Temporomandibular joint: conservative care of TMJ dysfunction in a competitive swimmer.
Objective: To detail the progress of a patient with TMJ dysfunction
and headaches due to swimming, who underwent a conservative treatment
plan featuring soft tissue therapy, spinal manipulative therapy, and
Clinical Features: The most important features were initial bilateral temporal headaches and persistent left sided TMJ pain brought about by bilateral breathing while swimming. Conventional treatment aimed at decreasing hypertonic muscles, increasing hyoid mobility, improving TMJ mobility, resolving cervical restrictions, and improving digastric facilitation.
Intervention and Outcome: The conservative treatment approach utilized in this case involved soft tissue therapy, hyoid mobility treatment, TMJ mobilization, spinal manipulative therapy, and digastric facilitation. Outcome measures included subjective pain ratings, range of motion, and motion palpation of the cervical spine.
Conclusion: A patient with bilateral temporal headaches and TMJ pain due to bilateral breathing while swimming appeared to be relieved of his pain after three treatments of soft tissue therapy, hyoid mobility treatment, spinal manipulative therapy, and digastric facilitation.
(JCCA 2009; 53(3):165-172)
KEY WORDS: temporomandibular, joint, headache, manipulation
Objectif: Expliquer en detail les progres d'un patient souffrant du dysfonctionnement d'une articulation temporomandibulaire (ATM) et de maux de tete relies a la natation, a qui Ton a prescrit un traitement conservateur comprenant un travail des tissus mous, une manipulation rachidienne et une readaptation.
Caracteristiques cliniques : La plus importante manifestation du dysfonctionnement se presentait d'abord sous forme de cephalees temporales bilaterales et de douleur persistante ATM du cote gauche, causee par la respiration bilaterale pendant la natation. Le traitement conventionnel visait a adoucir les muscles hypertoniques, accroitre la mobilite hyo'idienne, ameliorer la mobilite ATM, eliminer les contraintes cervicales et ameliorer le fonctionnement du muscle digastrique.
Intervention et resultat : La methode de traitement conservateur utilise dans le present cas a consiste a centrer le traitement sur les tissus mous, la mobilite hyo'idienne, la mobilite ATM, la manipulation rachidienne et le travail du muscle digastrique. L'indicateur des resultats a inclus des cotes subjectives de classification de la douleur, la portee du mouvement et la palpation du mouvement de la colonne cervicale.
Conclusion : Un patient souffrant de cephalees temporales bilaterales et de douleurs ATM attribuables a la respiration bilaterale pendant la natation semble etre soulage de sa douleur apres trois traitements d'une therapie des tissus mous, d'un traitement de la mobilite hyoidienne, d'une manipulation rachidienne et d'un traitement facilitant le fonctionnement du muscle digastrique.
(JACC 2009; 53(3):165-172)
MOTS CLES : temporomandibulaire, articulation, mal de tete, manipulation
Temporomandibular joint disorders
Temporomandibular joint disorders (Care and treatment)
Temporomandibular joint disorders (Research)
Swimming (Health aspects)
Orthopedic surgery (Health aspects)
Howitt, Scott D.
