Postpartum amenorrhoea among Manipuri women: a survival analysis.
Among the three major components of a closed birth interval,
waiting time to conception can somehow be managed with effective
contraceptives while gestation is universally constant in its duration;
the duration of postpartum amenorrhoea (PPA) varies in complex nature.
The present study aimed to investigate the proximate factors influencing
the duration of PPA. A community-based, cross-sectional study was
conducted in four valley districts of Manipur, India, during 1 August-31
December 2009, to analyze the differentials and determinants of duration
of PPA, applying the survival analysis technique. In total, 1,225
ever-married women were selected through two-stage cluster sampling. The
median duration of PPA was 5.7 months. Among the 11 explanatory
variables of interest, only three variables--place of residence
(p<0.05), infant mortality from preceding pregnancy (p<0.01), and
duration of breastfeeding (p<0.01)-- had a significant effect on the
duration of PPA. The findings may be used as baseline information for
future researchers and maternal health policy-makers.
Key words: Breastfeeding; Community-based studies; Cross-sectional studies; Infant mortality; Parity; Postpartum amenorrhoea; India
Amenorrhea (Demographic aspects)
Middle aged women (Health aspects)
Middle aged women (Research)
Singh, N. Sanajaoba
Singh, N. Sharat
|Publication:||Name: Journal of Health Population and Nutrition Publisher: International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research Bangladesh Audience: Academic Format: Magazine/Journal Subject: Health Copyright: COPYRIGHT 2012 International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research Bangladesh ISSN: 1606-0997|
|Issue:||Date: March, 2012 Source Volume: 30 Source Issue: 1|
|Topic:||Event Code: 310 Science & research|
|Geographic:||Geographic Scope: India Geographic Code: 9INDI India|
The duration of postpartum amenorrhoea (PPA) is the length of time between the termination of pregnancy and the first successive ovulation following the pregnancy during the reproductive span of a woman. In other words, it is the temporary sterility immediately following the termination of pregnancy during which conception usually does not occur. The attainment of first menstruation after delivery is treated as the termination of PPA. Being a physiological process associated with each conception, the importance of PPA in regulating human fertility has been a matter of general interest for many years because it tends to increase the average birth interval, thereby reducing women's fertility over her life span, especially in societies where the use of contraceptive methods is not widespread. There is substantial evidence that long-term breastfeeding is associated with a longer anovulatory period leading to prolonged PPA. It also reduces fertility even after menses and ovulation have returned.
Prolonged lactation suppresses the production of certain types of hormones, thereby extending the postpartum anovulatory period. Moreover, there are different social norms, taboos, and other socioeconomic factors, especially in traditional societies, that reinforce the effect of breastfeeding. However, many mechanisms by which breastfeeding behaviour and other factors produce variability in the length of the anovulatory period and thus, in the resumption of menses across populations and within a population in different social and cultural groups remain either unspecified or unknown. They are probably associated with the biological characteristics and specific social structures and implicit or explicit social norms.
The anovulatory period depends on a number of other factors, which vary from woman to woman in a population (1,2). PPA is associated with age of mother, marital duration, nutritional status, and parity (3-7). In these studies, breastfeeding is also found to be associated with delayed return of menstrual cycles and ovulation, reduced fecundability, and long birth intervals. The most important conclusion is that long-term breastfeeding was statistically associated with a long period of PPA (6,8-11). In the mid-1970s, some pioneering studies also stressed that, at least at the aggregate level, when regressing the average durations of PPA on the average durations of breastfeeding, the two are significantly and positively related (12,13). However, in the absence of breastfeeding, the average amenorrhoeic period may last 1-3 months (11,12). Education and family income have been inversely related with the duration of PPA (7,10,13).
In the policy point of view, the present empirical study was conducted in Manipur, one of the northeastern states of India. The study was conducted to investigate the nature and pattern of duration of PPA and to check the relative influences of various sociodemographic factors on it. The findings may be of immense values, particularly in couple's reproductive management, population planning, and health policy through which an attempt may also be made to improve the sociodemographic status of women in Manipur. Besides, the work is of considerable importance from the academic and application points of view, and as such, it assumes great significance as baseline information of reproductive health.
This community-based, cross-sectional study was conducted in four valley districts of Manipur, namely Bishnupur, Thoubal, Imphal West, and Imphal East, during 1 August--31 December 2009 using the two-stage cluster-sampling technique, with 11 July as the reference date of survey. The study subject was defined to be an eligible woman having at least one livebirth. The pretested and semi-structural type of interview schedule was used as the tool for collecting the required information. The sample consisted of 1,225 eligible women. The sample-size was determined based on the findings of Sharat (14), i.e. the mean[+ or -]standard deviation (SD) of duration of closed birth interval is 21.05[+ or -]18.79, under 95% degree of precision, with 5% margin of error to the mean (14). Altogether, clusters of 45 rural villages and 35 clusters of urban wards were randomly selected, of which 5 villages and 7 wards, 9 villages and 10 wards, 11 villages and 12 wards, and 20 villages and 6 wards were, respectively, selected proportionally from Bishnupur, Thoubal, Imphal West, and Imphal East districts. Of the 1,225 eligible women, 180, 316, 387, and 342 were randomly picked up from the selected clusters of Bishnupur, Thoubal, Imphal West, and Imphal East districts respectively.
