Study of polypharmacy and associated problems among elderly patients.
The study aims at the assessment of prescribing pattern for elderly
patients, since they are more prone to prescription of multiple
medications. The prescription of multiple medications leads to
polypharmacy, more adverse drug reactions and non-adherence to
treatment. The study was conducted on OPD basis in a rural health centre
for a period of six months. Information pertaining to the age, sex,
religion, monthly income, education level, any previous illnesses, or
any chronic diseases, any drug treatment, adherence to the treatment,
and self medication or non-allopathic treatment was collected. The study
included 310 elderly patients, among which 51.9% were males and 48.1%
were females. The prevalence of polypharmacy was 25.20%, more among
elderly men (26.10%) than women (24.20%), the odds ratio (OR) was 1.11.
The major fraction 35.81% of the patients was in the age group of 60-64
years. Only 59.3% were literate. 64.41% belonged to lower socioeconomic
status. The cardiovascular diseases 139 (44.83 %) followed by arthritis
121 (39.03%), and diabetes 58 (18.71%) were the most common ailments.
Anti-hypertensive drugs were prescribed in 26.13%,
analgesics/antipyretics in 19.68%, and antidiabetic drugs in 18.71%.
Non-adherence to therapy was seen in 49.68%. Self medication habits were
seen in 23.90% patients, who most commonly used analgesics/antipyretics
and antacids/anti-ulcer drugs. Polypharmacy is very common among elderly
and interventions to improve the optimal use of medication in elderly
could lead to reduction in the problems associated with polypharmacy.
KEY WORDS: Non-adherence; Polypharmacy; Self medication
Chronic diseases (Research)
Chronic diseases (Care and treatment)
Aged patients (Care and treatment)
Self-care, Health (Methods)
|Publication:||Name: Internet Journal of Medical Update Publisher: Dr. Arun Kumar Agnihotri Audience: Academic; Professional Format: Magazine/Journal Subject: Health Copyright: COPYRIGHT 2012 Dr. Arun Kumar Agnihotri ISSN: 1694-0423|
|Issue:||Date: Jan, 2012 Source Volume: 7 Source Issue: 1|
|Topic:||Event Code: 310 Science & research|
|Product:||Product Code: 2834510 Antacid Preparations NAICS Code: 325412 Pharmaceutical Preparation Manufacturing SIC Code: 2834 Pharmaceutical preparations|
|Geographic:||Geographic Scope: India Geographic Code: 9INDI India|
In India, life expectancy has steadily gone up from 32 years at the time of independence to over 63 years in 2001. In 2011 life expectancy has reached 66.8 years, in males it is 65.77 years and 67.95 years in females. There is no United Nations standard numerical criterion, but the UN agreed cut-off is 60+ years when referring to the elderly population (1). In India, the elderly (above 60 years) account for 7% of the total population. According to Census 2011, 5.5% of the India population is above 65 years of age. By 2020, 10.4% of population amounting to 142 million people 60 years or older will be living in India (2). A number of factors are believed to increase the risk of drug related problems in the elderly, including medication errors, inappropriate use of medications, polypharmacy, non-adherence to therapy and self medication (3). The term "Polypharmacy" is appropriately defined as the use of multiple medications and/or the administration of more medications than are clinically indicated, representing unnecessary drug use (4). The most common results of polypharmacy are increased adverse drug reactions, drug-drug interactions and higher costs (5). Polypharmacy is most common in the elderly but is also widespread in the general population (6). Patients at greatest risk of polypharmacy consequences include the elderly, psychiatric patients, patients taking five or more drugs concurrently, those with multiple physicians and pharmacies, recently hospitalized patients, individuals with concurrent comorbidities (7), low educational level (8), and those with impaired vision or dexterity. The study was primarily targeted at the elderly because, as a group they take more drugs than their younger counterparts and are known to be at risk of the side effects of many of the drugs they consume because of age-associated physiologic changes that may cause reduction in functional reserve capacity (i.e. the ability to respond to physiologic challenges or stress). These physiological changes with age have important practical implications for the clinical management of elderly patients: drug metabolism is altered, changes in response to commonly used drugs make different drug dosages necessary and there is need for rational preventive programs of diet and exercise in an effort to delay or reverse some of these changes (9).