|Publication:||Name: Journal of the Canadian Chiropractic Association Publisher: Canadian Chiropractic Association Audience: Academic Format: Magazine/Journal Subject: Health Copyright: COPYRIGHT 2009 Canadian Chiropractic Association ISSN: 0008-3194|
|Issue:||Date: July, 2009 Source Volume: 53 Source Issue: 3|
|Topic:||Event Code: 310 Science & research|
|Geographic:||Geographic Scope: Canada Geographic Code: 1CANA Canada|
The temporomandibular joint (TMJ) is a complex junction in the human skull incorporating disk, masticatory muscles, and cervicocranial innervation. The prevalence of TMJ pain in the general population is reported to be 25%. (1) Common signs associated with TMJ discomfort include popping, clicking, muscle tenderness, joint tenderness, and decreased opening of the jaw. (1) This joint has also been suggested to be a key propagating factor in oral and cervical disorders as well as headaches. TMJ pain commonly occurs with capsulitis, synovitis, meniscal derangement, tendonitis, degenerative joint disease, and infection. (2) The main movements which the TMJ is responsible for are the opening and closing of the mouth. Proper opening mechanics involves both mandible depression and chin retrusion. Alternatively mouth closing includes mandible elevation and chin protrusion. (2)
The National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (NBCE) 2005 survey of 2574 chiropractors in the USA confirms that TMJ pain or Temporal Mandibular Disorder (TMD) is a condition that is commonly seen. Their data rated TMD complaints as being a condition that 'sometimes' (26-50%) presents to a chiropractors office. In fact, the 2003 paper by Raphael et al reported that in their survey of women with TMD, that 22% of them chose complementary alternative therapies, which included chiropractic. (3)
Early signs of TMJ dysfunction vary from one patient to another, however commonly reported findings include: headache and facial pain, impaired jaw mobility, clicking or crepitus, pain in the TMJ and ears, masticatory muscle pain, "stuffy" sensation in the ears, eustachian tube dysfunction, and dizzy spells. (4)
Other predisposing factors can include joint specific issues such as joint laxity, anatomical variation, capsular or muscular inflammation, repetitive motion, and static articular stress.
The number of strokes a freestyle swimmer takes in a practice is considered to be approximately 2500. Assuming they are taking a breath every three strokes, this translates into the swimmer turning their head over 800 times per workout. (5) This is further complicated if the majority of the swimmers breaths are unilaterally (only rotating the head in one direction for breathing in a front crawl) as it could lead to muscle imbalances. Such dysfunctions can be further irritated by postural alterations such as forward head carriage. Repetitively turning the head from the axis of rotation at C1-C2, into a stressed position while breathing, can cause the neck to adopt a hyperextended and rotated position. It has been suggested that the overuse of a hyperextended cervical spine can predispose the swimmer to cervicogenic headaches. (5) Thus bilateral breathing (breathing to the left when the right arm is extended overhead and to the right when the left arm is extended overhead) during the front crawl is promoted in swimmers from an early age to enhance muscle balance.
The term for a headache occurring during physical activity is called "benign exertional headache." Although swimming headaches are rare, they are often described as sudden, severe, exploding, and pulsating. (10,11) It has been suggested that vascular factors are involved in the pathogenesis of swimming headaches. (10) Increased levels of CO2 in the blood, due to insufficient ventilation while swimming, could possibly give rise to cerebral vasodilatation, resulting in increased intracranial pressure leading to an exertional headache. (10) Another possible explanation for swimming induced headaches could be neuronal irritation. Cervicogenic headaches while swimming may also be the result of nerve entrapments in hypertonic cervical muscles brought on by the repetitive rotation and hyperextension of the neck. Such a mechanism could also be used to explain a TMJ dysfunction brought on by swimming via relay through the previously mentioned trigeminal spinal tract subnucleus and C1-C2 dorsal horn transitional zone.
The purpose of this case report was to describe a patient who experienced TMJ pain and headaches during swimming while training for a triathlon. The patient underwent a successful, simple, non-invasive chiropractic treatment plan using manual procedures and rehabilitative training for the TMJ musculature as well as undergoing technique and postural education for their swimming stroke.
This case report involves a 31 year old male recreational triathlete who developed headaches and TMJ pain while attempting to incorporate bilateral breathing into his freestyle swimming training regime. Initially the patient was breathing every 2 or 4 strokes only rotating his head to the left side. Breathing bilaterally every 3 strokes introduced an additional right sided rotation breathing. On his first day of initially attempting to bilaterally breathe the patient experienced a bilateral temporal headache after his swim which was relieved by Advil[TM]. Two days later while attempting to bilaterally breathe for the second time, the patient experienced another bilateral temporal headache (again relieved by Advil[TM]) and left sided jaw pain while in the pool. The next day while attempting to bilaterally breathe for the third time the patient experienced a mild headache, extreme jaw pain, and an inability to open his mouth more than 50% which prompted the patient to present for treatment.