The duration of PPA was taken as the response variable. Since ovulation itself is difficult to identify, the reliable estimate of the end of amenorrhoea is the return of menstruation itself. In this study, the duration of PPA was estimated as an interval between the termination of conception and the return of first menses. Women reporting the termination of amenorrhea before the survey date were considered uncensored cases, and their duration of PPA was the interval between the termination of conception and the return of the first mense. On the other hand, women reporting continuance of amenorrhoea even after the survey date were considered censored cases, and their event history of interest was the interval between the termination of conception and the survey date. In the case of women having more than one livebirth, the duration variable, i.e. the duration of PPA for the last birth, was taken into consideration to control the data recall error.
The explanatory variables or so termed as covariates were demographic and socioeconomic factors. The socioeconomic variables included the place of residence, educational level, and family income. Under the demographic variables, duration of breastfeeding, age at marriage, sex of the previous child, parity and living status of the previous child, and use of contraceptive devices were considered. These variables were expected to cause the variation in the duration of PPA in view of the past findings. It was rather difficult to explore the effects of the explanatory variables in isolation owing to the fact that these were purely interdependent on one another. Here, the adopted tools had to quantify the possible effects of the variables after adjusting the effects of other variables under consideration.
Methods of analysis
As the study was confined in the censored data, survival analysis techniques were used for statistical analysis. The Log-rank test was employed to compare the survival experience between different groups under study. The Cox's proportional hazard model was used for determining the effects of breastfeeding variables and other demographic and socioeconomic factors on the duration of PPA. The simple form of the Cox's proportional hazard model was given by [lambda](t;x)=[lambda]0(t) exp ([beta]/,x), where [lambda]0(t) is the baseline hazard function and [beta] is a vector of unknown regression coefficients to be estimated (15). The ratio--[lambda] (t;x)/[lambda]0(t)=exp ([beta]/,x)--represents the 'relative risk' of failure or so termed as the risk of resumption of menstruation. Therefore, the hazard function enables one to estimate the relative risks of other groups in relation to the baseline group (reference group). When there is no covariate present in the model, exp ([beta]/, x) is unity. The results are expressed in terms of [beta]-coefficients, standard error (SE), p values, and relative risk (RR: e[beta]) with their 95% confidence interval (CI). The value of relative risk of a group of the study subjects greater than unity means that the risk of resumption of menstruation is higher for this group when compared with the reference group while values of less than one indicate that the risk is lower for the case group being analyzed when compared with the baseline group.
Table 1 shows the median durations of PPA according to the specific demographic and socioeconomic characteristics of the study women. The median duration of PPA in the study subjects was 5.7 months. The median duration of PPA increased with the increase in the duration of breastfeeding. By the Log-rank test, the association between the duration of breastfeeding and PPA was highly significant ([chi square]=41.439, p<0.01). A negative and strong association was found between the duration of PPA and the age at marriage of women (p<0.01). The median duration of PPA increased with the increase in parity, and this variation was highly significant (p<0.01) in the study subjects, irrespective of other covariates. The sex of the previous child did not influence PPA (p>0.05). The survival status of the previous child showed a strong effect on the duration of PPA (p<0.01). The longer duration of PPA was found with mothers who had an alive child (5.8 months) than who experienced a dead child (4.2 months). The duration of PPA for the couple who used contraceptive devices was significantly shorter than those who had never used any form of contraceptive devices (p<0.05). Non-users resumed menses six months after childbirth while users resumed menses after 5.3 months. The variation in the median duration of PPA according to educational level of couple was a downward linear trend, which was again highly significant (p<0.01).
To assess the partial effects of the explanatory variables on the duration of PPA while controlling for other covariates, multivariate proportional hazard model analysis was performed. The results are presented in Table 2. After the adjustment of other covariates under study, the duration of breastfeeding had a negative association with the risk of return to menses ([beta]=-0.015, p<0.01). In fact, for every one-month increase in the duration of breastfeeding, the risk of resumption of menses decreased by 1.5% (RR=0.985). The survival status of the previous child during infancy had a significant effect (p<0.01) on the duration of PPA. The risk of resumption of menses of women with the survival of the previous child was 0.58 times lower than those who experienced the death of the previous child during infancy (RR=0.584). Among the socioeconomic variables, the place of residence had a significant effect (p<0.05) on the risk to return of menstruation after controlling for all other explanatory variables. The rural women were found to be subject to a hazard of menstruation 0.835 lower than that of urban women (RR=0.835).
