachial syndrome [12] and decrease in movement [2]. The etiology of the pain still seems obscure. Del Valle and Giordano [12] ascribed it to a sympathetic or plexal origin due to compression of microscopic nerves, which are relieved by removal of the anomalous joint. Other causes mentioned in literature are the degenerative changes of the joint and the close proximity to the brachial plexus, but they seem to be of little importance [2].

It has been suggested that the coracoclavicular joint is related to traumatic sequelae [13] and that the joint itself has a tendency to undergo arthritic changes [4]. Some authors have proposed that coracoclavicular joint may predispose to acromioclavicular or/and sternoclavicular degenerative changes. Possati [14] described the case of a workman who underwent acromioclavicular degenerative changes, while Kier et al [15] considered coracoclavicular joint as a predisposal factor for sternoclavicular degenerative changes. It is not known why coracoclavicular joint may predispose neighbouring joints to arthritic changes; nevertheless, it is plausible that the anomalous articulation plays a part in the stiffness of the acromioclavicular and sternoclavicular joints, reducing the capacity to absorb the different stresses applied on them [4].

Cho and Kang [8] correlated the appearance of coracoclavicular joint with the increase of age and raised the possibility that the joint may develop as a result of degenerative changes. Cockshott [5] proposed that the formation of coracoclavicular joint has genetical basis. On the contrary, Kaur and Jit [3] supported that this variant was not a result of any congenital malformation because neither of the 35 fetuses nor the 50 neonates studied showed the presence of the joint. They further reasoned that the formation of the joint later in life is conditioned more by genetic than by environmental factors.

Sexual and racial differences were not statistically significant. Nalla et al [7] found that individuals possessing the joint showed statistically significantly larger scapulae, longer clavicles and longer first ribs. Cho and Kang [8] supported that there is no correlation between the coracoclavicular joint and the size of the scapula, the clavicle length and the slope and heights of some coracoacromial arch elements. Gumina et al [4] observed no statistically significant differences between the mean length and the mean index of sinuosity of the anterior lateral curve of clavicles with and without coracoclavicular joint.


Notes
Consent

A written consent was obtained by the skeleton-cadaver?s next of kin for publication of the article. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the Editor-in-Chief of this journal.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors? contributions

GP did the collection of the bones and discovery of the very rare variant of the coracoclavicular joint and also supervised the manuscript writing. MES performed the literature review and obtained the written consent. AS obtained the photos and wrote the draft of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.


References
Olotu Joy E,Oladipo GS,Eroje MA,Edipamode IE. Incidence of coracoclavicular joint in adult Nigerian populationScientific Research and EssayYear: 200834165167
Hall FJS. Coracoclavicular joint; rare condition treated successfully by operationBr Med JYear: 1950176676810.1136/bmj.1.4656.766
Kaur H,Jit I. Brief communication: Coracoclavicular joint in Northwest indiansAm J Phys AnthropolYear: 199185457460192831810.1002/ajpa.1330850409
Gumina S,Salvatore M,De Santis P,Orsina L,Postachini F. Coracoclavicular joint : osteologic study of 1020 human claviclesJ AnatYear: 200220151351910.1046/j.1469-7580.2002.00115.x12489763
Cockshott WP. The coracoclavicular jointAJRYear: 1979131313316441311
Fischer L,Vuillard P,Blanc JF,Bouchet A. L?articulation coraco-claviculaireLyon MedYear: 1971225125712605122013
Nalla S,Asvat R. Incidence of the coracoclavicular joint in South African populationsJ AnatYear: 19951866456497559137
Cho BP,Kang HS. Articular facets of the coracoclavicular joint in KoreansActa AnatYear: 19981635662985235510.1159/000046446
Lewis OJ. The coracoclavicular jointJ AnatYear: 19599329630314416547
Abe K. On the coracoclavicular joint and its incidenceActa Anat NipponYear: 19643922723114199758
Frasseto F. Tre casi di articolazione coraco-clavicolare osservati radiograficamente sul viventeChir Org MovYear: 19215116124
Del Valle D,Giordano A. Sindrome doloroso cervico-brachial originado por articulacion coracoclavicular. Operacion-curacionRev Argentino-Norteamericana Cien MedYear: 19431687693
Lane WA. The anatomy and physiology of the shoemakerJ AnatYear: 18882259362817231765
Possati A. Un caso di articolazione coraco-clavicolare osservato radiograficamenteChir Org MovYear: 192610533536
Kier R,Wain SL,Apple J,Martinez S. Osteoarthritis of the sternoclavicular joint. Radiographic features and pathologic correlationInvest RadiolYear: 198621227233395759610.1097/00004424-198603000-00007

Figures

[Figure ID: fig-001]
Figure 1. 

The clavicular facet (arrow) of the coracoclavicular joint, as seen on the inferior surface of the acromial end of a left clavicle.



[Figure ID: fig-002]
Figure 2. 

The articulation facets as they articulated in the coracoclavicular joint (arrow).



Article Categories:
  • Case report


Previous Document:  Osteolipoma independent of bone tissue: a case report.
Next Document:  Catatonic syndrome associated with lead intoxication: a case report.