The patient was a physically fit health care professional who reported to work-out daily (either swimming, biking, running, or weightlifting, each 2-3 times per week). He denied any previous incidences of TMJ pain or dental issues, but did report previous cervicogenic headaches as a student, that resolved with postural exercises. No previous motor vehicle accidents were reported however the patient acknowledge that he suffered several concussions in his youth playing minor sports. Occasional knee discomfort associated with his run training was noted however the primary complaint was his jaw pain and dysfunction which was aggravated by his swim training.
The subject presented with decreased hyoid mobility (less lateral motion from left to right) and a dysfunctional active mouth opening pattern where pterygoid hypertonicity/jaw jut was prominent. No headache or neck pain was noted at this time, but bilateral TMJ pain (with the left side greater than the right) was reported at the initial assessment. The subject rated his TMJ pain 7 out of 10 on Visual Analog Scale (VAS), while Neck Disability Index was zero out of 50. The centric relation protraction test (TMJ compression) and biting/jaw clenching did not reproduce pain. Motion palpation revealed the left TMJ to be subjectively hypermobile while the right TMJ was found to be hypomobile. A cervical spine screen found right rotation painful and decreased by 25% while left rotation was full but painful at end range. Bilateral restrictions were found with motion palpation at C0, C1, and C2. Jackson's, Spurling's, and Cervical Compression tests (as described by Vizniak's Clinical Chiropractic Handbook) were all found to be negative for facet joint and nerve root involvement, however left Kemps test was found to cause pain on the left at C1-C2 without radiation. Soft tissue palpation revealed tight and tender sternocleidomastoid (SCM), upper trapezius, levator scapula, superior and inferior oblique, rectus capitis minor, lateral pterygoids and masseter muscles bilaterally. Deep neck flexors were also found to be weak, as indicated by an endurance test in which the patient could only maintain a chin tucked position for 10 seconds and reported the sensation of a headache "coming on" at the conclusion of the test.
[FIGURE 1 OMITTED]
The patient was treated with 3 sessions of soft tissue therapy consisting of Active Release Technique[R] (ART[R]) to the SCM, upper trapezius, levator scapula, superior and inferior oblique, and rectus capitis minor muscles (see Figure 1); hyoid mobility treatment done passively with the patient lying supine and the slack taken out on the hyoid bone by pushing lateral to medial in both directions until resistance was encountered (see Figure 2); TMJ mobilization done passively taking out the joint slack and rotating the joint in a figure eight like motion (see Figure 3); spinal manipulative therapy was performed by rotary adjustment to C1-C2 (see Figure 4); and digastric exercises were accomplished by an isometric facilitation, every other day over the course of 1 week. Additionally the patient was instructed to continue digastric facilitation exercises by placing the tongue on the roof of his mouth while opening his jaw (see Figure 5) and deep neck flexor exercises (chin tucks) at home 2 to 3 times daily (see Figure 6). The patient returned to the pool 1 week later with a swimming coach for stroke assessment and reported no pain. These interventions combined with 1 week of rest resulted in relief from headaches and TMJ pain as the patient resumed his biweekly swim training with a VAS of zero out of 10. At follow up one month later the patient reported no reoccurrence of headache or TMJ pain, exhibited an improved mouth opening pattern and full range of TMJ and cervical spine motion. He also demonstrated an improved deep neck flexor endurance test to 45 seconds, and VAS remained zero out of 10.