The findings showed that the median duration of PPA was 5.7 months. The findings also highlighted that the longer duration of breastfeeding was significantly associated with a lower risk of menstruation. This is due to the fact that prolonged lactation suppresses the production of certain types of hormones, thereby extending the postpartum anovulatory period. In fact, longer breastfeeding has suckling stimulation and proper prolactin secretion by the pituitary gland. Prolactin again suppresses gonadotropin (GnRH), which delays the secretion of follicle stimulation hormone (FSH) and Luteinizing hormone (LH), resulting in longer PPA. The results of this study are consistent with findings of studies in different countries (8-12, 16-18). The death of the index child during infancy was associated with the short duration of PPA, which is also consistent with findings of other studies (19,20). It may be possible that the death of a child during infancy cuts short the duration of nursing, which results in earlier resumption of menses and ovulation. The finding of the present study is also in the same direction.
The effects of age at marriage, parity, sex of the previous child, use of contraceptive devices, and parity were not at all significant. The place of residence had a significant relationship with the duration of PPA. The risk of resumption of menses for urban women was higher than rural women. The shorter duration of PPA among urban women was perhaps due to the fact that the educational level and employment status were higher among urban women than among rural women. In other words, the socioeconomic status of rural women was comparatively low due to their low level of education and employment. In contrast, most urban employed mothers did not get enough time to breastfeed their children as they work outside and, thus, tend to lactate for a shorter period and also probably provide food supplements to their children much earlier.
This finding is in agreement with findings of Srinivasan et al. (2), Aguirre et al. (6), and Aryal (7). Despite the importance of parity in the determination of the amenorrhoeic period, we found that this variable was not at all significant. It seems that its effect is absorbed totally by other related variables. This finding is contradictory with findings of other studies (3,7,10).
The findings of this interpretative study confirm that PPA is highly influenced by the duration of breastfeeding. Breastfeeding is again associated with other explanatory variables in many ways in the study subjects due to the diverse sociocultural and behavioural aspects. The policy-makers and planners, particularly maternal health planners are thus, suggested to promote breastfeeding practice and its associated factors to reduce fertility in the study subjects through prolonged birth intervals.
The factors--breastfeeding, infant mortality, and residence--were found to have their high impacts on the duration of PPA. Prolonged breastfeeding can delay the resumption of menses following a livebirth, leading to lengthening of the subsequent birth intervals to reduce total fertility to achieve the national goal of replacement fertility of 2.1. Death of infants cuts down the nursing period, resulting in early resumption of menses and ovulation. Besides, evidence of high risk of short PPA among urban women might have been associated with higher education and employment, which are again linked to reduce the breastfeeding period. Hence, population scientists and health planners are needed to improve the factors associated with the prolonged duration of breastfeeding so that the eligible mothers could extend the duration of PPA.
(1.) Bongaarts J, Potter RG. Fertility, biology and behavior: an analysis of the proximate determinants. 1st ed. New York, NY: Academic Press, 1983:36.
(2.) Srinivasan K, Pathak KB, Pandey A. Determinants of breastfeeding and post-partum amenorrhea in Orissa. J Biosoc Sci 1989;21:365-71.
(3.) Hajian-Tilaki KO. Factors affecting the patterns of postpartum amenorrhea. Ann Saudi Med 2002;22:404-7.
(4.) Delgado H, Martorell R, Brineman E, Klein RE. Nutritional, lactational, and birth interval components in rural Guatemala. Am J Clin Nutr 1982;31:1468-76.
(5.) Ford K, Kim Y. Distributions of post-partum amenorrhoea: some new evidence. Demography 1987;24:413 30.
(6.) Aguirre GP. The determinants of postpartum amenorrhea: a multi-state hazard approach. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin-Madison, 1996. 29 p. (Center for Demography and Ecology working paper no. 96-03).
(7.) Aryal TR. Differential of breastfeeding among rural women of western Nepal: a survival analysis. J Nepal Health Res Council 2005;3:58-64.
(8.) Pinto G, Palloni GA, Jones RE. Effects of lactation on post-partum amenorrhoea: re-estimation using data from a longitudinal study in Guatemala. Popul Stud 1998;52:231-48.
(9.) Aguirre GP, Jones RE. Breastfeeding and post-partum amenorrhea in rural Guatemala. Pollaciony Saluden Masoamerica 2005;3:1-18.
(10.) Pinto G. Breastfeeding and postpartum amenorrhea among Bolivian women: a survival analysis. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2005. 55 p. (Center for Demography and Ecology working paper no. 2005-01).
(11.) Yadava KNS, Jain SK. Post-partum amenorrhea in rural eastern Uttar Pradesh, India. J Biosoc Sci 1998;30:227-43.
