Risk of second non breast malignancies (SNBM) in relation to Brca1 and Brca2 mutation status following breast-conserving surgery and radiotherapy.
BRCA mutations (Physiological aspects)
Breast cancer (Care and treatment)
Breast cancer (Genetic aspects)
Radiotherapy (Complications and side effects)
Radiotherapy (Genetic aspects)
Breast diseases (Risk factors)
Breast diseases (Genetic aspects)
Ovarian cancer (Risk factors)
Ovarian cancer (Genetic aspects)
Breast (Complications and side effects)
Breast (Genetic aspects)
Kirova, Youlia M.
|Publication:||Name: American Journal of Immunology Publisher: Science Publications Audience: Professional Format: Magazine/Journal Subject: Biological sciences Copyright: COPYRIGHT 2006 Science Publications ISSN: 1553-619X|
|Issue:||Date: July, 2006 Source Volume: 2 Source Issue: 3|
|Topic:||Event Code: 310 Science & research|
|Product:||Product Code: 8521215 Immunology NAICS Code: 54171 Research and Development in the Physical, Engineering, and Life Sciences|
|Geographic:||Geographic Scope: France Geographic Code: 4EUFR France|
Abstract: Women from hereditary breast cancer families with BRCA1/2
germline mutation are at increased risk for contralateral breast cancer
(BC) and for ovarian cancer (OC). It is less clear whether mutation
status influences the rate of SNBM other than OC. In addition, little is
known on the risk of OC in individuals from hereditary BC families
without identified BRCA mutation. Our purpose was to answer to these two
questions. We retrospectively analysed a cohort of women with small
cancers treated with breast conserving surgery and radiotherapy at our
Institut from 1981 to 2000. The studied population was matched using
strict criteria. BRCA1/2 carriers had more SNBM than the French women
population (FWP) (SIR=1099.2 [354.3-2565.4], p < [10.sup.-3]); there
were no differences between non carriers or controls and the FWP
(SIR=149.3 [30.0-436.2] and SIR=80 [21.5-204.7], respectively). The
BRCA1/2 carriers and non carriers had more OC than the FWP (SIR=9640.1
[2593.6-24680.6]; p < [10.sup.-3] and SIR=1155.7 [129.8-4172.6];
p<0.05, respectively). We did not find any differences between the
incidence rates of digestive, gynaecological and lung carcinoma between
controls and the FWP, between BRCA1/2 carriers and the FWP; and between
non carriers and the FWP. After 9 year follow-up, our study showed that
the rate of OC was increased in BRCA1/2 mutation carriers as well as in
non carriers compared to the FWP. We also showed that these patients
were not at higher risk of SNBM other than OC. No differences have been
found in the incidence rates of SNBM other than OC between controls and
the FWP, between BRCA1/2 carriers, non carriers and the general
population, but more statistical power is needed to confirm these
Key words: BRCA1/2 germline mutation, second non breast malignancies, ovarian cancer
Women from hereditary breast cancer (BC) families who carry a BRCA1 or BRCA2 germline mutation are at increased risk for contralateral breast cancer and for ovarian cancer [1-3]. Special programs of follow-up, risk-reduction strategies, including intensive screening and/or risk-reducing surgery are developed and proposed to mutation carriers [3,4]. It is less clear whether mutation status influences the rate of second non breast malignancies (SNBM) other than ovarian cancer . In addition, little is known on the risk of ovarian cancer in individuals from hereditary breast cancer families without identified BRCA mutation. The purpose of this study was to answer to these two questions.
PATIENTS AND METHODS
We retrospectively analysed a cohort of women with small breast cancers treated with breast conserving surgery and radiotherapy at the Institut Curie from 1981 to 2000. These patients were invited to attend the family cancer clinic of our institute between 1990 and 2001 if they presented with a familial history of breast or ovarian cancer. Selection criteria and the procedure used for molecular testing, as well as the way to obtain information such as family cancers, age at cancer diagnosis of relatives and age at death or current age have been reported previously [6,7]. Molecular testing offered to women who presented with one of the following family criteria: (i) two first-degree relatives affected with cancer, with at least either one with invasive breast cancer before 41 years or one with ovarian cancer at any age and (ii) at least three first- or second-degree relatives from the same lineage affected with invasive breast or ovarian cancer at any age. The index case was one of the affected family members. The probability of being carrier of a breast cancer predisposing allele mutation was estimated by taking into account the segregation parameters of Claus modified by Easton and by using the MLINK program [8,9]. After informing the patients about the aims and the limits of breast cancer genetic testing, a blood sample was collected with their written consent. One hundred thirty one patients (with 136 breast cancers) were tested. All of them underwent conservative surgery and radiotherapy in our hospital. They were matched to 261 control breast cancer patients (with 271 tumors) without family history (sporadic cases), taken from a prospectively registered population of 9179 patients in the Institut Curie's breast cancer database . All of them had been treated conservatively from 1981 to 1999 at the Institut Curie. Matching was performed on an individual basis: for each case two controls were randomly selected. Matching factors included the age at diagnosis, year of treatment and period of follow-up: the follow-up of controls was at least equal to the time-interval between diagnosis and genetic testing in cases. BRCA status was unknown in all patients but one at the time of diagnosis and treatment. Clinical, pathological and outcome data were recorded. One control tumour has been excluded from the group because it did not respect selection criteria. All patients underwent breast-conserving treatment: wide surgical excision of the primary tumour and axillary lymph node dissection in most cases followed by breast irradiation and regional node irradiation when nodes were involved. More information concerning the genetic testing can be found in previously published data . Incidence rates of each SNBM localisation found in our groups were estimated for 100,000 person-year (PY) in the whole population of patients and for each of the three groups (mutation carriers, non-carriers and controls). The incidence in each group was compared to the incidence in the French women population, using the standardized incidence ratio SIR .
BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations were found in 20.6% patients with a family history. Nineteen patients had a BRCA1 mutation and 8 had a BRCA2 mutation. Median follow-up for all 392 patients was 8.75 years (range 2.25 - 19.4 years). The follow-up of controls was at least equal to the time-interval between diagnosis and genetic testing in cases. The median patients' age at diagnosis was: 43 years (range, 26-60) in carriers, 43.5 (24-78) in non-carriers and 43 (23-79) in sporadic groups, respectively (p 0.92). There was no significant difference in menopausal status between the three groups (p 0.24). The 9-year SNBM-free interval rates were: 98% [97-100%] in the control group, 97% [94-100%] in the BRCA1/2 non carriers and 79% [6597%] in the BRCA1/2 carriers, respectively (p<[10.sup.-5]). From 8 cancers in the "familial group", there were 5 in BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutation carriers (4 ovaries and 1 pancreatic carcinoma) and 3 in BRCA1 and BRCA2 non carriers (2 ovarian and 1 meningioma). In the group of controls, there were 3 gynaecological tumours (endometrium and cervix) and 1 small cell lung cancer. Overall, BRCA1/2 carriers had more SNBM than the French women (SIR=1099.2 [354.3-2565.4], p<[10.sup.-3]); we did not find any differences between BRCA1/2 non carriers or controls and the French population (SIR=149.3 [30.0-436.2] and SIR=80 [21.5-204.7], respectively). The BRCA1/2 carriers and BRCA1/2 non carriers had more ovarian cancer than the French population (SIR=9640.1 [2593.6-24680.6]; p<[10.sup.-3] and SIR=1155.7 [129.8-4172.6]; p<0.05, respectively). We did not find any differences between the incidence rates of digestive, gynaecological and lung carcinoma between controls and the French women population, between BRCA1/2 carriers and the French population; and between BRCA1/2 non carriers and the French population. These results are presented in Table 1-3. Some studies have suggested that patients with familial breast cancer history are at increased risk of developing ovarian cancer compared with general population [11,12]. Our results support these findings with median follow-up of nine years. Other authors reported that women from BRCA mutation-negative, site specific breast cancer families were not at increased risk for ovarian cancer . However, the mean follow-up of patients in this study was only 40.6 months.
Our study confirms the conclusion of Thompson et al. , that the first site of non breast malignancies is the ovary. In spite of the homogeneity of our series and the matching of patients with their controls, the number of patients is not sufficient to make definitive conclusions. Studies of larger series of patients with longer follow-up are needed before decreeing that this specific population of patients does not need special screening for ovarian cancer. Other interesting fact showed by our study is that the patients, who present BRCA1/BRCA2 mutation, have no elevated risk for cancers at sites other than the breast and ovaries. The power of our study is not enough to confirm this conclusion. We prepare another study with more patients to answer to this question.
In conclusion, after 9 year follow-up, our study showed that the rate of ovarian cancer was increased in BRCA1/2 mutation carriers as well as in BRCA1/2 non carriers compared to the general population. We also showed that these patients were not at higher risk of SNBM other than ovarian cancer. Therefore, screening for ovarian cancer is needed for both carriers and non carriers. However, large prospective screening programs are needed to evaluate the risk of ovarian cancer before offering risk-reduction strategies to women with family history but without BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation. No differences have been found in the incidence rates of SNBM other than ovarian cancer between controls and the French women population, between BRCA1/2 carriers, non carriers and the general population, but more statistical power is needed to confirm these results.
[1.] Antoniou, A., P.D. Pharoah, S. Narod, H.A. Risch, J.E. Eyfjord and J.L. Hopper et al., 2003. Average risks of breast and ovarian cancer associated with BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutations detected in case series unselected for family history: A combined analysis of 22 studies. Am. J. Human. Genet., 72: 1117-30.
[2.] Kirova, Y., D. Stoppa-Lyonnet, A. Savignoni, B. Sigal-Zafrani, N. Fabre and A. Fourquet, 2005. Risk of breast recurrence and contralateral breast cancer in relation to BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutation status following breast-conserving surgery and radiotherapy. Eur. J. Cancer, 41: 2304-11.