[FIGURE 2 OMITTED]
The three main categories of TMJ disorders are myofascial pain, internal derangement, and degenerative destruction. (2) The myofascial category is the most common and often involves pain not only in the muscles of mastication but also muscles of the neck and shoulders. (2) A number of muscles can be involved with movement of the TMJ, however it has been suggested that the most important are the digastricus, masseter, and lateral pterygoid. (2) (see Figure 7) The primary action of the digastricus is to aid in opening of the mouth, whereas the masseter muscle is chiefly responsible for closing the mouth. The masseter is assisted in this task by the medial pterygoid and temporalis muscles. The lateral pterygoids bilaterally stabilize the TMJ and contribute to protrusion of the chin during mouth opening. (2) Manual treatments for relaxation, facilitation, and mobilization of these muscles have been shown to be successful in dealing with TMJ pain. (2)
[FIGURE 3 OMITTED]
[FIGURE 4 OMITTED]
[FIGURE 5 OMITTED]
[FIGURE 6 OMITTED]
Postural alterations have also been associated with TMJ disorders as individuals with an anterior head carriage typically display protrusion of the chin and hyperextension of the cervicocranial junction. (2) Prolonged static maintenance of this posture can cause lengthening of the deep neck flexors and coupled shortening of the suboccipital muscles. Furthermore, the masseter muscles can become hypertonic due to the increased gravitational challenge, whereas the antagonistic digastricus muscles are often found to be inhibited in people with this posture. Strength and performance of the TMJ and cervicocranial junction are thus compromised making this region less stable and prone to injury. (2)
The upper cervical spine (C1 and C2 spinal segments) is also implicated in TMJ disorders. The dorsal horns of this level of the spinal column represent a transition zone between the trigeminal spinal tract subnucleus (cranial nerve V) of the brainstem and the rest of the spinal cord. (12) Cranial nerve V contains 3 divisions: ophthalmic, maxillary, and mandibular. The mandibular division innervates the lower lip, cheek, teeth, and anterior two-thirds of the tongue, plus the skin of the lower jaw and the side of the head. (12) The TMJ is specifically innervated by the masseteric and auriculotemporal branches of the mandibular nerve. (13) It has been reported by Morch et al. that the C1 and C2 dorsal horns receive extensive primary afferent inputs from the lateral aspect of the face and from nerves of the craniofacial muscles such as those of the mandibular division of cranial nerve V supplying the masseter, temporalis, and anterior digastric muscles. (13,14) Afferent convergence patterns have been implicated as an important process underlying pain referral in conditions such as TMJ disorders. (13,14) It has also been documented that upper cervical dorsal horns receive nociceptive inputs from deep craniofacial tissues and act as a critical relay center in craniofacial nociceptive reflexes. (12,13) Previous studies have shown the involvement of the trigeminal spinal tract subnucleus and C1 dorsal horn to be an important relay site of deep and cutaneous nociceptive craniofacial information to higher brain centers. (14) These two structures also act as a significant interneuronal relay site for jaw reflex responses to deep noxious stimuli. These features suggest that the trigeminal spinal tract subnucleus and C1-C2 dorsal horns may act as one integrative functional unit to process nociceptive information from craniofacial structures such as the TMJ. (12)
[FIGURE 7 OMITTED]
Patients with TMJ disorders often have histories that reveal predisposing and complicating factors that can significantly contribute to their condition, such as muscle imbalance and upper cervical spine joint dysfunction. (15) One predisposing factor to consider in every TMJ patient is hypertonic sternocleidomastiod (SCM) muscles. In fact, trigger points in the SCM muscle can be used as an objective indicator for orofacial and cervicocranial disorders. (15) Chronic over activity of the neck flexors such as the SCM will cause an inhibitory weakening of the deep neck flexors and lead to a forward head posture seen with cervicocranial disorders. Tight SCM muscles can also lead to heterotopic pain in the form of temporal headaches, which is another common finding with TMJ pain. If left untreated this can lead to not only TMJ dysfunction but also compromise such functions as speech, swallowing, chewing, and respiration. (15)
When considering a swimmer with TMJ pain, stroke mechanics are recommended to be investigated with the assistance of a coach in order to avoid relapses and to ensure the athlete is performing with optimal biomechanical advantage. It is important to note that common swimming drills such as kicking with a flutter board can cause the neck to be put into a position of hyperextension for prolonged periods of time and thus should be avoided in athletes who have cervical pain. Improving or maintaining ideal posture and technique during practice may have long term benefits for the athlete. (5) Athletes with neck pain and decreased range of motion with tight cervical muscles will often experience relief of their symptoms from mobilizations or manipulation to the cervical spine. (5) Despite bilateral breathing causing the complaint in this patient, bilateral breathing during swim