An ancient assemblage of scavenger insects in patagonia (Argentina).
Scavengers (Zoology) (Research)
Otero, J. Gomez
|Publication:||Name: Entomologica Americana Publisher: New York Entomological Society Audience: Academic Format: Magazine/Journal Subject: Biological sciences; Science and technology Copyright: COPYRIGHT 2009 New York Entomological Society ISSN: 1947-5136|
|Issue:||Date: Jan, 2009 Source Volume: 115 Source Issue: 1|
|Topic:||Event Code: 310 Science & research|
|Geographic:||Geographic Scope: Argentina Geographic Code: 3ARGE Argentina|
Abstract.--The study of a carrion fauna from a forensic perspective
provides insight into cadaveric succession during vertebrate
decomposition and contributes to documentation of taphonomic processes.
The insects associated with sea lion bones of 1290 [+ or -] 100 years BP
found in Puerto Madryn (Argentina) were examined. The recorded species
were: Cochliomyia macellaria and Fannia sp. (Diptera), Dermestes
maculatus and Necrobia rufipes (Coleoptera), and Tineola cf biselliella
(Lepidoptera). The succession of insect species occurred at the end of
spring or the beginning of summer, on carrion exposed to the open air
for approximately 50 days. Decomposition was apparently interrupted by
mass wasting that buried the carcasses.
Key words: carrion fauna, taphonomy, forensic entomology, cadaveric succession, Argentina.
Resumen.--El estudio de la fauna carronera desde una perspectiva forense permite conocer el proceso de descomposicion de los vertebrados (aun en una sucesion cadaverica antigua) y contribuye con los estudios fafonomicos. En esta investigacion, fueron examinados los insectos asociados a restos de lobos marinos de 1290 [+ or -] 100 [sup.14]C anos AP hallados en Puerto Madryn (Argentina). Las especies registradas fueron: Cochliomyia macellaria y Fannia sp. (Diptera), Dermestes maculatus y Necrobia rufipes (Coleoptera) y Tineola cf. biselliella (Lepidoptera). Fue determinado que la sucesi6n se desarrollo a fines de la primavera o comienzos del verano y los restos estuvieron expuestos al aire abierto por aproximadamente 50 dias, cuando la descomposici6n aparentemente fue interrumpida pot fen6menos de remoci6n en masa que enterraron los restos.
Key words: fauna cadaverica, tafonomia, entomologia forense, sucesion cadaverica, Argentina.
Vertebrate carcass decomposition implies a heterotrophic succession where, throughout relatively discrete diverse stages, various arthropod groups colonize the carrion as a resource for feeding and breeding (Golf, 1993; Centeno et al. 2002). From the succession of the carrion fauna it is possible to obtain information about circumstances associated with and following the death of the animal(s), which is helpful in forensic investigations (Goff 1993; Benecke, 2001).
Different body parts of insects and other arthropods can be preserved unaltered for thousands of years [e.g., 24,550 [+ or -] 600 years BP (Coope, 1986; Petrulevicius, 2001)] or can become fossilized. For example, fossilized Diptera of the family Calliphoridae have been found in association with Pleistocene mammals from Argentina, and represent an example of an ancient cadaveric decay assemblage (Petrulevicius, 2001). No fossilized scavenger insects were found associated with Egyptian or Peruvian mummies dating to several thousands years B.P. (Panagiotakopulu 2001). The study of assemblages of insects found in archeological sites from the Middle Ages provides knowledge about environment utilization, displacements, and behavior of ancient populations (Hellqvist & Lemdahl, 1996; Carrott & Kenward, 2001). The knowledge of cadaver fauna from a specific time can be helpful in the study of circumstances associated with past events such as animal death and decay, graves, mummies, or other sites of archaeological interest. The study of this fauna from a forensic perspective can contribute information valuable to reconstructing past events (Panagiotakopulu, 2004). Our study of carrion insects was carried out in conjunction with an archaeological investigation in Patagonia, Argentina.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Insect remains were collected from the site of a taphonomic event at the site called "Sitio Lobos", located at Punta Dorado, on the Golfo Nuevo coast, 12 km northeast of Puerto Madryn (Serran et al. 2007). This site was found by members of the archaeology laboratory of the Centro Nacional Patagonico (Patagonia, Argentina), who discovered bones arising within the walls of a gully aligned perpendicular to the coast. The bone remains were buried at depths ranging from 40-70 cm, in a continuous layer that extended 13 m, located 44 m inland from the high tide line and 1.85 m above present sea level. The bones were identified as those of at least 22 individual sea lions (Otaria flavescens (Shaw)) of both sexes and varying ages (i. e., pups, juveniles, subadults and adults). A radiocarbonic age of 1290 [+ or -] 100 C-14 B.P. was reported (Serran et al 2007). Taphonomic analyses indicated a mass mortality event of the sea lions. No evidence of human activity or catastrophic event was recognized in the site; thus an acute illness was proposed as the cause of death (Serran et al., 2007).