[3.] Kauff, N.D., N. Mitra, M.E. Robson, K.E. Hurley, S. Chuai and D. Goldfrank et al., 2005. Risk of ovarian cancer in BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutation negative hereditary breast cancer families. J. Natl. Cancer Inst., 97: 1382-4.
[4.] Narod, S.A. and W.D. Foulkes, 2004. BRCA1 and BRCA2: 1994 and beyond. Nat. Rev. Cancer, 4: 665-76.
[5.] Thompson, D. and D.F. Easton, 2002 The breast cancer linkage consortium: Cancer incidence in BRCA1 mutation carriers. J. Natl. Cancer Inst., 94: 1358-65.
[6.] Wagner, T., D. Stoppa-Lyonnet and E. Fleischmann et al., 1999. Denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography detects reliably BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations. Genomics, 62: 369-376.
[7.] Stoppa-Lyonnet, D., P. Laurent-Puig and L. Essioux, et al., 1997. BRCA1 sequence variations in 160 individuals referred to a breast/ovarian family cancer clinic. Institut Curie Breast Cancer Group. Am. J. Hum. Genet., 60: 1021-1030.
[8.] Claus, E.B., N. Risch and W.D. Thompson, 1991. Genetic analysis of breast cancer in the cancer and steroid hormone study. Am. J. Hum. Genet., 48: 232-242.
[9.] Easton, D.F., D.T. Bishop and D. Ford et al., 1993. Genetic linkage analysis in familial breast and ovarian cancer: results from 214 families. The Breast Cancer Linkage Consortium. Am. J. Hum. Genet., 52: 678-701.
[10.] Remontet, L., A. Buemi, M. Velten, E. Jougla and J. Esteve, 2003. Evolution de l'incidence et de la mortalite par cancer en France de 1978 a 2000. Edition : Aout 2003.
[11.] Bergfeldt, K., B. Rydh, F. Granath, H. Gronberg, L. Thalib and H.O. Adami et al., 2002. Risk of ovarian cancer in breast cancer patients with a family history of breast or ovarian cancer: A population based cohort study. Lancet, 360: 891-4.
[12.] Lorenzo, B.J. and K. Hemminki, 2004. Risk of cancer at sites other than the breast in Swedish families eligible for BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation testing. Ann. Oncol., 15: 1834-41.
(1) Youlia M. Kirova, (1) Alain Fourquet, (2) Alexia Savignoni, (4) Brigitte Sigal-Zafrani (3) Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet for the Institute Curie Breast Cancer Study Group
Departments of (1) Radiation Oncology, (2) Biostatistics, (3) Oncology Genetics, (4) Pathology Institut Curie, Paris, France
Corresponding Author: Youlia M. Kirova, M.D., Radiotherapy Department, Institut Curie, 26 Rue d'Ulm, 75248 Paris, Cedex 05, France, Tel: 331 44 32 46 37, Fax: 331 44 32 46 16
Table 1: Incidence rates of second non-breast malignancies in the control population compared to the incidence in the French women population; * Incidence rates for 100,000 persons-year, ** standardized by age France * Controls * SIR ** IC 95 % p Gynaecological 28 133.2 368.2 [74-1075.7] NS Ovarian 14.9 0 0 [0-846.5] NS Gastro- 77.8 0 0 [0-261.3] NS Intestinal Pulmonary 15.9 44.4 233.2 [3.1-1297.4] NS All 136.6 177.6 129.8 [34.9-332.4] NS Table 2: Incidence rates of second non-breast malignancies in BRCA1/2 non carriers compared to the incidence in the French women population; * Incidence rates for 100,000 persons-year, ** standardized by age France * BRCA 1/2 SIR ** IC 95 % p non carriers * Gynaecological 28 0 0 [0-1128.5] NS Ovarian 14.9 224.6 1155.7 [129.8-4172.6] <0.05 Gastro- 77.8 0 0 [0-639] NS Intestinal Pulmonary 15.9 0 0 [0-2130.5] NS All 136.6 224.6 241.1 [48.4-704.4] NS Table 3: Incidence rates of second non-breast malignancies in BRCA 1/2 carriers compared to the incidence in the French women population; * Incidence rates for 100,000 persons-year, ** standardized by age France * BRCA 1/2 carriers * Gynaecological 28 0 Ovarian 14.9 1764.7 Gastro-Intestinal 77.8 441.2 Pulmonary 15.9 0 All 136.6 2205.9 SIR ** IC 95 % p Gynaecological 0 [0-4768.3] NS Ovarian 9640.1 [2593.6-24680.6] <0.0001 Gastro-Intestinal 875.5 [11.44-4871] NS Pulmonary 0 [0-9294] NS All 1837.5 [592.1-4288] <0.0001
|Gale Copyright:||Copyright 2006 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.|