practices should be encouraged as breathing only to the favored side leads to muscular imbalances within the neck (especially with rotation). These muscular imbalances can be aggravated by forward head carriage, as the axis of rotation changes, resulting in greater extension and side bending of the cervical spine to compensate for the decreased rotation. Alternatively, breathing to the unfavored side may not rotate the body enough, potentially contributing to over-rotation of the neck and subsequent discomfort. (11) While often overlooked, scapula stability is also important in neck function and postural education. Even more important however is the role of the deep neck flexors, longus colli and longus capitis. Rehabilitative treatment for these muscles should focus on endurance exercises to improve the ability to contract over time. (5)
The 2000 publication by Skaggs and Liebenson describes 4 clinically useful tests for diagnosing and treating TMJ dysfunction which were used in this case. (2) The first test, Centric Relation Protraction Test, is a structural assessment test. It is designed to place the disc-condyle complex in the most stable position. A positive test indicates malposition of the disc-condyle complex and suggests a structural pathology with poor prognosis to conservative care. Possible causes of pain include disc dislocation, osteoarthritis, and capsulitis. (2) The remaining 3 tests are functional assessment tests. The second test, Mouth Opening Pattern Test, involves observing the patients chin while they open their mouth, paying special attention to the initiation of movement. A positive test is protrusion of the chin during the initiation of opening or limited opening range of motion, and indicates over-activity and tension of the masseter or lateral pterygoid muscles. Treatment (postisometric relaxation) focused on lateral pterygoids and involves passively opening the patients mouth and resisting their gentle attempt to poke the chin out. On relaxation, the clinician takes out slack in a posterior direction of chin retrusion to lengthen the muscle. Treatment (postisometric relaxation) focused on masseter muscles involves passively opening the patients mouth (down and back) while resisting the patients gentle attempt to close the mouth. On relaxation, the patient is asked to simulate a yawn, during which time, the clinician follows the mandible to the next barrier of resistance and the procedure is then repeated. (2) The third test, Hyoid Mobility Test, is done passively with the patient lying supine. The practitioner takes out the slack on the hyoid bone by pushing lateral to medial in both directions until resistance is encountered. A positive test is little or no springing of the bone or a distinct asymmetry of palpable tension and indicates increased tension in the digastric muscle on the ipsilateral side. Treatment (postisometric relaxation) focuses on the digastric muscle. The clinician prepositions the patient's mouth open with the chin in retrusion, contacting the hyoid on the blocked side. The clinician then attempts to close the patient's mouth and instruct the patient to resist closure. On relaxation the clinician follows the release of hyoid to next barrier and then repeats. (2) The fourth and final test, TMJ Mobility Test, is an active test done with light palpation of the disc-condyle complex just anterior to the tragus of the ear. This test assesses for symmetry in the translation of the condyles while the patient slowly opens and closes their mouth several times. Subjectively the clinician can appreciate either hypo or hypermobility of the TMJ. Treatment to a hypermobile joint involves connective tissue release techniques such as Active Release Technique, whereas a hypomobile joint is recommended to be treated via mobilizations. This is done by contacting the molars of the affected side with the thumb. Joint slack is taken out with long axis distraction and the practitioner gently rotates (clockwise or counterclockwise) the TMJ in a figure eight like motion for up to 20 seconds. (2)
Headaches in swimmers have been previously documented, however to our knowledge this is the first case were a TMJ dysfunction has been reported and treated in a swimmer. (10,11) The causes of TMJ complaints are believed to be multi-factorial and include postural alterations that can lead to hypo/hypertonic muscles and cervical spine restrictions, visceral insufficiency, and neuronal irritation. Conventional treatment aims at decreasing hypertonic muscles, increasing hyoid mobility, resolving cervical fixations, and improving digastric facilitation to enhance mouth opening patterns. Furthermore, the 2004 Cochrane review concluded there was weak evidence for the use of stabilisation splint therapy for reducing pain severity and was neither worse nor better than other active interventions. (16) More recently, the conservative care paper by Vinjamury et al. found the effectiveness of manual treatment for TMD to be both safe and effective. (17) In this case, a patient with bilateral temporal headaches and TMJ pain due to bilateral breathing while swimming appeared to be relieved of his pain after having three manual treatments and through incorporating digastric facilitation exercises and deep neck flexor exercises into their exercise regime. As a result, a prospective study to investigate TMJ dysfunction treatment through conservative manual therapies is suggested.