The study was done on OPD basis and patients above the age of 60yrs attending the rural health centre OPD run by Rohilkhand medical college & Hospital, Bareilly, Uttar Pradesh during a five month period from 1 Aug 2008 to 31 Jan 2009 were registered under the study. The research protocol was approved by institutional ethical committee and informed consent obtained from each subject prior to inclusion in the study. The information was collected regarding- the age, sex, religion, monthly income, education level, any previous illnesses, or any chronic diseases, any drug treatment, adherence to the treatment, and self medication or treatment in any other system of medicine (like Homeopathy, Ayurveda, Unani, naturopathy). The socioeconomic status was assessed using Modified Prasad's socioeconomic classification. Modified Prasad's classification (1997) divides the population in to five classes based on per capita monthly income: class 1-1900 and above, 2 -950 to 1899, 3 -570 to 949, 4 -285 to 569, 5 -284 and below.
The study included 310 elderly patients, among which 161 (51.9%) were males and 149 (48.1%) were females. The prevalence of polypharmacy was 25.20%, more among the elderly men (26.10%) than women (24.20%). Out of 161 males and 149 females, polypharmacy was noticed in 42 males and 36 females (odds ratio [OR] 1.11). The Socio-demographic characteristics of the study population was collected and compiled in Table 1. Table 1 show that a major fraction (35.81%) of the patients were in the age group of 60-64 years old, while only 14.84 % of the patients were above 75 years of age. Males were in higher proportion in the study. 59.3% Literacy rate was found in the study population of patients. A majority of study population 64.41% belonged to lower socioeconomic status (Class 4 & 5) and 25.80% to middle class 3. Most of the study population were Hindus (210, 67.74%) followed by Muslims (71, 22.90%).
This study showed that cardiovascular diseases 139 (44.83 %) followed by arthritis 121 (39.03%), and diabetes 58 (18.71%) were the most common diseases in elderly. (Table 2) In cardiovascular diseases we included hypertension, angina, Ischemic Heart Diseases and stroke. In respiratory diseases, we included asthma, COPD and tuberculosis. The most commonly prescribed medications on chronic basis in elderly patients were anti-hypertensives in 81(26.13%), NSAIDs in 61 (19.68%), anti-diabetic in 51 (18.71%), and anti-platelets in 53(17.10%) patients (Table 3).
Out of 310 patients only 156 were regularly taking the medications and were adherent to the treatment, rest 154 (49.68%) were non-adherent to one or more medications prescribed to them. The reasons for non-adherence were:
* Poor economic status 112 (71.80%)
* Illiteracy 64 (41.03%)
* Lack of proper care at home 46 (29.48%)
* Forgetfulness 29 (18.83%)
* Poor drug supply 43 (27.56%)
* Adverse drug reactions 42 (26.92%)
* Unable to swallow medication 19 (12.18%)
The incidence of self medication in our study was 23.90% (74). Eighty-nine percent of the respondents used analgesics/antipyretics, Antacids/anti-ulcer drugs were used in 71.62% patients, followed by Expectorants/cough suppressants in 40.54%, Iron-multivitamins in 43.24%, Ayurvedic medicines in 25.70% and Homeopathic drugs in 17.6% (Table 4).
The term "Polypharmacy" is appropriately defined as the use of multiple medications and/or the administration of more medications than are clinically indicated, representing unnecessary drug use (3). It is defined as concomitant use of five or more drugs and it could enhance drug interactions and drug related problems 10 The prevalence of potential drug-drug interactions increases in a linear mode with increasing age and with the number of drugs prescribed (11). Polypharmacy is very commonly seen among ICU treated patients as it is difficult to treat patients in the ICU with multiple co-morbidities with less number of drugs as they require drugs for treatment of specific condition as well as for prophylaxis, but it is also essential to keep a balance between the number of drugs and effective pharmacotherapy (12). In our study 310 elderly patients (above 60yrs age) were included, among which 161 (51.9%) were males and 149 (48.1%) were females. The polypharmacy was more among the elderly men than women, it was noticed in 42 males and 36 females (odds ratio [OR] 1.11). In a similar study, the prevalence of polypharmacy in patients over 65 years-old was 33.77% (13). This study showed that cardiovascular diseases 139 (44.83 %) followed by arthritis 121 (39.03%), diabetes 58 (18.71%) were the most common diseases in elderly. The most commonly prescribed medications on chronic basis in elderly patients were anti-hypertensive drugs in 81 (26.13%), NSAIDs in 61 (19.68%), anti-diabetic in 51 (18.71%), and anti-platelets in 53(17.10%). In a similar study, cardiovascular drugs, antirheumatics, and analgesics were the most frequently consumed therapeutic classes (14). Out of 310 patients only 156 were regularly taking the medications and were adherent to the treatment, the other 154 (49.68%) showed non-compliance to the treatment. The most common associated factors for non-compliance were poor economic status (71.8%) followed by illiteracy (41%). The percentage of non-compliance in our study was comparable to other similar studies (15). The compliance was noted to be on higher side when pharmacist provided the prescribed drug and counseled the patient at home (15). Literacy rate in India in 2011 is 74.04%. In India, among elderly people literacy rate ranges from 80% to 38% in different studies (16,17). Our study showed that 41.7% of respondents were illiterate. It was observed in this study that illiteracy is higher among females (53.69%) than males (28.57%). The disparity in literacy status may be attributed to the fact that educating females in those days was not considered as important as establishing a marriage at an early age. The incidence of self medication in our study was 23.90% (74). Previous Over-the-Counter (OTC) medicine use studies indicate that about 50% of adults over 65 regularly use OTC pain relievers and vitamins, 23% regularly use antacids, and 10% regularly use cold remedies or antihistamines (18). In another study, 59.3% reported taking something for pain over the month preceding the survey. Of these, 49.5% reported taking an OTC NSAID pain reliever (e.g. aspirin, ibuprofen, Motrin, Advil, Excedrin, etc.) and 39.4% reported taking acetaminophen (e.g. generics or Tylenol) most often for pain (19).