Remains of several arthropods, some of them well preserved, were collected in association with the sea lion bones. Taxonomic analysis of the insects and their context within the site allowed establishment of the cadaver-inhabiting nature of the fauna. We analyzed the insects from a forensic perspective, trying to determine the incidence of different processes at the site.
The insect remains and the associated sediment were transferred to the laboratory where they were cleaned, using minutens, brushes and other instruments in order to prepare them for taxonomic determination. Insect remains were stored in the Laboratory of the Centro de Estudios e Investigaciones at the Universidad Nacional de Quilmes. Table 1 lists the identified species and includes some details about the life stages represented in the fauna.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The discovery of several puparia of Calliphoridae containing other calliphorid puparia inside is evidence of more than a single generational cohort. The larvae of the second generation entered empty puparia from the first generation in order to pupate. Something similar would have happened with pupae of Fannia sp. which were found inside Cochliomyia macellaria F. puparia, indicating that at least some of the Fannia arrived after the Calliphoridae. This observation is consistent with results obtained from Santa Catalina (Buenos Aires province, Argentina) where Calliphoridae arrived relatively early, followed by Fannia sp. during the more advanced stages of decay (Centeno et al., 2002).
The Cleridae are represented by Necrobia rufipes De Geer, an omnivorous species that, once the succession started, likely came to the carrion in order to feed on dipterous eggs or larvae. It is also conjectured that this clerid might feed on fat from the corpses (Payne & King, 1970). The rest of the coleopterous larval exuviae are from Dermestes maculatus De Geer, indicating that this succession proceeded to an advanced decay stage, close to skeletonization and/or mummification, where only bony tissue, dried skin and hair are preserved. This interpretation is reinforced by the presence of a Lepidopteran cocoon, probably a representative of the family Tineidae, and very similar to Tineola biselliella Hummel. Larvae of this species are known to feed on hair and other dried tissues (Payne & King, 1969; Oliva, 1997).
With respect to the estimation of event seasonality, palaeoclimatic studies indicate that current weather conditions in the plateau of north Patagonia extrandina began about 2500-2000 years BP (Paez 1993; Schaibitz & Liebricht 1998). That allows us to infer that at the time of death of the sea lions, climatic conditions in the area were similar to the present arid temperate environment. Referring to Calliphoridae seasonality in a temperate climate like that NW of Buenos Aires province (Centeno et al., 2004), Calliphora macellaria
are most abundant during the late spring and early summer. Thus, the abundance of puparia of C. macellaria indicates that decomposition would have taken place during the warm season of the year, probably the end of spring or the beginning of summer. The absence here of other Calliphoridae species that are common during other seasons of the year reinforces this prediction. These results are supported by thin-section analysis of the pup and adult sea lion teeth, which corroborate the summer as the most probable season of their demise.
Geomorphological analyses show that the layer containing the pinneped bones is composed of small gravel (coming from the palaeocliff) mixed with coarse sand and small scattered mollusc valves. This indicates that the corpses were buried by a mass wasting event, possibly due to torrential rain. Under semiarid climatic conditions with cool temperatures, severe droughts commonly alternate with violent pluviometric episodes that can move a great amount of detritus. Coronato & Del Valle (1993) calculated that the 63% of the hydric erosion that occurred in the northeast of Chubut during a sixteen month period was due to only two intense pluviometric summer episodes. (see Serran et al., 2007 for further information).
To calculate the length of time the corpses were exposed prior to burial, it is important to take into account the development rates of C. macellaria in the laboratory, which vary between 13 and 14 days at temperatures between 16[degrees] C and 29[degrees] C (Greenberg, 1991). The added time of overlapping generations extends the estimated duration of exposure somewhat. The minimum development time for a C. macellaria larva to reach stage III is estimated to be two days (under the previously described conditions); at this time, the larva entered into an empty puparium left behind by the previous generation in order to pupate (Byrd & Butler, 1996). This indicates that the carcasses were unburied until at least the 10th or 11th day of succession, being able to attract C. macellaria and be colonized with new eggs, from which arose the larvae that pupated in empty puparia.
Cadaveric decomposition studies conducted in Buenos Aires province during the summer showed that dermestid beetles were captured 10 days after the beginning of succession, when remains were in an advanced decomposition stage (Centeno et al., 2002). This span coincides with the estimated time that the corpses remained exposed based on the remains of C. macellaria. These data allow us to conclude that the first stages of decomposition would have been reached by at least 10 or 11 days post-mortem. Then, the remains were unburied until reaching a dry stage (mummification/skeletonization), providing suitable habitat for beetles such as D. maculatus and eventually, sarcophagous moths such as T. biselliella. The interval length of this final stage is hard to estimate, considering that T. biselliella takes almost 40 days to reach the pupa stage. From this, it can be assumed that approximately 40 days passed following the initial stages of decomposition.
The post-mortem interval thus can be estimated as 50 days, this being the time interval in which the cadaveric succession developed before reaching a stage of near-skeletonization. Then the sea lion carcasses would have been buried by a mass wasting episode, possibly due to torrential rain.