(1) George J, Fennema J, Maddox A, Nessler M, Skaggs C. The effect of cervical spine manual therapy on normal mouth opening in asymptomatic subjects. J Chiropractic Medicine. 2007; 6:141-145.
(2) Skaggs C, Liebenson C. Orofacial Pain. Top Clinical Chiropractic. 2000; 7(20):43-50.
(3) Raphael KG, Lausner JJ, Nayak S, Marbach JJ. Complementary and alternative therapy use by patients with myofascial temporomandibular disorders. J Orofac Pain. 2003; 17(1):36-41.
(4) Balestra C, Germonpre P, Marroni A, Snoeck T. Scuba diving can induce stress of the temporomandibular joint leading to headache. Br J Sports Medicine. 2004; 38:102-104.
(5) Pollard H, Fernandez M. Spinal musculoskeletal injuries associated with swimming: a discussion of technique. Australasia Chiropractic and Osteopathy. 2004; 12(2):72-80.
(6) Pollard H, Crocker D. Shoulder pain in elite swimmers. Australasia Chiropractic and Osteopathy. 1999; 8(3):91-95.
(7) McMaster W. Swimming injuries: An overview. Sports Medicine. 1996; 22(5):332-336.
(8) Kenal K, Knapp L. Rehabilitation of injuries in competitive swimmers. J Sports Medicine. 1996; 22(5):337-347.
(9) Troup J. The physiology and biomechanics of competitive swimming. Clinics in Sports Medicine. 1999; 18(2):267-283.
(10) Kim J. Swimming headache followed by exertional and coital headache. J Korean Medical Science. 1992; 7(3):276-279.
(11) Indo T, Takashashi A. Swimmer's migraine. Headache. 1990; 30:485-487.
(12) Hua J, Suna K, Vernon H, Sesslea B. Craniofacial inputs to upper cervical dorsal horn: implications for somatosensory information processing. Brain Research. 2005; 1044: 93-106.
(13) Morch C, Hu J, Arendt-Nielsen L, Sessle B. Convergence of cutaneous, musculoskeletal, dural and visceral afferents onto nociceptive neurons in the first cervical dorsal horn. European J Neuroscience. 2007; 26:142-154.
(14) Bronton J, Hu J, Sessle B. Effects of temporomandibular joint stimulation on nociceptive and nonnociceptive neurons of the cat's trigeminal subnucleus caudalis (medullary dorsal horn). J Neurophysiology. 1988; 59(5):1575-1589.
(15) Skaggs C. Temporomandibular dysfunction: chiropractic rehabilitation. J Bodywork and Movement Therapies. 1997; 1(4):208-213.
(16) Al-Ani MZ, Davies SJ, Gray RJ, Sloan P, Glenny AM. Stabilisation splint therapy for temporomandibular pain dysfunction syndrome. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2004. 1.
(17) Vinjamury SP, Singh BB, Comberiati R, Meier R, Holm S. Chiropractic treatment of temporomandibular disorders. Alternative Therapies. 2008; 14(4):60-63.
Erik Yuill, BPHE, BSc, MSc * Scott D. Howitt, BA, CK, CSCS, DC, FCCSS(C), FCCRS(C) **
* Clinic Intern, CMCC
** Assistant Professor, Clinical Education, Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College, 6100 Leslie St., Toronto, Ontario, M2H 3J1. Phone: (416) 226-6780 x7233. Fax: (416) 488-0470. Email: email@example.com
|Gale Copyright:||Copyright 2009 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.|