Polypharmacy in the elderly should be addressed emphatically as it leads to associated problems of non-adherence and self medication, apart from causing adverse drug reactions, drug interaction and increased cost of therapy. In one study on polypharmacy, the clinical pharmacist performed the drug therapy reviews and taught the patients about drug safety and polypharmacy. They also colloborated with the physicians and patients to correct polypharmacy problems. Similar programs are likely to reduce the potentially deleterious consequences of polypharmacy. Such programs hinge upon patients and doctors informing pharmacists of other medications being prescribed, as well as herbal, over-the-counter substances and supplements that occasionally interfere with prescription-only medication (20).
Results of the study revealed that polypharmacy is a significant issue and little research has been conducted regarding the methods primary care providers utilize to assess polypharmacy. Interventions to improve the optimal use of medication will need to target policy, patients and physicians. Better information needs to be provided to physicians and patients about the risks and benefits of drug therapy, and the problems of patient compliance and inappropriate and unnecessary prescribing need to be addressed.
(1.) Health statistics and health information systems. Retrieved from: http://www.who.int/healthinfo/survey/ageingd efnolder/en/index.html.
(2.) WHO Fact Sheet No: 135, Revised 2007.
(3.) Royal College of Physicians. Medication for the elderly: a report of the Royal College of Physicians, London. J R Coll Physicians Lond. 1984;18(1):7-17.
(4.) Hajjar ER, Cafiero AC, Hanlon JT. Polypharmacy in elderly patients. Am J Geriatr Pharmacother. 2007 Dec; 5(4): 345-51.
(5.) Haider SI, Johnell K, Weitoft GR. The influence of educational level on polypharmacy and inappropriate drug use: a register-based study of more than 600,000 older people. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2009 Jan; 57(1):62-9.
(6.) Haider SI, Johnell K, Thorslund M, et al. Trends in polypharmacy and potential drug-drug interactions across educational groups in elderly patients in Sweden for the period 1992-2002. In J Clin Pharmacol Ther. 2007 Dec;45(12):643-53.
(7.) Boyd CM, Darer J, Boult C, et al. Clinical practice guidelines and quality of care for older patients with multiple comorbid diseases: implications for pay for performance. JAMA. 2005 Aug;294(6):716-24.
(8.) Haider SI, Johnell K, Thorslund M, et al. Analysis of the association between polypharmacy and socioeconomic position among elderly aged > or =77 years in Sweden. Clin Ther. 2007 Feb;32(2):419-27.
(9.) Boss GR, Seegmiller JE. Age-related physiological changes and their clinical significance. West J Med. 1981 Dec;135(6):434-40.
(10.) Viktil KK, Blix HS, Moger TA, et al. Polypharmacy as commonly defined is an indicator value in the assessment of drug-related problems. Br J Clin Pharmacol. 2007 Feb;63(2):187-95.
(11.) Lin CF, Wang CY, Bai CH. Polypharmacy, aging and potential drug-drug interactions in outpatients in Taiwan: a retrospective computerized screening study. Drugs Aging. 2011 Mar;28(3):219-25.
(12.) John LJ, Devi P, John J. Drug utilization study of antimicrobial agents in medical intensive care unit of a tertiary care hospital. Asian J Pharm Clin Res. 2011; 4(2);81-4.
(13.) Garrido-Garrido EM, Garcia-Garrido I, Garcia-Lopez-Duran JC, et al. Study of polymedicated patients over 65 years-old in an urban primary care centre. Rev Calid Asist. 2011 Mar-Apr;26(2):90-6.
(14.) Rozenfeld S. Prevalence, associated factors, and misuse of medication in the elderly: a review. Cad Saude Publica. 2003 May Jun;19(3):717-24.