(12.) Bongaarts J. The proximate determinants of natural marital fertility. In: Bulatao RA, Lec RD, editors. Determinants of fertility in developing countries. New York, NY: Academic Press, 1983:103-38.
(13.) Santow G. Reassessing the contraceptive effect of breastfeeding. Popul Stud 1987;41:147-60.
(14.) Sharat NS. A contribution to determinants of birth-interval and fertility of Manipur women: a case study of Imphal. Manipur: Manipur University, 2002:91. (PhD thesis).
(15.) Cox DR. Regression models and life tables. JR Stat Soc 1972;34:187-220.
(16.) Aryal TR. Retrospective reporting of the duration of post-partum amenorrhea: a survival analysis. Kathmandu Univ Med J 2006;4:211-7.
(17.) Jones RE. The effect of initiation of child supplementation on the resumption of postpartum menstruation. J Biosoc Sci 1990;22:173-89.B
(18.) McNeilly. Lactation control of reproduction. Reprod Fert Dev 2001;13:583-90.
(19.) Chakraborty N, Sharmin S, Islam MA. Differential pattern of birth interval in Bangladesh. Asia Pacific Popul J 1996;11:73-86.
(20.) Mturi AJ, Akim J. The determinants of birth interval among non-contracepting Tanzania women. Afr Popul Stud 1997;12:14-21.
N. Sanajaoba Singh , N. Sharat Singh , and R.K. Narendra 
 Directorate of Census Operations, Porompat, Manipur, India,  Thoubal College, Thoubal, Manipur, India, and  Unit of Biostatistics, Regional Institute of Medical Sciences, Imphal, India
Correspondence and reprint requests should be addressed to:
Dr. N. Sanajaoba Singh
Directorate of Census Operations
Porompat, Manipur 795 005
Table 1. Univariate analysis of duration of postpartum amenorrhoea Log-rank Median of PPA test Variable (months) ([chi square]) Demographic Duration (months) of breastfeeding <5 4.8 41.439, p<0.01 5-10 5.1 10-15 5.8 15-20 6.2 20-25 6.8 [greater than or equal to]25 8.4 Age (years) at marriage of wife <15 6.4 23.705, p<0.01 15-20 5.8 20-25 5.1 25-30 4.5 [greater than or equal to]30 4.3 Parity 0 4.3 23.068, p<0.01 1 5.1 2 5.8 3 6.4 4+ 6.9 Sex of previous child Female 5.1 0.334, p>0.05 Male 6.2 Survival status of previous child Death 4.2 8.340, p<0.01 Survival 5.8 Use of contraceptives No 6.0 5.453, p<0.05 Yes 5.3 Socioeconomic factors Place of residence Urban 5.2 5.612, p<0.05 Rural 6.0 Educational level of husband No schooling 6.9 Primary school 6.0 Seondary school 5.6 16.672, p<0.01 Higher seondary school 5.2 College and university 4.6 Educational level of wife No schooling 6.8 15.403, p<0.01 Primary school 6.1 Seondary school 5.7 Higher seondary school 5.5 College and university 4.9 Family income (Rs) <2,000 6.4 7.306, p<0.05 2,000-<4,000 6.0 4,000-<6,000 5.7 6,000-<8,000 5.3 8,000-<10,000 4.8 [greater than or equal to]10,000 4.3 Overall 5.7 PPA=Postpartum amenorrhoea Table 2. Cox's multivariate regression analysis of duration of postpartum amenorrhoea Coefficient Wald test Variable ([beta]) (p value) Demographic Duration (months) of breastfeeding -0.015 11.703, p<0.01 Age (years) at marriage of wife 0.011 1.588, p>0.05 Parity -0.027 2.393, p>0.05 Sex of previous child -0.003 0.003, p>0.05 Survival status of previous child -0.538 8.167, p<0.01 Use of contraceptives -0.008 0.011, p>0.05 Socioeconomic Place of residence -0.180 5.710, p<0.05 Educational level of husband 0.004 0.313, p>0.05 Educational level of wife -0.005 0.465, p>0.05 Family income (Rs) 0.000 0.727, p>0.05 Relative risk 95% CI for Variable (e[beta]) e[beta] Demographic Duration (months) of breastfeeding 0.985 0.976-0.994 Age (years) at marriage of wife 1.011 0.994-1.029 Parity 0.973 0.940-1.007 Sex of previous child 0.997 0.890-1.117 Survival status of previous child 0.584 0.390-0.845 Use of contraceptives 0.992 0.859-1.146 Socioeconomic Place of residence 0.835 0.721-0.968 Educational level of husband 1.004 0.989-1.019 Educational level of wife 0.995 0.980-1.010 Family income (Rs) 0.999 0.998-1.001 CI=Confidence interval
|Gale Copyright:||Copyright 2012 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.|