A student surgical society--the Cape Town experience.
|Abstract:||The UCT Surgical Society, Africa's first student surgical society, is a student-managed academic society that promotes undergraduate interest in the field of surgery at the University of Cape Town. With over 700 members in 2009, it is one of the largest student surgical societies in the world. This article describes the origins, aims and objectives of the Society, and outlines a framework that students anywhere may use to create their own academic interest societies.|
Medical societies (History)
Medical societies (Aims and objectives)
Surgery (Study and teaching)
Medical education (Access control)
|Publication:||Name: South African Journal of Surgery Publisher: South African Medical Association Audience: Academic Format: Magazine/Journal Subject: Health Copyright: COPYRIGHT 2011 South African Medical Association ISSN: 0038-2361|
|Issue:||Date: August, 2011 Source Volume: 49 Source Issue: 3|
|Topic:||Event Code: 220 Strategy & planning; 350 Product standards, safety, & recalls Computer Subject: Company growth|
|Product:||Product Code: 8622000 Medical Associations; 8000410 Surgical Procedures NAICS Code: 81392 Professional Organizations; 62 Health Care and Social Assistance SIC Code: 8621 Professional organizations|
|Organization:||Organization: University of Cape Town; Royal College of Surgeons of England|
|Geographic:||Geographic Scope: South Africa Geographic Code: 6SOUT South Africa|
The UCT Surgical Society is a student-managed academic society that
promotes undergraduate interest in the field of surgery at the
University of Cape Town. It is Africa's first student surgical
society, and with over 700 enrolled members in 2009 has grown to become
both one of the largest academic medical student organisations in South
Africa and one of the largest student surgical societies in the world.
In this article we describe the origins of the Society and its aims and
objectives, and most importantly outline a framework that students
anywhere may use as a mould for the creation of their own academic
interest societies. The first author's personal involvement with
the Society during 2008 and 2009 was the stimulus for the article.
The history of the Society
The UCT Surgical Society was formed in late 2006 by six 4thyear medical students at the University of Cape Town, who were inspired by news of the formation of student-run surgical interest groups at numerous medical universities in the UK. (1,2) These societies, formed as part of an education outreach initiative of the Royal College of Surgeons of England (RCS), hosted regular extracurricular surgical lectures and clinical activities for their medical students, all with the general aim of increasing undergraduate (and ultimately postgraduate) interest in the study of surgery. (3) In its first year of existence, the UCT Society managed to attract approximately 300 members, most of whom were medical students at UCT. In its second year the Society fared less well, with an enrolled membership of 220. In 2009, enrolled membership soared to 711, making the Society the largest academic society at UCT.
Aims and objectives
The UCT Surgical Society holds aims and objectives (Fig. 1) similar to those of the undergraduate societies initiated by the RCS in the UK, and furthers these aims by hosting regular events throughout the academic year.
What does the Society do?
Traditionally, the backbone of the UCT Surgical Society has always been the series of monthly evening lectures (Fig. 2) that are presented throughout the academic year by leading local and inter national surgical personalities. Since the rise in popularity of the Society during 2009, these lectures have become so increasingly popular that often no lecture theatre at the Medical School can accommodate all in attendance (talks regularly attract 200-300 attendees).
The Society has also begun to host an additional tri-monthly lecture series entitled the 'Open Forum' series, where speakers are invited to present broad medically related topics that often do not fit the purely surgical themes of the main academic lecture series (Fig. 2).
In addition to lecture- and presentation-based education, the Society also offers monthly practical surgical skill courses for its members. These courses, offered in partnership with the Department of Surgery at UCT (which has very generously shared its equipment, time and personnel with the Society), are designed as an addition to the standard surgical skills courses offered to all 5th-year medical students at UCT. The courses are centred on excerpts from the official Basic Surgical Skills Course (which is offered across the country by the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa) and are open to all enrolled members. They are divided into two streams, basic and advanced (Fig. 3), and are tutored by members of the Department of Surgery at UCT. These courses have become so popular among the students that bookings are done months in advance!