(15.) Okuno J, Yanagi H, Tomura S. Compliance and knowledge about prescribed medication among elderly home-care recipients by method of providing medications. Nippon Ronen Igakkai Zasshi. 2001 Sep;38(5):644-50.
(16.) Padda AS, Mohan V, Singh J, et al. Health Profile of aged persons in urban and rural field practice areas of Medical College Amritsar. Indian J Community Med. 1998;23:72-6.
(17.) Singh C, Mathur JS, Mishra VN, et al. Social problems of aged in a rural population. Indian J Community Med. 1994;19:23-5.
(18.) Stewart R. Availability of OTC drugs increases total medication use in elderly. Age Ageing. 1991;20:182-8.
(19.) Neafsey PJ, Shellman J. Adverse self-medication practices of older adults with hypertension attending blood pressure clinics: adverse self-medication pactices. The Internet Journal of Advanced Nursing Practice. 2001; 5(1): retrieved from http://www.ispub.com/journal/the-internetjournal-of -advanced-nursing-practice/volume- 5-number-1/adverse-self-medication-practicesof-older -adults-with-hypertension-attending- blood-pressure-clinics-adverse-selfmedication-practices.html
(20.) Zarowitz BJ, Stebelsky LA, Muma BK, et al. Reduction of high-risk polypharmacy drug combinations in patients in a managed care setting. Pharmacotherapy. 2005 Nov; 25(11):1636-45.
Shalini * MD and MC Joshi ([PSI]) ([dagger]) MD
* Associate professor, ([dagger]) Assistant Professor, Department of Pharmacology Rohilkhand Medical College Hospital, Bareilly (UP), India
(Received 12 April 2011 and accepted 23 June 2011)
([PSI]) Correspondence at: Department of Pharmacology, Rohilkhand Medical College Hospital, Bareilly, UP India; Mobile: +919759850210; Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Table 1. Socio-demographic characteristics Variables Male (n=161) Female (n-149) Total (n=310) Age (yrs) 60-64 53 (36.02%) 53 (35.57%) 111 (35.01%) 65-69 45 (27.95%) 49 (32.88%) 94 (30.32%) 70-74 32 (19.87%) 27 (18.12%) 59 (19.03%) >75 26 116.15%) 20 (13,42%) 46 (14.84%) Education Illiterate 46 (28.57%) 80 (53.69%) 126 (40.64%) Literate 115 (71.43%) 69 (46.31%) 184 (59.35%) Socio-economic status Glass 1 6 (3.73%) 3 (2.01%) 9 (2.90%) Class 2 9 (5.59%)) 12 (3.05%) 21 (6.80%) CIass 3 46 (28.57%) 34 (22.82%) 80 (25.80%) Class 4 92 (57.14%) 79 (53.02%) 171 (55.16%) Class 5 8 (4.97%) 21 (14.01%)) 29 (9.35%) Table 2: Disease pattern of elderly Disease Male (n=161) Female (n=149) Total (n=310) Cardiovascular 83 56 139 (44.84%) diseases Diabetes 31 27 58 (18.71%) Respiratory diseases 26 28 54 (17.42%) Cataract 43 37 80 (25.81%) Arthritis 69 52 121 (39.03%) Piles 23 9 32 (10.32%) Benign prostrate 32 00 32 (10.32%) hypertrophy Hearing loss 29 11 40 (12.90%) Neurological 17 14 31 (10.0%) disorders Table 3: Drug utilization pattern in elderly Drag group Male (n=161) Female (n=149) Total (n=310) Anti-hypertensives 52 39 81 (26.13%) Anti-platelets 30 23 53 (17.10%) Anti-anginal 11 4 15 (4.84%) Hypolipidemics 9 5 14 (4.52%) Anti-diabetic 31 27 58 (18.71%) NSAIDs 32 29 61 (19:68%) Broncho dilators 13 15 28 (9.0%) Anti-tubercular 9 5 14 (4.52%) Anti-depressants 12 11 23 (7.42%) Anti-parkinsonism 5 3 8 (2.58%) Steroids 16 17 31 (10.0%) Table 4. Self medications in elderly patients Drug Category Male(n=41) Female (n=32) Total=74 Analgesics/Antipyretics 39 27 66(89.20%) Antacids/Antiulcer 31 22 53(71.62%) Expectorants/cough 17 13 30(40.54%) suppressants Iron-Multivitamin 11 21 32(43.24%) Ayurvedic medicines 12 7 19(25.70%) Homeopathy medicines 10 3 13(17.60%)
|Gale Copyright:||Copyright 2012 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.|