We want to thank for the valuable commentaries of the reviewers of the article. Also we thank for E. Crespo and N. Garcia for the section analysis of the pup and adult sea lion teeth. The Lic. Serran have a fellowship from CONICET. Dr. Centeno is supported by Agencia Nacional de Promocion Cientifica y Tecnologica and Universidad Nacional de Quilmes.
Received and accepted February 20, 2008.
Benecke, M. 2001. A brief history of forensic entomology. Forensic Science International 120(1-2): 2-14.
Byrd, J. H. and J. F. Butler. 1996. Effects of Temperature on Cochliomyia macellaria (Diptera: Calliphoridae) Development. Journal of Medical Entomology 33(6): 901-905 (1996).
Carrott, J. and H. Kenward. 2001. Species Associations Among Insect Remains from Urban Archaeological Deposits and their Significance in Reconstructing the Past Human Environment. Journal of Archaeological Science 28: 887-905.
Centeno, N., M. Maldonado and A. Oliva. 2002. Seasonal patterns of arthropods occurring on sheltered and unsheltered pig carcasses in Buenos Aires province (Argentina). Forensic Science International 126: 63-70.
Centeno, N., D. Almorza and C. Arnillas. 2004. A Study of Diversity on Calliphoridae (Insecta: Diptera) in Hudson, Argentina. Neotropical Entomology 33(3): 387-390.
Coope, G. R. 1986. Coleoptera analysis. In: B. E. Berglund (ed.), "Handbook of Holocene Palaeoecology and Palaeohydrology.", pp. 703-713. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Coronato, F. and H. Del Valle. 1993. Methodological comparisons in the estimate of fluvial erosion in an arid closed basin of north-eastern Patagonia. Journal of Arid Environments 24:231-239.
Goff, M. L. 1993. Estimation of postmortem interval using arthropod development and successional patterns. Forensic Science Review 5(2): 81-94.
Greenberg, B. 1991. Flies as forensic indicators. Journal of Medical Entomology 28(5): 565-577.
Hellqvist, M. and G. Lemdahl. 1996. Insect Assemblages and Local Environment in the Mediaeval Town of Uppsala, Sweden. Journal of Archaeological Science 23: 873-881.
Oliva, A. 1997. Insectos de interes forense de Buenos Aires (Argentina). Primera lista ilustrada y datos bionomicos. Revista del Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales "Bernardino Rivadavia". Entomologia 7(2): 14-59.
Paez, M. 1993. Historia paleoambiental y ocupacion humana en el valle de Piedra Parada (Chubut).
En Actas de las II Jornadas de Arqueologia de la Patagonia, Centro Nacional Patagonico, Puerto Madryn. (electronic version).
Panagiotakopulu, E. 2001. New Records for Ancient Pests: Archaeoentomology in Egypt. Journal of Archaeological Science 28: 1235-1246.
Panagiotakopulu, E. 2004. Dipterous remains and archaeological interpretation. Journal of Archaeological Science 31:1675-1684.
Payne, J. A. and E. W. King. 1969. Lepidoptera associated with pig carrion. Journal of the Lepidopterists Society 23(3): 191-195.
Payne, J. A. and E. W. King. 1970. Coleoptera associated with pig carrion. Entomologist's Monthly Magazine 105: 224-232.
Petrulevicius, J. F. 2001. Cenozoic insects from Argentina. Proceedings of the First International Meeting on Paleoarthropodology, Special Issue of Acta Geologica Leopoldensia 24(52-53): 137-144 ISSN 0101-5303, Editora Unisinos, Ribeirao Preto.
Schabitz, F. and H. Liebricht. 1998. Landscape and climate development in the south-eastern part of the Arid Diagonal during the last 13,000 years. Bamberger Geographische Schriften H 15: 371-388.
Serran, M., N. Centeno, N. Weiler and J. Gomez Otero. 2007. Massive death of pinnipeds 1200 years ago: Taphonomic history of the "Lobos site" (Golfo Nuevo, Patagonia, Argentina). Quaternary International (2007). doi: 10.1016/j.quaint.2006.12.001
N. CENTENO (1), M. SERRAN (1), J. GOMEZ OTERO (2) AND N. WEILER (2)
(1) Centro de Estudios e Investigaciones, Universidad Nacional de Quilmes, Saenz Pena 352, Bernal (B1876BXD), Provincia de Buenos Aires, Argentina. e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org; email@example.com
(2) CENPAT, Boulevard Brown S/Nro (9120), Puerto Madryn (Provincia de Chubut), Argentina. e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org; email@example.com
Table 1. Species and body parts of arthropod remains from Sitio Lobos. Order Family Species Diptera Calliphoridae Cochliomyia macellaria F. Diptera Fannidae Fannia sp. Coleoptera Dermestidae Dermestes maculatus De Geer Cleridae Necrobia rufipes De Geer Lepidoptera Tineidae Tineola sp. cf. biselliella Hummel Order Remains Diptera pupae, empty puparia and puparia containing other puparia or an adult Diptera pupa inside C macellaria puparium, empty puparia Coleoptera exuvia head, thorax, elytra, abdomen Lepidoptera cocoon
|Gale Copyright:||Copyright 2009 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.|