In 2010, the Society aimed to continue with its goal of promoting extra-curricular academic learning among undergraduate medical students. Additions to the Society's academic year included the establishment of regular dissection groups (taught by members of the Department of Anatomy at UCT), the hosting of conference-style events focusing on specific surgical themes, and a programme to further promote research by members. In addition, the Society aims to help form similar medical student societies elsewhere in South Africa and Africa.
[FIGURE 4 OMITTED]
Statistics of the Society
In 2009, the Society compiled its first set of statistics. A questionnaire filled in by 80% of our membership revealed the gender distribution within the Society (Fig. 4) and our members' surgical interests at an undergraduate level (Fig. 5). In addition, it was found that 64% of all enrolled UCT medical students belonged to the Society.
[FIGURE 5 OMITTED]
A framework for the creation of student-managed academic interest groups
A student surgical society is an organisation that is easily replicated at any institution: all that is needed is a group of motivated, hardworking students united in their interest in a specific field or topic, and mentorship and guidance from senior faculty.
Before forming an academic interest society, a checklist needs to be evaluated (Fig. 6).
Essential to the formation of a society is the formulation of a set of aims and objectives that will underlie all actions taken by the society. These aims will often be revised as the society develops and matures. It is also important to decide who the target audience will be--will the society cater for medical students alone, or include others?
In addition, a programme of events needs to be developed. It is important that all events be carefully planned well in advance in order to maintain membership interest in the society. Events hosted by the UCT Surgical Society have been described above. As such a society can have a significant impact on its members, we recommend inviting charismatic and inspirational academic personalities. A checklist for the organisation of a society lecture is set out in Fig. 7.
Hosting lectures, debates and courses costs a lot of money, and it is therefore necessary to develop a basic financial plan before launching a society. In Cape Town, we were fortunate to be able to finance our events thanks to generous sponsorships from pharmaceutical and surgical equipment manufacturers. We also raised lesser amounts from our membership contributions. It is strongly recommended that a portfolio or brochure describing the society for prospective sponsors should be designed, specifically highlighting how the sponsor may benefit from donating to the society. The UCT Society even has a coat of arms (Fig. 8).
[FIGURE 8 OMITTED]
Advertising is another important aspect of a society--advertise well, and your events will be well attended (unfortunately, the opposite is also true). In Cape Town, we used a mixture of media to communicate to our members: (i) mobile text messaging (via a 'bulk sms' service); (ii) printed posters posted at Medical School and academic hospitals; and (iii) web-based advertising (the Society has a website (www.surgsoc.org), detailing future lectures). We found the most effective medium to be the mobile phone bulk text message system.
Organising a well-functioning team to lead a society can be a challenging process. We recommend the following leadership system: an executive team, consisting of president, deputy (who both oversee all aspects of the society) and treasurer; and a general team ranging from 5 to 10 members (depending on the size of the society) who rotate their roles and duties (advertising, helping organise events, etc.) throughout the academic year. We successfully implemented this system in Cape Town, and found that its strength lies in the efficient load-sharing of the daily work required to run the society.
As with all new projects, one must be prepared for both success and failure--the latter often providing the stimulus for significant long-term improvements. However, hard work, enthusiasm and constant review of society programmes will ultimately result in a healthy and successful society.
Discussion: Is the UCT Society relevant to undergraduate study?
The Society provides an informal, extra-curricular teaching programme that is proving to be a stimulating adjunct to the medical school curriculum at UCT. This is especially relevant today in light of the reduction of undergraduate teaching time allocated to anatomy and surgery worldwide. (4,5)
We have not found any studies that examine the possible effects of such a society on undergraduate academic performance. As our Society is still in its infancy, we have no data to this effect. It is also as yet unknown whether such a society truly influences a larger number of students towards a career in surgery. Future investigation is needed to address these questions more precisely.
The UCT Surgical Society has grown tremendously since its formation 3 years ago. We hope that it will continue to provide sterling informal academic education to future generations of members. The experience of being involved in an academic student society is very rewarding and highly recommended, and we hope that our Society's story will inspire the formation of similar groups elsewhere in Africa and the world.
On behalf of the Society, I would like to sincerely thank Professor Delawir Kahn for his constant guidance, inspiration and support. Special mention and thanks are due to Dr Sanju Sobnach, who founded the Society in 2006 and led it throughout its first few years. I would also like to thank the hard-working and motivated committees of 2006--2008 and especially 2009; all speakers; Professor Graham Louw (Department of Human Biology, UCT); members of the Department of Surgery (especially Mr Jason Lewis); Professor Marian Jacobs, Dean of the UCT Medical School; the Society's very generous sponsors; and all our members and supporters.
Dr Favara was president of the UCT Surgical Society during 2009 and is currently completing his internship in the Eastern Cape. Correspondence to firstname.lastname@example.org
(1.) The Royal College of Surgeons of England. Surgical societies--surgical careers. http://surgicalcareers.rcseng.ac.uk/students/medical-students/ surgical-societies/ (accessed 15 January 2010).
(2.) The Royal College of Surgeons of England. Annual Report 2001-02. London: Royal College of Surgeons of England, 2002.
(3.) The Royal College of Surgeons of England. MSLC--surgical careers. http://surgicalcareers.rcseng.ac.uk/students/medical-students/ surgical-societies/mslc/ (accessed 15 January 2010).
(4.) Older J. Anatomy: a must for teaching the next generation. Surgeon 2004; 2(2): 79-90.
(5.) Peterson CA, Tucker RP. Undergraduate coursework in anatomy as a predictor of performance: comparison between students taking a medical gross anatomy course of average length and a course shortened by curriculum reform. Clin Anat 2005; 18(7): 540-547.
D. M. FAVARA, M.B. CH.B. East London Hospital Complex, E Cape
D. KAHN, CH.M., F.C.S. (S.A.) Department of Surgery, Division of General Surgery, and Transplant Unit, University of Cape Town
Fig. 1. The aims and objectives of the UCT Surgical Society. 1. To promote surgical education among students and stimulate interest in the field of surgery 2. To promote a culture of medical and surgical research among students 3. To expose students to leading personalities in the field of surgery 4. To expose students to the latest surgical innovations available both locally and internationally 5. To provide a stimulus for a career in surgery 6. To make contact and create partnership with other surgical societies worldwide
Fig. 2. Previous academic lectures presented at the UCT Surgical Society. 2009 lectures: 1. Main academic lecture series: * Professor J. E. J. Krige--'Scalpels and sutures--The history of surgery, from medieval to modern' * Professor D. Kahn, Drs Muller, Stupart and Cairncross--'Women in surgery' * Dr K. Adams and Professor G. Louw--'Plastic surgery and an introduction to face transplantation' * Professor D. Benatar--'The ethics of contested surgeries' * Dr R. Verster and Professor G. Louw--'Surgery for obesity' * Professors Fieggen, Sala and Figaji--'An evening of neurosurgery: Intra-operative neurophysiological monitoring and neuro-endoscopy' * Professor M. Veller--'Endovascular surgery--does it save lives?' 2. Launch of the 'Open Forum' series * Dr J. Cowlin - 'The medical practitioner's guide to the business world' Past topics: Past lectures have included topics ranging from 'Advances in endoscopic surgery, 'Head and neck ENT surgery', 'Trauma surgery' and 'Cardiac transplantation' to 'The history of vascular surgery' and 'Life as a surgical registrar', and have been presented by speakers including Professors H. van der Walt, J. Fagan, K. Boffard, P. Navsaria and J. Brink, and Drs P Matley, E. Steyn and W. Koen
Fig. 3. Surgical skills courses offered to members of the UCT Surgical Society. 1. Basic stream: Theatre etiquette, suturing skills 2. Advanced stream: Lymph node dissection, vessel ligation, bowel anastomosis
Fig. 6. Checklist for the formation of an academic student society. 1. Society aims and objectives 2. Target audience 3. Events/other expression of aims and objectives 4. Means of finance 5. Means of advertising 6. Roles within the management team
Fig. 7. Checklist for the organisation of an evening lecture. 1. Decide on a theme or topic 2. Invite potential speakers (based on the recommendations of faculty mentors) 3. Organise venue, snacks and beverages, gift for speakers 4. After the presentation: * clean the venue * write letters thanking all speakers * critically review the event in terms of future improvements
|Gale Copyright:||Copyright 2011 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.|